Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan's Upper West Side, Cheesy Pizza at 2640 Broadway invites pizza lovers and night owls alike to savor authentic New York-style slices that define the city's culinary charm. This classic pizzeria is famed for its generous cheese portions and a menu that extends beyond pizza to include tasty gyros, wings, calzones, and hearty heroes.
Step inside Cheesy Pizza to find one of the largest dining areas in the neighborhood, complete with air conditioning—perfect for group gatherings or a casual bite after a day exploring the city. The old-school vibes and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere that resonates with locals and visitors seeking a genuine New York pizza experience. While the space feels a bit unpolished, the charm lies in its straightforward, no-frills approach to great food and community spirit.
Known for its classic cheese slices, Cheesy Pizza also serves up a variety of other delights including wings, calzones, and gyros, making it a versatile stop whether you're craving a quick snack or a full meal. Vegetarian options are available, catering to diverse tastes. The pizzeria also offers ice cream for a sweet finish, and serves coffee and beer to complement your meal.
Cheesy Pizza operates daily from 10:00 AM until the early hours of 5:00 AM, making it an ideal spot for late-night cravings. You can dine in, where seating is ample and family-friendly, or choose takeout and delivery options through popular platforms like Uber Eats. Payment is flexible, accepting credit cards, debit cards, cash, and even NFC payments for convenience.
Reviews for Cheesy Pizza paint a mixed but lively picture. Many customers appreciate the generous cheese and classic New York style pizza served late into the night, praising the friendly service and nostalgic ambiance. However, some have experienced inconsistencies, such as stale slices or delivery issues, which have led to disappointment among a few patrons. Overall, this pizzeria remains a beloved neighborhood staple with a loyal following.
- What are the operating hours of Cheesy Pizza? Cheesy Pizza operates daily from 10:00 AM to 5:00 AM.
- Does Cheesy Pizza offer delivery services? Yes, Cheesy Pizza provides delivery services through platforms like Uber Eats.
- Is there seating available at Cheesy Pizza? Yes, Cheesy Pizza offers seating for dine-in customers.
- Are there vegetarian options available? Yes, Cheesy Pizza offers vegetarian-friendly options.
- Does Cheesy Pizza accept credit cards? Yes, Cheesy Pizza accepts credit cards, debit cards, and cash.
Located at 2640 Broadway in the vibrant Upper West Side of Manhattan, Cheesy Pizza has cultivated a dedicated local following for over two decades. Since opening its doors in 2000, this classic pizzeria has become synonymous with generous portions of cheese and a welcoming, old-school New York vibe. Its reputation for serving hearty, comforting slices has made it a beloved neighborhood staple.
Cheesy Pizza's journey began in the year 2000, marking the start of a local culinary tradition at its Broadway location. Throughout the 2000s, it steadily built its fan base, particularly gaining recognition in 2010 when it became famous for its late-night service. This made it a preferred destination for night owls seeking a satisfying, cheesy slice well after other places closed their doors.
Celebrating its 20th anniversary in 2020, Cheesy Pizza solidified its place as an enduring and cherished part of the Upper West Side community.
Cheesy Pizza is renowned not only for its iconic cheesy slices but also for its diverse menu including gyros, wings, calzones, and classic heroes. Its affordability and late-night hours make it a convenient spot for a casual meal or a quick bite after an evening out. The pizzeria’s atmosphere captures an old-school New York essence, adding to its charm and appeal among locals and visitors alike.
- Established in 2000 - Opening of Cheesy Pizza at 2640 Broadway, marking the start of a neighborhood favorite.
- Late-night pioneer in 2010 - Known for catering to night owls with extended hours, becoming a go-to late dining option.
- 20th anniversary in 2020 - Milestone celebration that highlighted its lasting connection with the neighborhood.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Cheesy Pizza is a quintessential New York pizzeria that captures the spirit of the city with its casual ambiance and delicious offerings. Open late, this hotspot is perfect for night owls craving a slice of classic pie or a hearty meal from their extensive menu, featuring not only pizza but also gyros, wings, calzones, and heroes.
- Late-night service
- Variety of pizza options
- Gluten-free options available
- Delivery and takeout services
- Casual ambiance
- Mixed reviews on customer service
- Some concerns about pricing
- Ambiance may not appeal to all
Cheesy Pizza is perfect for casual diners, families looking for a comforting meal after a busy day, and those seeking a late-night bite. With its ample seating and relaxed atmosphere, it appeals to groups of friends enjoying a night out, as well as families looking for a hearty dinner.
Before you head over, be aware that Cheesy Pizza does not take reservations, so expect a casual, walk-in dining experience. Also, while the late-night hours cater to those craving a slice at odd hours, the quality of ingredients can sometimes vary, as indicated by recent reviews. It's advisable to check the latest reviews for the freshest insights into the menu.
Cheesy Pizza stands as a staple of the Upper West Side for its classic offerings and late-night availability. While its reviews may be mixed, it remains a beloved spot for many locals and visitors alike. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a full meal, Cheesy Pizza reflects the charm of New York's pizza culture.
- Cheesy Pizza is open late, typically until 2 AM.
- Unfortunately, Cheesy Pizza does not offer outdoor seating.
- Yes, Cheesy Pizza does offer vegan options on their menu.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, make sure to stop by Cheesy Pizza for a genuine taste of New York. With its laid-back vibe and late-night availability, it's an experience you won't want to miss.
Nestled in the vibrant Upper West Side at 2640 Broadway, Cheesy Pizza offers a true taste of classic New York-style pizza in a setting that blends old-school charm with a casual neighborhood vibe. This beloved pizzeria is a go-to spot for locals and visitors seeking an authentic slice, available for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.
Cheesy Pizza’s extensive menu goes beyond just pizza. You can indulge in hearty gyros, crispy wings, savory calzones, and classic heroes. Whether you’re craving a cheap slice or a full meal, this spot accommodates a variety of tastes including vegetarian options. The welcoming indoor dining area is spacious, air-conditioned, and perfect for groups and families, making it a friendly spot to enjoy lunch or dinner.
- Delivery available - Order online to have your favorite pizza and dishes brought straight to your door with no extra cost.
- Takeout option - Prefer to pick up? Order online for quick and easy takeout whenever hunger strikes.
- Family-friendly environment - With a spacious dining area and amenities like restrooms, Cheesy Pizza welcomes families and groups for relaxed meals.
- Payment convenience - Accepts credit, debit cards, and NFC payments for a smooth transaction experience every time.
While some reviews mention fluctuations in pizza quality and freshness, many patrons appreciate the friendly service and the nostalgic, no-frills pizzeria atmosphere that Cheesy Pizza brings to the Upper West Side. It’s a spot where you can enjoy a quick bite, affordable slices, and a welcoming vibe that feels like a true neighborhood staple.
Open late into the night, Cheesy Pizza is your reliable go-to for satisfying cravings after a long day exploring Manhattan. Customers can find comfort in a menu designed to please a variety of tastes, with the added bonus of ice cream and wings for those looking to mix it up.
