Nestled at 546 Myrtlewood Drive in picturesque Calimesa, California, New York Pizzeria serves up a delightful taste of traditional New York-style pizza right in Riverside County. This casual local favorite is known for its brick-oven-fired pies that boast a crispy crust and fresh toppings, creating an irresistible pizza experience for both residents and visitors alike.
Beyond their signature pizzas, New York Pizzeria offers a variety of Italian classics including soups, sandwiches, pastas, and delicious sides like potato wedges. Patrons appreciate the friendly staff and the vibrant atmosphere, enhanced by the fun arcade located conveniently next door—a perfect spot for families and groups looking for entertainment alongside their meal.
Enjoy a full-service experience with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, alongside amenities like wheelchair accessibility, free parking, and a kid-friendly menu.
- Crispy thin-crust pizzas made to order in a brick oven.
- Family-friendly environment with kids’ menu and arcade next door.
- Flexible dining options including takeout, delivery, and dine-in with reservations.
- Affordable parking and easy access with free on-site and street parking.
The community has shared a range of opinions about New York Pizzeria, making the sentiment mixed but overall engaged. Many diners rave about the crispy, flavorful pizza and appreciate the quick service and friendly staff. The location’s proximity to the arcade adds a lively touch that families find enjoyable.
However, some customers have pointed out areas for improvement, such as occasional inconsistencies in pizza preparation and the casual, no-frills seating arrangements that encourage a fast-eat-and-go mindset. Despite these critiques, many consider New York Pizzeria a worthwhile destination for authentic New York-style pizza in Calimesa.
- Does New York Pizzeria offer delivery? Yes, New York Pizzeria provides delivery services to local areas.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, the restaurant offers outdoor seating for customers.
- Are reservations accepted? Yes, New York Pizzeria accepts reservations for dine-in customers.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible, including the entrance, parking lot, and restroom.
- Does New York Pizzeria offer catering services? Yes, they offer catering services for events and parties.
Established in 1990, New York Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of Calimesa's culinary scene for over 27 years. This beloved eatery quickly became popular for serving authentic New York-style pizza, delighting locals and visitors with its perfectly crisp, brick-oven-fired pies.
From its inception, the pizzeria demonstrated a strong commitment to quality, utilizing fresh ingredients and crafting their pizza dough daily. This dedication was further highlighted in 1998 when New York Pizzeria introduced homemade lasagna alongside their freshly made dough, expanding their Italian menu offerings.
As the years progressed, New York Pizzeria evolved to meet the diverse tastes of its clientele. In 2005, the menu was expanded to include a variety of subs and classic Italian dishes, making it a versatile dining destination for families and food enthusiasts alike.
The expansion of services continued with catering offerings introduced in 2010, allowing the restaurant to play a significant role in local events and celebrations. This addition emphasized their role not just as a dining spot but as a community hub for gatherings and special occasions.
In 2015, to adapt to changing consumer needs, New York Pizzeria introduced delivery and takeout options, enhancing convenience for their patrons. These services, combined with their well-loved dine-in experience, have solidified the pizzeria as a go-to spot in Calimesa for quality Italian cuisine.
Throughout its history, New York Pizzeria has maintained a reputation for excellent customer service and an inviting atmosphere. Whether indulging in a classic pepperoni pizza or enjoying one of their hearty Italian subs, guests appreciate the authentic flavors and warm hospitality that have defined this establishment for nearly three decades.
- 1990: New York Pizzeria opened its doors in Calimesa, CA.
- 1998: Addition of homemade lasagna and fresh pizza dough made daily.
- 2005: Menu expanded to include a variety of subs and Italian dishes.
- 2010: Began offering catering services for local events.
- 2015: Added delivery and takeout options for customer convenience.
Located at 546 Myrtlewood Dr, Calimesa, CA, New York Pizzeria offers a casual dining experience with a menu featuring authentic New York-style pizza, sandwiches, and pasta dishes. This family-friendly establishment is known for its brick-oven-fired pies and fresh ingredients, making it a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Fresh ingredients
- Friendly service
- Family-friendly atmosphere
- Variety of menu options
- Inconsistent food quality
- Limited seating capacity
- Some cleanliness concerns
- Occasional service delays
New York Pizzeria is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, pizza lovers craving authentic flavors, and groups seeking a laid-back atmosphere to enjoy a meal together.
Be prepared for a casual dining experience where you order at the counter. While the pizza is delicious, some reviews mention inconsistent food quality and occasional service delays. It's advisable to check for seating availability during peak hours.
New York Pizzeria stands out for its authentic pizza and friendly service, making it a beloved spot in Calimesa. While there are some areas for improvement, the overall experience is enjoyable for those seeking a hearty meal in a relaxed setting.
Nestled at 546 Myrtlewood Drive in the heart of Calimesa, New York Pizzeria offers a flavorful escape for pizza lovers and foodies alike. Known for its brick-oven-fired pies, this casual chain pizzeria brings authentic New York-style pizza to Riverside County with a menu that also features hearty soups, classic sandwiches, and savory pastas. Whether you're craving a delicious pepperoni slice or a vegetarian delight, this spot caters to diverse tastes in a relaxed, welcoming environment.
At New York Pizzeria, each pizza is crafted with care, boasting a crispy crust that customers rave about. The potato wedges make a perfect sidekick to the pies, complementing the flavors with their golden crunch. The restaurant embraces a casual counter-service style, where you place your order and pick it up quickly, perfect for those looking to enjoy a fast yet satisfying meal. While the seating is functional with paper plates and plastic utensils, the focus remains on delivering quality food that hits the spot every time.
- Dine-in Offers a casual dine-in experience perfect for groups and families looking to enjoy a laid-back meal.
- Takeout and Delivery Convenient takeout and delivery options ensure you can enjoy their tasty menu wherever you are in Calimesa.
- Catering Services Perfect for parties and events, their catering brings crowd-pleasing pizza and Italian favorites to your special occasion.
This pizzeria stands out not just for its mouthwatering pizzas but also for its strategic location next to a lively arcade, making it a great spot for families and groups looking to combine delicious food with fun entertainment. Guests appreciate the quick service, friendly staff, and menu variety that includes vegetarian options and kid-friendly meals. Ample free parking with both lot and street options makes visits hassle-free, while payment methods include contactless NFC, debit, and credit cards for modern convenience.
- Family-friendly environment with suitable menu options and seating arrangements.
- Beer and wine served enhancing the dining experience for adults.
- Accessible restrooms and free parking add to the overall convenience of your visit.
