Totonno's Menu Overview Brooklyn NY Coney Island Pizza Classic Italian Coal Oven Neapolitan Style Food Drink Specials Dining Experience Authentic Local Flavor
Nestled in the heart of Coney Island, Totonno's is a legendary pizzeria that has been delighting Brooklyn locals and visitors since 1924. Known for its timeless approach to authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, this historic spot features a coal-fired oven that infuses every pie with a distinctive smoky char and crispy thin crust. Using imported Italian tomatoes and freshly made local mozzarella, Totonno's crafts pizzas that celebrate tradition and genuine flavor.
Starters and Appetizers
Although Totonno's menu mainly showcases their signature pizzas, guests can anticipate a warm and inviting atmosphere that gets the appetite going. For those eager to start the meal, the classic White Pie makes for an excellent choice as an appetizer-style delight. Topped with creamy mozzarella, fragrant garlic, and extra virgin olive oil, it provides a rich, savory introduction.
Mains - Classic Pizza Selections
The star of Totonno's menu is undeniably their classic pizza pies baked to perfection in their signature coal-fired oven. The Plain Pie is a must-try, featuring a minimalistic yet bold combination of rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. It’s a pure expression of authentic New York-style pizza, showcasing the perfect balance of chewy crust, tangy sauce, and creamy cheese.
- Plain Pie: tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese on a thin, crispy crust.
- White Pie: a garlic-infused delight with mozzarella cheese and olive oil, offering a creamy, savory flavor without tomato sauce.
Desserts and Drinks
While Totonno's does not feature a dedicated dessert menu, the robust flavors of their pizzas make a sweet finish unnecessary for many guests. Complementing the flavors of the pies, beverages include a refined selection of beer and wine, perfect for pairing with the smoky, cheesy goodness. This makes Totonno's an ideal spot to savor classic New York pizza alongside your favorite drinks in a casual setting.
Specials and Experience
Totonno's stands as a culinary landmark, prized for its *timeless* pizza recipes and coal-fired cooking method that has been cherished by generations. Although the venue offers limited dine-in options and no table service currently, the takeaway experience allows visitors to connect with a piece of Brooklyn pizza history. The ambiance is immersed in nostalgia, making every order a trip into a rich tradition of authentic Italian-American flavors.
