Nestled on the vibrant corner of 90 E 10th St in New York City, Penny is redefining seafood dining with its fresh, inventive menu and sleek bar-style setting. Known for its carefully curated selection of ocean delights, this spot thrills food lovers who crave exceptional quality and artistic presentation. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Penny promises an intimate, stylish experience that seafood aficionados and trend-conscious diners will adore.
At Penny, every dish is a celebration of the sea’s bounty—meticulously prepared with no filler, just pure flavor. Regulars rave about the Ice Box, a show-stopping platter of fresh raw seafood featuring tender lobster and shrimp cocktail, perfect for sharing. The sesame brioche topped with anchovies delivers a rich, buttery bite that melts in your mouth, while the dressed razor clams offer a perfectly seasoned, savory experience.
Don’t miss the stuffed squid, a fan favorite that’s tender and flavorful, or indulge in the unique Ice Cream Sandwich dessert, a sweet finish that perfectly balances the meal. The menu’s seafood focus means portions are crafted for savoring multiple dishes, making it ideal for adventurous palates who want to explore a variety of tastes.
Penny’s vibe is both stylish and inviting. The bar and counter seating create a lively yet intimate atmosphere perfect for date nights or small groups. Diners frequently praise the attentive and knowledgeable staff who elevate the experience by providing helpful recommendations and friendly service.
Ambient lighting and unique table lamps add a warm glow that highlights the artful plating of each dish, making every visit feel special. It’s no surprise that Penny is quickly becoming a beloved hotspot among New Yorkers seeking fresh seafood with a sophisticated edge.
- Operating hours: Penny welcomes guests Monday through Saturday from 5:00 PM to 10:30 PM and is closed on Sundays.
- Seating and group size: The restaurant offers mostly bar and counter seating, making it ideal for intimate dinners or small groups but less suited for large parties.
- Reservations: While Penny accepts a limited number of reservations, many seats are available on a first-come, first-served basis. Arriving early is recommended to secure your spot.
Penny stands out in New York City’s competitive dining scene thanks to its unwavering commitment to fresh seafood, artistic culinary craftsmanship, and a welcoming yet sophisticated atmosphere. Diners consistently praise the combination of top-tier dishes like the lobster and stuffed squid, alongside attentive service and a chic ambiance that makes each meal memorable.
Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or craving a sophisticated seafood night out, Penny delivers a dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.
Nestled in the vibrant East Village at 90 E 10th Street, Penny emerged onto New York City's dynamic dining scene in March 2024. Founded by the innovative duo Joshua Pinsky and Chase Sinzer, Penny offers an immersive seafood dining experience that captures the essence of contemporary urban eating. As the sister restaurant to the acclaimed Claud located just below, Penny continues the legacy of culinary excellence, crafting dishes that celebrate the ocean's bounty with creative flair and meticulous attention to detail.
Launching in early 2024, Penny quickly caught the attention of food enthusiasts and critics alike. Its distinctive approach to seafood, focusing on freshness and innovative presentation, set it apart in a competitive New York dining landscape. Within the same year, Penny secured a coveted spot on The New York Times’ prestigious list of 50 favorite American restaurants, a remarkable feat for a newcomer. This accolade highlights Penny’s commitment to quality and places it among the most exciting culinary destinations in the United States.
Penny’s allure lies in its focused menu that emphasizes pure, high-quality seafood without unnecessary fillers. Known for signature dishes like dressed razor clams, brioche with anchovies, and tender lobster preparations, the restaurant delivers a sophisticated yet approachable atmosphere. The intimate bar seating enhances the social dining experience, making it a favorite spot for date nights and special occasions. Exceptional service, a carefully curated wine list – including standout Portuguese whites – and an inviting ambiance with soft lighting complete the package.
- Exclusive menu highlights: Ice Box, stuffed squid, and confit oysters offer unique seafood tastes.
- Atmosphere: Cozy and chic with intimate bar seating that encourages connection.
- Critical acclaim: Recognized by The New York Times as a standout American seafood restaurant in 2024.
Penny operates as an exclusively dinner venue, focusing on delivering an elevated seafood experience when it matters most. Reservations are highly recommended due to limited seating and the restaurant's growing popularity. Guests can expect a refined yet relaxed service style, with staff knowledgeable about both the menu and wine pairings. Although the portions lean towards tasting sizes to highlight the quality and variety of dishes, diners often find the selection deeply satisfying and perfect for sharing.
Nestled in the heart of New York City, Penny is a seafood restaurant that captivates with its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional culinary offerings. Known for its intimate bar seating and open kitchen concept, this modern eatery brings you fresh, high-quality seafood in an inviting setting. From the savory stuffed squid to the delectable ice cream sandwich, Penny promises a memorable dining experience that highlights the best of maritime cuisine.
- Fresh and high-quality seafood offerings
- Attentive and friendly service
- Vibrant and welcoming atmosphere
- Unique and creative menu items
- Intimate bar seating with open kitchen concept
- Limited seating with primarily bar-style seating
- Higher price point compared to some competitors
- Limited vegetarian options
- Potential wait times during peak hours
Penny is perfect for seafood enthusiasts and couples looking for a romantic yet casual dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, this spot will impress with its innovative dishes and warm ambiance.
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak dining hours. Be aware that many of the standout dishes sell out quickly, so arriving early is advisable. The menu focuses primarily on seafood, with few vegetarian options, making it essential for diners to choose wisely.
Overall, Penny offers a unique and intimate dining experience for seafood lovers. While it comes with a higher price tag, the quality and creativity found in each dish make it worth a visit. If you're looking for a place that combines exceptional food with a lively atmosphere, Penny is undoubtedly a must-try.
- Penny is open for dinner service, typically from 5 pm onwards.
- While there's no strict dress code, most patrons tend to dress smartly.
- Yes, Penny has a delightful selection of desserts, including a highly praised ice cream sandwich.
- Penny is more suited for adults, with a focus on seafood dishes that may not cater to children.
Experience the taste of the sea at Penny, where culinary excellence meets a delightful atmosphere. Make your reservation today and immerse yourself in a seafood dining adventure like no other.
Nestled in the vibrant heart of New York City, Penny offers a refined yet inviting seafood dining experience that foodies and city explorers will adore. This spot is celebrated for its creative menu that showcases the ocean's best, featuring everything from a dazzling raw bar to expertly prepared cooked seafood dishes. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or a curious diner seeking a fresh taste adventure, Penny stands out as a must-visit culinary gem.
At Penny, every dish is crafted with precision and passion. Start your culinary journey with their famed Seafood Raw Bar , featuring a tantalizing variety of fresh oysters, clams, and other shellfish served raw to highlight their natural briny flavors. For those craving something warm and satisfying, the Cooked Seafood Dishes like Stuffed Squid and Oyster Pan Roast are sure to impress with their bold flavors and masterful techniques. Complement your meal with Penny's extensive Wine Selection , which includes both classic vintages and innovative finds, perfect for pairing with any dish.
Penny's atmosphere is a perfect blend of sleek and cozy, with intimate bar seating that creates a lively yet relaxed vibe. The carefully curated lighting and décor elevate every dining experience, making it an ideal spot for a romantic night out or a chic evening with friends. Attentive and knowledgeable staff ensure your visit flows smoothly—from helpful menu recommendations to timely service—enhancing your enjoyment of each exquisite bite.
- Reservations are essential especially if you want to enjoy dinner later in the evening, as popular dishes sell out fast.
- Come with an appetite as Penny's menu focuses purely on seafood without many filler options, so ordering a variety of dishes ensures a satisfying meal.
- Indulge in dessert like their famed ice cream sandwich to complete your sophisticated seafood soirée.
Penny’s dedication to fresh, high-quality seafood paired with an adventurous menu and stellar wine list positions it as a standout in New York’s competitive dining scene. Reviewers consistently praise the impeccable taste, artistic presentation, and the sophisticated yet approachable atmosphere. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or seeking an exceptional everyday meal, Penny delivers a memorable seafood experience that will keep you coming back.
