San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina Menu Overview New York NY USA Upper East Side Authentic Italian Dining Experience Gourmet Wood Fired Pizzas Pasta Specials Vegetarian Options Cocktails Desserts Outdoor Seating Group Friendly Reservation Recommended Relaxed Atmosphere Outstanding Service Fresh Ingredients Italian Classics Local Favorite 2nd Avenue Manhattan 10028 Culinary Delights Starters Mains Desserts Drinks Specials
Nestled in the vibrant Upper East Side of Manhattan, San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina delivers an authentic Italian dining journey characterized by gourmet wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta dishes, and a welcoming rustic ambiance. This beloved neighborhood spot is ideal for food enthusiasts seeking traditional flavors crafted with the highest quality ingredients, alongside a selection of inventive specials that keep the menu exciting. Whether dining solo, celebrating with friends, or accommodating larger groups, guests enjoy attentive service and a lively yet cozy atmosphere enhanced by plentiful natural light and optional outdoor seating.
Starters to Awaken Your Palate
San Matteo’s starters are a celebration of classic Italian antipasti with vibrant flavors and thoughtfully sourced ingredients. Marvel at the Margherita pizza featuring rich tomato sauce, homemade mozzarella, and fresh basil—a timeless opener. For lovers of bold tastes, the Napoletana offers garlic, oregano, and basil infused tomato sauce, while the Marinara enriches that with black olives, capers, and Sicilian anchovies for a salty, savory punch. The Regina Margherita combines buffalo mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, and Parmigiano Reggiano, elevating the traditional Margherita with creamy and tangy notes.
- Diavola - Homemade mozzarella, spicy salami, cherry tomatoes, Parmigiano Reggiano, and basil blend heat and creaminess perfectly.
- Capricciosa - A rustic combination of homemade mozzarella, mushrooms, black olives, Parma ham, and fresh basil.
- Burrata & Prosciutto - Creamy mozzarella center with arugula, Castelvetrano olives, cherry tomatoes, and Prosciutto di Parma for a rich starter.
Mains Crafted With Passion
The main courses at San Matteo exhibit mastery in blending tradition with fresh ingredients. Signature pizza options range from the cheese-laden Quattro Formaggi, featuring homemade mozzarella, gorgonzola, Swiss Emmental, and provolone, to the earthy Patate e Porcini with potatoes, porcini mushrooms, Parmigiano Reggiano, and mozzarella. Truffle lovers will relish the Porcini e Tartufo, a harmonious mix of mushrooms, truffle oil, and creamy mozzarella. For those seeking something lighter, salads like the Insalata di Spinaci with fresh pears, walnuts, and pecorino cheese offer refreshing balance.
- Tartufata - Featuring truffle pâte, prosciutto di Parma, Parmigiano Reggiano, basil, and homemade mozzarella for an indulgent flavor.
- Cacio e Pepe - A classic Italian pasta elevation with dry cured pancetta, Cacio Cavallo cheese, and freshly cracked black pepper.
- Salsiccia e Friarelli - Homemade mozzarella topped with savory sausage and bitter broccoli rabe for a robust taste.
Desserts And Drinks To Savor
Complement your meal with San Matteo’s assortment of coffee and dessert offerings. The classic tiramisu provides a satisfying finish with its smooth layers of mascarpone and espresso-soaked ladyfingers. Pair your meal with expertly crafted cocktails, a curated selection of Italian wines, or freshly brewed espresso to complete the authentic Italian dining experience in a snug yet lively setting.
Chef’s Specials And Seasonal Highlights
San Matteo regularly features specials that showcase the freshest seasonal ingredients with creative Italian twists. Past guests rave about unique pizza specials like those with fresh ricotta and honey, and fresh pasta dishes that highlight bold, vibrant flavors. The specials menu offers a perfect opportunity to explore beyond classic offerings and discover the kitchen’s inventive spirit.
Why Choose San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina
Authenticity shines throughout the menu, from the wood-fired crusts to the carefully selected cheeses and cured meats.
Quality ingredients sourced locally and imported from Italy ensure every bite bursts with genuine flavor.
Welcoming atmosphere with ample seating options, including outdoor sidewalk dining, makes it an ideal spot for all occasions.
Menu variety caters to diverse tastes with vegetarian options and specialties that delight seasoned pizza aficionados and newcomers alike.
Experience the taste of Italy at San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina where the perfect combination of artisan craftsmanship, fresh ingredients, and inviting ambiance awaits. Reservation is recommended to enjoy a memorable meal in this Upper East Side gem known for its consistently outstanding Italian classics and spirited specials.
