Dicey’s Pizza & Tavern Menu Overview
Nestled in Chicago’s vibrant West Town neighborhood, Dicey’s Pizza & Tavern offers a delightful menu featuring authentic tavern-style pizzas, fresh starters, and hearty sandwiches. Whether you're craving a thin, cracker-style crust or inventive toppings, this local gem satisfies pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike with a bold blend of flavors and quality ingredients.
Starters
Begin your meal with Dicey’s fresh and flavorful starters. The Little Gem Salad features crisp little gem lettuce accented with radishes and cucumbers dressed lightly for a refreshing bite. For those who love bold dips, the Giardiniera Dip combines tangy giardiniera with Parmesan and cream cheese, served alongside crunchy kettle chips — a perfect shareable starter. Spice lovers can indulge in their classic Buffalo Wings tossed in zesty buffalo sauce. Don't miss the crispy Tater Tots, a simple yet satisfying snack to pair with any dish.
Mains
The heart of Dicey’s menu is its diverse selection of tavern-style pizzas, each crafted with care and distinctive toppings. The Peppy Boy pizza layers Old World pepperoni with hot honey, mozzarella, Parmesan, wild oregano, tomato sauce, and a drizzle of Calabrian chili oil for a tantalizing sweet-and-spicy experience. For a classic meat and pickle embrace, the Sausage and Giardiniera pizza pairs savory sausage with the signature spicy giardiniera.
Cheese aficionados will appreciate the Cacio e Pepe pie, boasting fresh mozzarella, creamy Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, and cracked black pepper — a rich and peppery delight. The Calabrian Vodka pizza offers a unique blend of vodka sauce, provolone, Calabrian chili, roasted red pepper, Parmesan, and fresh basil, delivering layers of smoky heat and herbaceous freshness.
For vegetable lovers, the Veggie Supreme is loaded with tomato sauce, roasted peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, mozzarella, and Parmesan — a colorful and robust vegetarian option. Meanwhile, the Earth Crisis pizza showcases tomato sauce, eggplant, roasted onions, chili flakes, basil, lemon, and olive oil, combining smoky, bright, and spicy notes in every slice. Additionally, Dicey’s serves an Italian Submarine sandwich with Italian meats, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and sub roll — perfect for a flavorful handheld meal.
Drinks and Specials
Dicey’s complements its menu with a solid selection of beers and cocktails. Guests frequently enjoy starting with a classic Negroni before settling into an Old Style beer alongside their pizza. The friendly tavern atmosphere and curated drinks list elevate the dining experience, ensuring there’s something for every palate to savor.
- Fan favorite pizzas include the spicy-sweet Peppy Boy and the savory Sausage and Giardiniera.
- Fresh starters like the Giardiniera Dip and Tater Tots prepare your palate perfectly.
- Vegetarian options such as Veggie Supreme and Earth Crisis pizzas deliver bold flavors without compromise.
