[Section Heading]
Located on Amsterdam Avenue in the heart of Manhattan, Sugar and Plumm offers a vibrant American bistro experience infused with artisanal chocolates and baked goods. This colorful, dessert-inspired eatery serves up a thoughtfully curated menu featuring indulgent sweets alongside savory mains, perfect for satisfying any craving whether you're visiting with family or friends.
Starters and mains
Begin your meal with vibrant flavors and hearty options that showcase the best of American comfort food with an artisanal twist.
- Pulled Pork Waffle: House-smoked pulled pork layered over a fluffy waffle, drizzled with maple BBQ sauce and topped with tangy pickled onion slaw for a perfect blend of sweet and savory.
- Lemon Ricotta Pancakes: Light and fluffy pancakes infused with fresh lemon and creamy ricotta, served with a medley of fresh berries and a cloud of whipped cream.
- Short Rib Hash: Tender braised short ribs combined with crispy potatoes and onions, topped with fresh arugula and a perfectly fried egg for a deliciously robust dish.
Decadent desserts
Sugar and Plumm truly shines with its dessert selection, featuring innovative creations that mix classic favorites with inventive elements.
- Earthquake in a Fishbowl: An indulgent parfait featuring angel food cake, dark chocolate ganache, cheesecake, key lime pie, Brooklyn blackout cake, butterscotch pudding, and an assortment of vanilla, chocolate, and salted caramel ice creams topped with whipped cream.
- Waffle & Bacon Shake: A creamy blend of vanilla ice cream and Vermont maple syrup with candied bacon and a mini waffle, merging sweet and savory in a decadent shake.
- Cajeta Caramel Crepe: Delicate crepes filled with goat's milk caramel, topped with salted caramel ice cream and finished with whipped cream for a luscious treat.
- Macarons: A delicate assortment including pistachio, rosewater, banana-chocolate, and passion fruit flavors, perfect for a light, sweet bite.
- Almond Croissants: Buttery, flaky pastries filled with creamy almond paste, a perfect pairing with coffee or tea.
- Creme Brulee Cookies: Buttery vanilla cookies inspired by the classic dessert, offering a crisp texture with a rich, sweet flavor.
Beverages and specials
Complement your meal with beverages such as their signature boozy hot cocoa, a delightful blend of rich chocolate and whiskey, although it cools quickly, maintaining its sweet whiskey flavor. Keep an eye out for seasonal specials that often feature unique dessert and brunch offerings to surprise your palate.
Sugar and Plumm is a New York City gem where you can indulge in sweet and savory delights made from quality ingredients, all set within a lively, kid-friendly atmosphere that invites you to enjoy every bite.
