Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan at 26c Macombs Place, Pizza by Lucille’s is a local favorite that brings a slice of joy to New York’s thriving pizza scene. Known for its generous portions and eclectic menu, this spot has something for everyone—from crispy, cheesy classics to inventive vegan pies. Whether you’re a dedicated foodie, a local looking for a go-to spot, or a digital nomad craving a hearty lunch, Lucille’s delivers a friendly atmosphere and quality flavors that resonate beyond just a meal.
Lucille’s prides itself on its distinctive dough, made fresh daily to balance that perfect crisp exterior with a soft, pillowy interior. The menu offers a wide variety of options — from the spicy, tangy supreme square pizza with well-done crunchy edges to creative vegan-friendly pies like the Veggie Pesto Square, ensuring all tastes are pleased. The garlic knots and hearty meatball pizza add to the rich New York-style pizza experience. Plus, it’s perfectly situated just steps from Yankee Stadium, making it a beloved pre-game destination.
Feedback from visitors paints a generally positive picture. Many praise the crispy crust and flavorful toppings, especially highlighting the variety on offer including vegan options. The friendly service and hearty portions earn frequent commendation, reinforcing the spot as a neighborhood gem. Some customers have noted room for improvement in seasoning and dough texture on certain pies, reflecting a desire for the restaurant to keep refining its craft. Seating is limited, so many opt for takeout or delivery via Uber Eats and Postmates, enjoying the convenience without sacrificing quality.
- What are the operating hours of Pizza by Lucille's? Monday to Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 9:45 PM; Thursday to Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:45 PM; Sunday: 11:00 AM - 9:45 PM.
- Does Pizza by Lucille's offer delivery services? Yes, delivery is available through Uber Eats and Postmates.
- Is there seating available for dine-in? Yes, limited seating is available for dine-in customers.
- Are vegan options available on the menu? Yes, Pizza by Lucille's offers vegan-friendly options, including the Veggie Pesto Square.
- Is Pizza by Lucille's pet-friendly? Yes, the restaurant is pet-friendly.
Nestled at 26C Macombs Place in the vibrant heart of East Harlem, New York City, Pizza by Lucille's has become synonymous with authentic New York-style pizza since it opened its doors in 2018. This beloved pizzeria quickly carved out a niche for itself with its signature crispy crusts and generous toppings that capture the essence of classic New York pizza making. Its convenient location near Yankee Stadium has made it a popular gathering spot for both locals and visitors eager to enjoy a flavorful pre-game meal.
After its launch in 2018, Pizza by Lucille's garnered widespread acclaim for delivering pizzas that impressed with a perfect balance of crunch and softness in the dough, coupled with vibrant, well-seasoned toppings. Its commitment to quality quickly built a loyal customer base in East Harlem and beyond.
By 2020, recognizing a growing demand for inclusive dining options, the restaurant expanded its menu to include vegan-friendly pizzas. This move was celebrated by many, as it broadened the appeal of their authentic offerings to a wider audience seeking plant-based alternatives without compromising on flavor.
In 2022, Pizza by Lucille's became a popular pre-game destination for fans heading to Yankee Stadium, offering a satisfying and authentic slice of New York pizza culture. Its reputation as a go-to spot for game day meals added another layer to its identity as a community hub and culinary landmark in East Harlem.
In 2024, the establishment broadened its culinary offerings by introducing a variety of starters and desserts, elevating the overall dining experience. This thoughtful expansion caters to a diverse clientele looking for more than just pizza, making Pizza by Lucille's a versatile and welcoming destination for all occasions.
- 2018: Pizza by Lucille's opened its doors in East Harlem, quickly gaining popularity for its authentic New York-style pizza.
- 2020: The restaurant introduced vegan-friendly options to cater to a broader audience.
- 2022: Pizza by Lucille's became a popular pre-game destination for fans visiting Yankee Stadium.
- 2024: The establishment expanded its menu to include a variety of starters and desserts, enhancing its dining experience.
Located at 26c Macombs Place in Manhattan, Pizza by Lucille’s is a popular spot for pizza lovers, especially those heading to nearby Yankee Stadium. Known for its delicious offerings and a friendly atmosphere, this establishment serves a variety of pizzas, including vegan options. While it has garnered a mix of reviews, it remains a go-to for locals and visitors alike.
With a focus on quality ingredients and a casual dining experience, Pizza by Lucille’s aims to satisfy both traditional and adventurous palates.
The restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, making it accessible for various dining preferences.
Overall, Pizza by Lucille’s is a notable addition to the Harlem food scene, offering a blend of traditional and innovative pizza options.
The ambiance is casual and welcoming, making it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
As a pre-game spot for Yankee Stadium, it attracts sports fans looking for a quick bite before the game.
The restaurant also offers a selection of vegan-friendly options, catering to diverse dietary preferences.
While the pizzas are generally praised for their crispy crusts and generous toppings, some reviews indicate inconsistencies in flavor and quality.
The restaurant's limited seating can be a drawback, especially during peak hours, and it does not accept reservations.
Additionally, the absence of alcohol on-site may deter some diners looking for a complete dining experience.
However, the friendly and accommodating staff often make up for these shortcomings, enhancing the overall experience.
In summary, Pizza by Lucille’s offers a casual dining experience with a focus on quality pizza, making it a worthwhile stop in Harlem.
Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a meal with friends, this restaurant has something for everyone.
Pros
• Delicious pizzas with crispy crusts and generous toppings
• Vegan-friendly options available
• Proximity to Yankee Stadium makes it a popular pre-game spot
• Offers delivery, takeout, and limited dine-in options
• Friendly and accommodating staff
Cons
• Limited seating for dine-in customers
• Some patrons note that the dine-in space is limited
• No reservations accepted
• No alcohol served on-site
• No online ordering through the restaurant's website
Ideal for
• Casual dining with friends and family
• Pre-game meals before events at Yankee Stadium
• Quick takeout for busy days
Things to know before visiting
• Expect limited seating, especially during peak hours
• No reservations are accepted, so plan accordingly
• The restaurant does not serve alcohol
• Parking is available on the street
Overall impression
Pizza by Lucille’s is a solid choice for pizza enthusiasts looking for a casual dining experience in Harlem.
While there are some areas for improvement, the combination of tasty pizzas and a welcoming atmosphere makes it worth a visit.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Pizza by Lucille’s is a delightful stop for a slice.
Nestled at 26c Macombs Place in the heart of Manhattan's Harlem, Pizza by Lucille’s offers a delightful slice of New York pizza culture with a unique twist. Popular among locals and visitors alike, this establishment serves up an array of flavorful pies, appealing to true foodies and casual pizza lovers searching for authentic New York-style pizza experiences.
The menu boasts a variety of pizzas including classics like pepperoni with a signature cup-style topping that offers a spicy, tangy, and cheesy delight with perfectly crunchy edges. Fans of bold flavors rave about the supreme square pizza, a satisfying choice that packs a punch without overwhelming your palate.
Vegetarian and vegan guests will be pleased to find options such as artichoke pizza and a deliciously crafted grandma pizza. For meat lovers, the meatball pizza features moist and spicy toppings that promise a tasty bite, although some suggest a touch more seasoning to elevate the experience.
Pizza by Lucille’s invites you to enjoy your meal with limited dine-in seating available, perfect for cozy gatherings or casual lunches and dinners. If you’re on the go, takeout orders are welcomed and can be placed directly at the restaurant, ideal for those craving a quick, quality meal.
For convenience, delivery service is offered through popular platforms like Uber Eats and Postmates, bringing your favorite pizza right to your doorstep. The spot is family-friendly with menu options suitable for children, and also caters to vegetarian diets, ensuring a broad appeal for all tastes.
- Delivery options via Uber Eats and Postmates for ultimate convenience.
- Takeout available with orders placed directly at the restaurant.
- Dine-in experience with limited seating for a comfortable meal.
Located in New York City's culturally rich Harlem neighborhood, Pizza by Lucille’s is accessible with free street parking nearby and accepts a variety of payment options including credit, debit, and contactless NFC payments. It's a pet-friendly spot, welcoming your furry companions as you enjoy your meal.
Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, this pizzeria offers a full spectrum of options including desserts and coffee, making it an ideal stop for any time of the day. Whether you’re craving a quick bite, a family meal, or a vegan-friendly pizza night, Pizza by Lucille’s delivers on taste and convenience in the heart of Manhattan.
Pizza by Lucille’s stands out as a neighborhood gem where traditional New York pizza style meets a diverse menu that caters to a range of dietary preferences. Its combination of dine-in comfort, takeout flexibility, and delivery convenience make it a top choice for locals and visitors exploring Harlem's culinary landscape.
Experience authentic pizza craft with a menu designed to satisfy bold flavor seekers and health-conscious diners alike. From vegan options that rival traditional pies to meat-laden favorites, Pizza by Lucille’s invites you to taste the rich diversity of New York’s pizza scene in one welcoming spot.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with menu options for children.
- Accepts contactless payment options for modern convenience.
- Pet-friendly venue inviting guests to bring their dogs.
