Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan, Oath Pizza was a standout destination for pizza lovers seeking a fresh, health-conscious twist on a classic favorite. Known for its hand-stretched dough grilled and seared in avocado oil, this unique pizza joint combined ethical sourcing with seasonal inspiration to craft pies bursting with natural flavors and creativity. Whether you were craving a fully customized pizza loaded with farm-fresh toppings or a daring dessert pizza, Oath Pizza delivered an experience that was both satisfying and innovative.
What set Oath Pizza apart was its commitment to quality and customization. Guests could select from a variety of toppings and even personalize their pizzas to suit dietary preferences. The menu ranged from tried-and-true favorites to inventive options like the spicy chicken or Bahn mi pizza, each crafted with fresh, responsibly sourced ingredients. Vegan and gluten-free choices—including a Banza® Chickpea Crust and vegan cheese—ensured that everyone could find their perfect slice.
The signature cookie pizza was a delightful dessert option that left many patrons wanting more, often paired with unique soda selections that harkened back to classic times while embracing modern tastes. The friendly and attentive staff, including notable team members like Maria and Jose, added to the welcoming atmosphere, making Oath Pizza a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
Oath Pizza garnered a mixed yet generally positive reception from its community. Many patrons praised the fresh ingredients, unique crust, and the ability to customize orders extensively. The casual, friendly vibe and speedy service were often highlighted as strong points, while some reviews noted occasional inconsistencies in food quality and service. Overall, its blend of health-consciousness and flavor innovation made it a memorable destination in New York's bustling food scene.
- Is Oath Pizza still open? As of May 2025, Oath Pizza at 1142 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10065, is permanently closed.
- What are the operating hours of Oath Pizza? Before closing, Oath Pizza operated from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Monday through Saturday, and 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on Sundays.
- Does Oath Pizza offer gluten-free options? Yes, Oath Pizza offered gluten-free options, including a Banza® Chickpea Crust.
- Is Oath Pizza vegan-friendly? Yes, Oath Pizza provided vegan options, including vegan cheese and a variety of vegetable toppings.
- Does Oath Pizza offer delivery and takeout? Yes, Oath Pizza offered both delivery and takeout services.
Founded in 2015 on picturesque Nantucket Island, Oath Pizza quickly distinguished itself as a craft pizza brand committed to fresh, innovative flavors and health-conscious ingredients. Its signature feature was a crust made with avocado oil, offering a unique twist on traditional pizza dough that delighted food enthusiasts seeking something both vibrant and wholesome.
In pursuit of sharing their artisanal pies with a wider audience, Oath Pizza launched a branch in New York City, located at 1142 3rd Avenue in Manhattan's vibrant Upper East Side. This location became a hotspot for both locals and visitors, offering an inviting atmosphere where guests could customize their pizzas with an array of fresh and seasonal toppings. The menu was inclusive, featuring vegan and gluten-free options that accommodated diverse dietary preferences, while maintaining the brand's dedication to ethically sourced ingredients.
Hand-stretched dough grilled and seared in avocado oil formed the foundation of Oath Pizza's distinct flavor profile. Customers enjoyed the freedom to personalize their meals, with options ranging from spicy chicken to unique creations like the Bahn Mi flavor. A standout delight was their dessert cookie pizza, offering a sweet finish that perfectly complemented the fresh, savory offerings.
- Ethically sourced, seasonally inspired ingredients ensuring vibrant, fresh flavors in every bite.
- Customization options allowed patrons to craft their perfect pizza experience.
- Menu inclusivity with vegan and gluten-free choices to suit all palates.
After nearly a decade of serving up distinctive artisan pizzas, the New York City location of Oath Pizza closed permanently in March 2024. While its physical presence has ended, Oath Pizza remains remembered for its dedication to fresh, customizable cuisine and its innovative use of avocado oil crusts. This legacy continues to influence modern pizzerias and health-conscious diners seeking flavorful alternatives in urban settings.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Oath Pizza is revolutionizing the New York City pizza scene. This vibrant eatery at 1142 3rd Ave invites pizza lovers to indulge in handcrafted pizzas that prioritize fresh, ethically sourced ingredients. The moment you step inside, the casual, upbeat atmosphere greets you, making it an ideal spot for everything from a quick lunch to a leisurely dinner. With a focus on customization, Oath Pizza allows diners to create their perfect pizza, ensuring a personalized experience for every palate.
- Unique crust that is hand-stretched and grilled
- Customizable toppings for a personalized experience
- Vegan and gluten-free options available
- Quick service with friendly staff
- Inconsistent service reported by some guests
- Variations in food quality on different visits
- Limited seating during peak hours
- No cash payments accepted
Oath Pizza is perfect for families looking for a quick meal, friends wanting to catch up over a unique dining experience, or anyone craving a healthy twist on their pizza. The customizable menu caters to various dietary preferences, making it an inviting option for vegans and gluten-free diners alike.
Guests should be aware that the restaurant does not accept cash, so bringing a card is essential. While the ambiance is casual, seating can be limited during peak hours, so consider visiting during off-peak times or opting for takeout to enjoy Oath Pizza's delicious offerings at your convenience.
Oath Pizza stands out as a must-visit for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike in New York City. With its emphasis on fresh ingredients, customizable options, and welcoming staff, it creates a unique dining atmosphere. Whether you opt for a traditional topping or venture into something more adventurous like their dessert pizza, Oath Pizza promises a delightful experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 1142 3rd Avenue, Oath Pizza offers a tantalizing escape for pizza lovers craving a fresh, flavorful twist on classic New York-style pies. This vibrant spot combines quality ingredients with innovative cooking methods, delivering hand-stretched, thin crust pizzas seared in avocado oil that promise a healthier yet delicious experience. Known for its unique dough and ethically sourced toppings, Oath Pizza attracts locals and visitors eager for customizable options and seasonal inspirations. Healthy, fresh, and vibrant flavors come together here, with toppings sourced straight from the farm, ensuring a clean and satisfying meal every time. Whether you prefer crafting your own pie from a myriad of fresh ingredients or choosing from expertly tailored menu items, Oath Pizza has something to excite every palate.
Oath Pizza’s menu stands out with a range that includes everything from classic favorites to innovative creations. Among the standout choices is the spicy chicken pizza, revered for its perfect balance of heat and savory notes. The Bahn Mi pizza adds an exciting fusion twist, layering bold flavors inspired by Vietnamese street food onto a crisp crust. For those with dietary preferences, vegan and gluten-free dough options ensure everyone can enjoy a satisfying slice. Don’t miss the dessert cookie pizza, a delightful sweet treat that perfectly caps off your meal, combining the unexpected but irresistible pairing of cheese and chocolate.
Step inside Oath Pizza and you’ll immediately feel the welcoming vibe radiating from the hard-working and friendly team members. The open counter design fosters a sense of connection, making the experience feel personal and inviting. Whether dining in, picking up your order, or opting for delivery, expect quick and attentive service that enhances your visit. A unique soda machine offers an array of beverage choices that blend nostalgia with modern convenience, perfectly complementing your meal.
- Hand-stretched dough grilled and seared in avocado oil for a crisp, healthier crust.
- Ethically sourced, seasonal ingredients ensuring fresh and sustainable pizzas.
- Fully customizable pizzas with options to mix and match toppings or choose from signature combinations.
- Vegan and gluten-free choices catering to a variety of dietary needs.
- Friendly, attentive staff making every visit warm and memorable.
