Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 2039 1st Avenue, Five Star is a cozy, unpretentious pizzeria that draws locals and visitors alike with its flavorful Italian eats and quick service. This spot charms with a simple counter-service setup where you can enjoy classic and inventive pies, hearty sandwiches, and kid-friendly menu options in a relaxed environment. Whether you’re craving a loaded supreme slice or want to savor crispy chicken fingers with your fries, Five Star delivers a satisfying meal without the fuss.
Five Star excels in offering flavorful comfort food with a focus on quality ingredients and speedy delivery. This pizzeria is popular for its generous toppings and well-seasoned chicken fingers, which come with fries that many customers rave about. The staff is often praised for remembering repeat customers’ favorite orders, adding a personal touch to your dining experience. Prices are wallet-friendly, making it an excellent choice for casual lunches, family dinners, or late-night bites in New York City.
Five Star offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services, catering to a variety of preferences. Although the cozy space doesn’t have outdoor seating or live music, it welcomes families with children and provides a menu that appeals to younger diners. Payment via credit cards is accepted, making transactions easy. While it doesn’t serve alcoholic beverages like beer, wine, or cocktails, the focus here is on delicious food served promptly and with care.
- Dine-in, takeout, and delivery available for your convenience. Kid-friendly menu options make it a great spot for families.
- Accepts credit cards, but no valet parking or outdoor seating.
- No beer, wine, or cocktails; focus on quality food and beverages.
Guests appreciate the flavorful cheesesteaks and variety of pizzas at Five Star, often highlighting the friendly waitstaff and speedy delivery, even close to closing time. However, some reviewers note inconsistencies in customer service and occasional issues with order accuracy. While a few mention cleanliness concerns and service misses, many patrons enjoy the welcoming atmosphere and personalized touch that keeps them coming back. This mixed but overall positive sentiment reflects a neighborhood gem balancing quality food with room to improve service.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Monday to Thursday and Sunday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM; Friday and Saturday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM.
- Does Five Star offer delivery services? Yes, they offer delivery, takeout, and dine-in options.
- Is there parking available at the restaurant? Yes, there is parking available nearby for diners who wish to drive.
Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of East Harlem, New York, Five Star Cheesesteak and Pizza has been a beloved culinary landmark since its establishment in 2008. Over the last 16 years, this no-frills pizzeria has become synonymous with hearty, comforting eats that delight locals and visitors alike.
Starting as a humble spot focused on cheesesteaks, Five Star quickly earned a reputation for quality and flavor. By 2010, just two years after opening, the owners expanded their offerings to include a variety of pizzas alongside their renowned cheesesteaks, catering to diverse tastes and solidifying their place in the local dining scene.
In 2015, Five Star adapted to the changing dining landscape by introducing delivery and online ordering services, making their delicious cheesesteaks and pizzas more accessible than ever. This move not only enhanced convenience for customers but also expanded their reach within East Harlem and beyond.
The year 2020 marked a significant milestone as Five Star celebrated its 12th anniversary. The celebration featured special promotions that honored the loyal community supporting the establishment through the years, further cementing its place as an East Harlem institution.
Five Star’s enduring popularity stems from its commitment to delivering hearty, satisfying comfort food in a straightforward setting. Their menu, featuring classic pizzas piled with a variety of toppings and the iconic cheesesteaks, continues to attract food enthusiasts seeking authentic flavors in East Harlem.
- Established in 2008 as a local eatery serving East Harlem.
- Menu expanded in 2010 to include pizzas and cheesesteaks.
- Delivery and online ordering started in 2015 enhancing accessibility.
- 12th anniversary in 2020 celebrated with community promotions.
Located at 2039 1st Ave., New York, NY, Five Star is a narrow counter-service pizzeria that specializes in Italian eats, including pies and sandwiches. The establishment is known for its generous portions and flavorful options, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors alike. With multiple service options available, including dine-in, delivery, and takeout, it caters to a variety of dining preferences.
- Generous portions Flavorful options Multiple service options (delivery, takeout, dine-in)
- Inconsistent service Inconsistent food quality
Five Star is perfect for casual dining, family gatherings, or a quick meal on the go. Its diverse menu appeals to both children and adults, making it a family-friendly spot.
Five Star accepts credit cards and offers both takeout and delivery options. It's advisable to check for peak hours to avoid long wait times, especially during weekends.
Overall, Five Star offers a satisfying dining experience with its hearty portions and varied menu. While service may occasionally falter, the flavorful dishes and convenience of multiple dining options make it a worthwhile stop in Manhattan.
Five Star Pizzeria New York Experience Manhattans Classic Slice Spot 1st Avenue Upper East Side Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In New York City Eats Pizza Sandwiches Kid Friendly Affordable Authentic Italian Flavors Quick Service Family Atmosphere Authentic New York Pizza Five Star Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan New York NY 10029 USA Eat Local Foodie Favorite Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Family Friendly Five Star Pizza Location Manhattan City New York NY 10029 USA 2039 1st Avenue Upper East Side Pizza Sandwiches Affordable Dining Kid Friendly Customer Service Five Star Local Favorite Affordable Pizza Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Classic Italian Pizzeria New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Foodie Favorite Authentic Italian Flavors Cozy Friendly Atmosphere Comfort Food Quick Service 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan New York NY 10029 USA Five Star Pizzeria Location Manhattan City New York NY 10029 USA 2039 1st Avenue Upper East Side Pizza Sandwiches Affordable Dining Kid Friendly Customer Service Five Star Local Favorite Affordable Pizza Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Classic Italian Pizzeria New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Foodie Favorite Authentic Italian Flavors Cozy Friendly Atmosphere Comfort Food Quick Service 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan New York NY 10029 USA Five Star Pizzeria Location Manhattan City New York NY 10029 USA 2039 1st Avenue Upper East Side Pizza Sandwiches Affordable Dining Kid Friendly Customer Service Five Star Local Favorite Affordable Pizza Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Classic Italian Pizzeria New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Foodie Favorite Authentic Italian Flavors Cozy Friendly Atmosphere Comfort Food Quick Service 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan New York NY 10029 USA Five Star Pizzeria Location Manhattan City New York NY 10029 USA 2039 1st Avenue Upper East Side Pizza Sandwiches Affordable Dining Kid Friendly Customer Service Five Star Local Favorite Affordable Pizza Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Classic Italian Pizzeria New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Food Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Foodie Favorite Authentic Italian Flavors Cozy Friendly Atmosphere Comfort Food Quick Service New York City Five Star Pizzeria 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options Foodie Favorite Authentic Italian Cozy Friendly Atmosphere Comfort Food Quick Service
Discover Five Star: A Neighborhood Gem on 1st Avenue New York City Dining Spot for Families and Foodies Alike New York NY 10029 USA Manhattan's Affordable Italian Pizzeria Top Rated Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options in East Harlem Upper East Side Manhattan New York City 2039 1st Avenue Pizzeria Experience Classic New York Pizza and More Cozy Counter Service Family Friendly Atmosphere Authentic Italian Eats Great Value Affordable Dining Five Star Local Favorite Quick Friendly Service Dine-In Delivery Takeout New York City Food Scene Pizza Sandwiches Kid Friendly New York City Manhattan East Harlem Upper East Side 2039 1st Avenue New York NY 10029 USA Five Star Pizza and Italian Restaurant Neighborhood Treasure Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Foodie Favorite Affordable Pizza Counter Service Pizzeria Classic New York Style Pizza Sandwiches Cozy Friendly Service Family Friendly Takeout Delivery Dine-In New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Neighborhood Pizzeria Experience
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan's vibrant Upper East Side, Five Star is a go-to spot for locals craving authentic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian sandwiches. Located at 2039 1st Avenue, this narrow, counter-service pizzeria offers a cozy, no-frills atmosphere perfect for family dinners, casual meetups, and quick bites. What makes Five Star stand out is its commitment to delivering quality food with a welcoming vibe — whether you choose to dine in, take out, or get your meal delivered right to your doorstep.
Menu Highlights Five Star's Signature Flavors and Family Favorites Iconic New York Pizza and Hearty Italian Sandwiches Fresh Ingredients Local Favorite Kid Friendly Options 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Five Star Quick Service Dine-In Takeout Delivery Foodie Hotspot Manhattan's Upper East Side Pizza Sandwiches Family Friendly Affordable Dining New York City 2039 1st Avenue
Five Star's menu is a delightful blend of classic New York pizza slices — from simple cheese to supreme toppings — and satisfying Italian sandwiches that pack flavor and freshness. Customers rave about the chicken fingers and fries, calling them a perfect pairing for a comforting meal. Affordable pricing makes it easy for families and food lovers on a budget to enjoy a hearty bite, while kid-friendly options ensure even the youngest guests leave happy. Whether you're stopping by for lunch or dinner, the menu's variety and quality keep guests coming back.
Convenient Dining Options Delivery Takeout and Cozy Dine-In Experience at Five Star New York City 2039 1st Avenue Manhattan NY 10029 USA Fast Friendly Service Family Friendly Pizzeria Local Favorite Affordable Dining Five Star Delivery Takeout Dine-In Options
Five Star makes it effortlessly easy to enjoy their delicious offerings however you prefer. Opt for delivery to have your favorite slice or sandwich brought straight to your home, perfect for busy New Yorkers craving quick comfort food. If you're on the go, takeout is a breeze, so you can enjoy your meal wherever you like. Of course, the cozy dine-in option invites you to soak in the friendly atmosphere and enjoy your meal fresh and hot. The staff are known to remember returning customers’ favorite orders, creating a welcoming neighborhood feel that keeps you coming back.
Why Choose Five Star Your Go-To Pizzeria in Manhattan East Harlem Upper East Side New York City 2039 1st Avenue Family Friendly Affordable Delivery Takeout Dine-In Local Favorite Authentic Italian Flavors Quality Service Cozy Atmosphere Quick Service
- Affordable Pricing — enjoy authentic New York slices and Italian eats without breaking the bank.
- Family Friendly — kid-friendly menu items and a welcoming environment for all ages.
- Multiple Dining Options — dine in the cozy space, grab takeout, or get delivery straight to your door.
- Friendly Service — staff often remember guests’ favorite orders, making each visit personal and warm.
