Made in New York Pizza Menu Overview
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Made In New York Pizza offers an authentic taste of classic New York-style pizza with a menu that celebrates tradition and bold flavors. Whether you're a local or a visitor craving a slice of the city's finest, this spot delivers an extensive selection of pies, fresh starters, delightful desserts, and refreshing drinks, all crafted with quality ingredients and genuine care.
Starters
Kick off your meal with fresh and vibrant starters that complement the pizza perfectly. Choose from the crisp and colorful House Salad, featuring mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, onions, and carrots, or the classic Caesar Salad with romaine lettuce, parmesan, crunchy croutons, and Caesar dressing. For a warm, garlicky indulgence, savor the Garlic Knots served with rich marinara sauce.
Mains
The star of the menu is the incredible range of pizzas, each boasting a perfect balance of dough, sauce, and cheese. Dive into the iconic Plain Cheese Pizza built on a classic dough base with tomato sauce and a generous layer of cheese. The Fresh Mozzarella Margherita Pizza brings together fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil for a fragrant and traditional experience.
For those seeking bold flavors, the Sausage & Jalapenos Pizza combines spicy sausage with fiery jalapenos and fresh mozzarella. Fans of chicken will appreciate both the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, loaded with tangy buffalo sauce and mozzarella, and the BBQ Chicken Pizza featuring smoky BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and tender chicken pieces. Vegetarians can indulge in the White Spinach Pizza, rich with ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan, and fresh spinach or opt for the Veggie Pizza, piled high with sautéed peppers, mushrooms, and onions.
Other unique offerings include the Vodka Pizza, featuring fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, and basil, the Margherita (Stracciatella) with California crushed tomato, stracciatella cheese, oregano, chopped basil, and extra virgin olive oil, and the Grandma Pizza, a more classic rendition with cheese and tomato sauce. Fans of robust and spicy flavors will enjoy the Spicy Pepperoni Pizza, and the Classic Sicilian Pizza delivers a hearty, thick crust with cheese and tomato sauce. The White Pie focuses on a blend of ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses, while the Eggplant Pizza offers a savory mix of eggplant, sauce, and cheese.
Desserts
Finish your meal on a sweet note with classic Italian-American desserts. The New York Cheesecake offers a creamy blend of cream cheese, sugar, eggs, and vanilla on a graham cracker crust. The Tiramisu features layers of ladyfingers, mascarpone, coffee, cocoa powder, and sugar for a rich and indulgent experience. Chocolate lovers will delight in the Chocolate Cheesecake, combining cream cheese and chocolate over a graham cracker base. For a traditional treat, try the Cannolis filled with ricotta, chocolate chips, cinnamon, and sugar in crisp cannoli shells.
Drinks
Stay refreshed with classic beverage options including refreshing Soda made with carbonated water and flavorful sugar-based flavorings, or simply hydrate with a chilled glass of Water.
Signature Specials
- Margherita (Stracciatella) - Featuring California crushed tomato, stracciatella cheese, oregano, basil, and extra virgin olive oil for a rich, fresh twist on the classic.
- Vodka Pizza - Combines fresh mozzarella with a creamy vodka sauce and fresh basil on a perfectly baked dough.
