Overview of the menu
Situated at 53 Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, Butter & Scotch is a whimsical café and bakery known for its creative desserts and inviting atmosphere. This women-owned establishment has garnered attention for its unique blend of sweet and spirited offerings, first gaining popularity at the Smorgasburg food market. The culinary philosophy celebrates indulgence and creativity, emphasizing handmade desserts crafted from quality ingredients.
Signature dishes
- Bourbon Ginger Pecan Pie - A rich dessert combining pecans, bourbon, and ginger, all in a buttery crust.
- S'mores Pie - Featuring a graham cracker crust filled with chocolate custard and topped with fluffy marshmallow meringue.
- Negroni Pie - A delightful blend of Campari, gin, and vermouth whipped into a velvety dessert.
- Sticky Toffee Trifle - Layers of caramel-date cake, butterscotch pudding, and whipped cream.
Beverages and pairings
The beverage menu at Butter & Scotch complements the sweet offerings beautifully. Signature cocktails like the Honeychile Rider, made with gin, passion fruit, and lemon juice, offer a refreshing twist. Each drink is crafted to enhance the dessert experience, making it a haven for those looking for a delightful pairing.
Dietary options
Butter & Scotch caters to various dietary preferences, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their offerings. Vegetarian options abound, and many desserts can be adapted to vegan or gluten-free requests, accommodating a diverse clientele.
Chef recommendations
Seasonal highlights include the Bourbon Ginger Pecan Pie and the S'mores Pie, both of which are crowd favorites. The chefs encourage guests to try the rotating special, which often features unique flavor combinations that embody the spirit of the season.
Experience the menu
For a truly delightful experience, visit Butter & Scotch in Brooklyn, where the menu is designed to spark joy and satisfy sweet cravings. Whether you're indulging in a slice of pie or sipping on a creative cocktail, every visit promises a memorable experience.






