Discover Paulie Gee's: Brooklyn's Gourmet Pizza Haven

Name: Paulie Gee's
Address: 60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, USA, New York, 11222, US
Telephone: (347) 987-3748
Price range: $$

Nestled in the vibrant Greenpoint neighborhood of Brooklyn, Paulie Gee's offers a distinctive pizza experience that captivates locals and visitors alike. This gourmet pizzeria is renowned for its wood-fired pies topped with unusual, locally sourced ingredients , blending creativity with authentic flavors. Whether you're a foodie searching for the ultimate New York pizza or a trend-savvy traveler looking for a cozy hangout, Paulie Gee's delivers with passion and style.

A Cozy Nightlife Spot with Exceptional Pizza Choices

Step inside Paulie Gee’s and immerse yourself in a warm, rustic atmosphere filled with low lighting and curated local art that enhances the intimate vibe. The welcoming staff ensures attentive service, making it a great spot for casual dinners or late-night outings with friends. The menu features standout pizzas such as the famed Hellboy, which combines bold flavors with a perfect balance of hot honey drizzle that customers keep raving about.

What Makes Paulie Gee's Unique?

Paulie Gee's commitment to quality is evident in their inventive use of ingredients and dedication to catering to diverse dietary preferences. Vegan diners will appreciate the excellent dairy-free cheese options like Numu and Follow Your Heart, making it a top pick for plant-based pizza lovers. The pizzeria also serves delicious brunch, lunch, dinner, and cocktails, creating a full dining experience beyond just pizza.

Vegan options are plentiful : including innovative cheese alternatives.
Cozy, rustic ambiance : perfect for date nights or gatherings with friends.
Craft cocktails and beer : enhancing the dining experience.
Late hours and live music : great for a night out in Brooklyn.

Community Sentiment and Visitor Insights

Paulie Gee's enjoys a predominantly positive reputation within the community. Guests frequently praise the fresh, flavorful pizzas and the helpful, friendly service. The nostalgic pizzeria vibe makes it a beloved spot for both casual hangouts and special occasions. While some patrons note that pizza prices are on the higher side and wait times can be long during busy hours, many agree that the quality of food and atmosphere make it worth the visit. Families and groups feel welcomed, and the range of vegan and gluten-free options has expanded its appeal significantly.

Frequently Asked Questions about Paulie Gee's

Does Paulie Gee's accept reservations? Yes, Paulie Gee's accepts reservations.
Are there vegan options available? Yes, Paulie Gee's offers a variety of vegan pizzas and desserts.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes, limited outdoor seating is available.
Does Paulie Gee's offer takeout and delivery? Yes, takeout and delivery are available through their website and third-party services.
Is there a wait time during peak hours? Yes, wait times can be long during peak hours; it's advisable to arrive early or make a reservation.

History of Paulie Gee's Pizzeria in Brooklyn's Greenpoint Neighborhood.

Paulie Gee's has become a beloved institution since its establishment in 2010 in the vibrant Greenpoint neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York. Known for its artisanal wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas, this pizzeria quickly gained a reputation for bold, creative toppings crafted from locally sourced ingredients, setting it apart in the competitive New York pizza scene.

Early Years and Growth

Opening its doors in 2010, Paulie Gee's embraced the culinary culture of Brooklyn, quickly becoming a hotspot for pizza lovers who crave both quality and originality. By 2014, the pizzeria made a strategic decision to discontinue take-out services to enhance its dine-in experience — allowing guests to fully enjoy the cozy atmosphere and wood-fired flavors that define its offerings.

Expanding the Paulie Gee's Experience

In 2018, Paulie Gee's introduced the Slice Shop — a loving homage to New York City's iconic slice shops. This concept brought a casual, quick-serve option to fans of the brand, featuring classic slices alongside Paulie Gee's signature inventive toppings. The Slice Shop helped broaden the pizzeria's appeal, making its gourmet pizzas accessible to a wider audience looking for a taste of authentic New York-style pizza.

Fast-forward to 2024, Paulie Gee's has expanded beyond Brooklyn with new locations in Chicago, Baltimore, and Columbus. This growth demonstrates the brand’s successful fusion of traditional Neapolitan techniques with modern, innovative toppings — captivating pizza enthusiasts across multiple cities.

Why Paulie Gee's Stands Out

What sets Paulie Gee's apart is its commitment to quality and creativity. The pizzeria's wood-fired ovens deliver authentic Neapolitan crusts with perfect texture and flavor. Its locally sourced, unusual toppings create a gourmet pizza experience that remains true to tradition while inviting culinary exploration.

Established 2010 - Paulie Gee's originally opened in Brooklyn's Greenpoint, setting the stage for a new era of artisanal pizza.
2014 Transition - Shift away from takeout to focus on a superior dine-in experience.
2018 Slice Shop Opening - Launch of a new outlet honoring classic NYC pizza slice culture.
2024 Expansion - New locations in Chicago, Baltimore, and Columbus broaden the Paulie Gee's footprint beyond Brooklyn.