Tucked away at 218 West 35th Street, My Belly's Playlist is a must-visit gem for food lovers craving creative sandwiches and fresh salads in Manhattan. This spot is celebrated for its inventive menu that changes regularly, keeping your taste buds excited with new flavor combinations crafted from high-quality ingredients. Whether you're stopping by for lunch or dinner, the cozy, art-filled ambiance provides a welcoming retreat from the city's hustle, making every visit feel like a special discovery.
My Belly's Playlist shines not only with dine-in options but also through its convenient takeout and delivery services, perfect for busy New Yorkers or digital nomads looking for quick yet satisfying meals. Known especially for their standout sandwiches like the belly burger and the chicken sandwich, each order comes with a complimentary chocolate chip cookie — a sweet signature touch that delights customers every time.
The café also offers rich espresso crafted from #forfive beans sourced locally from Brooklyn, enhancing the authentic New York experience. While the entrance might be a bit discreet—located in the basement of a hotel and accessed through a maze of hallways—the reward is a vibrant and artistic space with impressive platters and a warm atmosphere that invites you to linger, even if seating is limited.
Positive customer feedback highlights the inventive menu and friendly service. Visitors appreciate the intimate atmosphere and the sense of discovery that comes with finding this hidden spot. The combination of creative culinary offerings and a unique location makes My Belly's Playlist a cherished part of the local food scene.
- Is My Belly's Playlist currently open? As of May 2025, My Belly's Playlist is open and operating at 218 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001.
- What are the operating hours of My Belly's Playlist? The restaurant operates Monday through Friday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and on weekends from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
- Does My Belly's Playlist offer delivery and takeout services? Yes, My Belly's Playlist offers both delivery and takeout services for their menu items.
- Is there parking available at My Belly's Playlist? Parking availability may vary; it's recommended to check with the restaurant directly for the most current information.
My Belly's Playlist, located at 218 W 35th St, New York, NY, has carved a unique niche in the bustling New York City food scene since its inception. This beloved spot started as a humble delivery-only sandwich shop in 2012, focusing on crafting creative and flavorful sandwiches, salads, and sides. Over the years, it has transformed into a cozy establishment offering dine-in services, allowing patrons to enjoy its vibrant atmosphere.
The journey of My Belly's Playlist can be summarized through significant milestones that reflect its growth and adaptation to the evolving culinary landscape of New York City.
- 2012: My Belly's Playlist started as a delivery-only sandwich shop in Lower Manhattan.
- 2017: The restaurant found a storefront location in the Financial District, offering dine-in services.
- 2025: As of May 2025, My Belly's Playlist continues to operate at 218 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001.
The restaurant is renowned for its unique approach to everyday ingredients. By using freshly baked breads from local bakeries and responsibly sourced vegetables and meats, My Belly's Playlist has successfully created a menu that resonates with food enthusiasts looking for quality and creativity.
As My Belly's Playlist continues to evolve, its commitment to excellence and community engagement remains steadfast. With an ever-changing menu filled with creative sandwiches, soups, and salads, patrons can expect delightful surprises that keep them coming back for more. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite to eat or looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a meal, My Belly's Playlist promises a memorable culinary experience.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 218 W 35th St, My Belly's Playlist serves as a culinary haven for sandwich enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Known for its creative and flavorful offerings, this eatery is a must-visit for those seeking a unique dining experience in New York City. With a menu that changes frequently, My Belly's Playlist keeps guests returning to discover new sandwich combinations and fresh ingredients.
- Creative and flavorful dishes
- Unique sandwich combinations
- Fresh ingredients
- Positive reviews for 'Rancher' sandwich and 'Belly's Cobb Salad'
- Longer wait times for delivery orders
My Belly's Playlist is perfect for lunch breaks, casual dinners, or even late-night cravings. With hearty sandwiches and delightful salads, it caters to foodies and busy professionals looking for quick, satisfying meals. The vibrant atmosphere and eye-catching decor make it an inviting spot for friends and families alike.
Be prepared for a unique access experience, as My Belly's Playlist is located in the basement of the Renaissance Hotel. Look for the door next to Planet Fitness and follow the signs. While the space isn't designed for extended dining, the efficiency of takeout makes it worth the visit. Expect delicious options with a rotating menu, and don’t miss out on the signature chocolate chip cookies offered with orders.
My Belly's Playlist offers a delightful culinary experience, blending creativity with high-quality ingredients. Whether you're grabbing lunch on the go or indulging in a leisurely dinner, this hidden gem promises satisfying flavors that will leave a lasting impression. Don't miss out on this unique dining adventure in the bustling streets of Manhattan.
- What are the hours of operation ? My Belly's Playlist is open for lunch and dinner service, but hours may vary. It's advisable to check their social media for updates.
- Can I order for delivery ? Yes, they offer delivery and takeout options for your convenience.
Tucked away at 218 West 35th Street in the heart of Manhattan, My Belly's Playlist is a true culinary treasure for food lovers seeking innovative and flavorful sandwiches. This spot expertly blends artistry with taste, crafting creative sandwiches that have earned devoted fans across New York City. Whether you're craving a hearty lunch or a satisfying dinner, their ever-changing menu offers a fresh take on classic favorites with imaginative twists that brighten up your palate.
Famed for its inventive sandwiches, My Belly's Playlist delivers mouthwatering options that combine quality ingredients with bold flavors. Customers rave about their signature creations like the Belly Burger, a perfect balance of juicy meat and fresh toppings. Each order includes a complimentary chocolate chip cookie — a beloved sweet treat that keeps guests coming back. Beyond sandwiches, you can also enjoy hearty soups and crisp salads that complement the menu’s variety.
My Belly's Playlist offers both dine-in and convenient takeout or delivery options, catering to diverse lifestyles and schedules. The restaurant’s interior features cool artwork and stylish decor that create an inviting ambiance despite its basement location inside the Renaissance Hotel building. While the spot is somewhat hidden and access involves a bit of exploration, the vibrant atmosphere and attentive service make every visit memorable.
This hidden gem stands out not only for its flavorful offerings but also for the delightful extras that enhance the experience. The free cookies, the use of premium Brooklyn-roasted espresso beans, and the friendly vibe all contribute to its popularity. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite between meetings or indulging in a casual lunch with friends, My Belly’s Playlist delivers quality and creativity that keep locals and visitors talking.
- Creative sandwiches crafted with fresh, bold ingredients to excite your taste buds.
- Complimentary chocolate chip cookies that add a sweet finish to your meal and keep guests smiling.
- Dine-in, takeout, and delivery options for maximum flexibility to fit your busy NYC lifestyle.
- Art-filled, cozy interior offering a unique and inviting atmosphere despite its underground location.
