Terry's Pizza has been a cherished name in Huntsville, Alabama, since its establishment in 1959. For decades, it served up signature pizzas like the Sticky Fingers Special, Chef’s Special, Bavarian Pizza, and Maui Wowee, delighting locals and visitors alike with authentic Italian flavors. This family-friendly restaurant was known not only for its hearty dishes but also for its welcoming atmosphere, making it a popular spot for lunch and dinner. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, plus menu choices catering to vegetarians and children, Terry's Pizza was a versatile choice for many.
Despite its long-standing reputation, recent customer reviews reveal a more complicated story. Patrons have expressed frustration over long waits during the Saturday pizza buffet, limited selection, and inconsistencies in food quality — including reports of burnt crusts and undercooked dough. Some reviews mention a need for management improvements and express disappointment with the overall buffet experience. However, there remain loyal fans who praise specific menu items and continue to enjoy Terry's Pizza’s unique offerings, emphasizing personal taste preferences in the community.
Although Terry's Pizza closed its doors in September 2024, its legacy lives on through convenient take-and-bake products. Fans and newcomers can still enjoy Terry's flavors by visiting Star Market locations in Huntsville and Meridianville, as well as Reeves Drug Store in Pulaski, Tennessee, where these frozen pizzas are available. This allows pizza lovers to bring a taste of the iconic establishment into their homes with ease.
- Is Terry's Pizza still open? No, Terry's Pizza closed its doors in September 2024.
- Where can I find Terry's Pizza products now? Terry's Pizza products are available as take-and-bake options at Star Market locations in Huntsville and Meridianville, as well as at Reeves Drug Store in Pulaski, Tennessee.
- What are the signature pizzas at Terry's Pizza? Signature pizzas include the Sticky Fingers Special, Chef’s Special, Bavarian Pizza, and Maui Wowee.
- When did Terry's Pizza first open? Terry's Pizza was established in 1959.
- Who owns Terry's Pizza now? The rights and recipes were acquired by Star Super Market Owner, Darden Heritage, after the original owner's passing in 2005.
The community's feeling towards Terry's Pizza is mixed. While some fondly recall the classic recipes and enjoyed the atmosphere, others have voiced concerns about food quality and service in recent years. Despite these divided opinions, Terry's Pizza remains an important part of Huntsville's culinary history, with many memories tied to its iconic pies and family-friendly dining experience. Its continued presence through take-and-bake products ensures that the spirit of Terry’s Pizza still flavors local tables.
- Dine-in, takeout, and delivery options catered to various customer preferences.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with children’s menu options making it ideal for local families.
- Signature pizzas with unique regional favorites like the Bavarian Pizza and Maui Wowee.
- Convenient parking and payment options with free parking lot and acceptance of debit cards and NFC payments.
Since its founding in 1959, Terry's Pizza has been a cornerstone of Huntsville's culinary scene, renowned for its signature pizzas and authentic Italian specialties. For over four decades, locals cherished this family-owned pizzeria as a go-to destination for comforting, handcrafted pies that captured the spirit of traditional Italian cooking.
The original owner, Lou Pejza, was the heart and soul behind Terry's Pizza. His passing in 2005 marked the beginning of a challenging period for the beloved establishment. Just a year later, in 2006, the family made the difficult decision to close the doors, ending nearly 50 years of continuous service to the Huntsville community.
Terry's Pizza might have closed, but its spirit lived on, sparking a revival over a decade later.
In 2018, Darden Heritage acquired the recipes and rights to Terry's Pizza, breathing new life into this Huntsville icon. This revival aimed to reconnect with loyal fans and introduce a new generation to the classic flavors that had made Terry's a local favorite. The reimagined menu and atmosphere sought to honor the legacy while adapting to modern dining preferences.
Despite the promise of revival, Terry's Pizza faced challenges maintaining the quality and service standards that customers expected. These issues ultimately led to the restaurant closing again in September 2024. While the doors shut, the legacy of Terry's Pizza remains influential in Huntsville's food culture.
Though the physical restaurant has closed, Terry's Pizza continues to delight pizza lovers with its popular take-and-bake pizzas available at local grocery stores. This convenient option allows longtime fans and newcomers alike to enjoy the beloved recipes in the comfort of their own homes, preserving Terry's unique taste and heritage.
- 1959: Terry's Pizza established in Huntsville, Alabama.
- 2005: Owner Lou Pejza passes away.
- 2006: Family closes the business.
- 2018: Darden Heritage acquires rights and recipes, reviving Terry's Pizza.
- 2024: Restaurant closes again in September due to declining quality and service.
Located at 7900 Bailey Cove Rd SE UNIT A in Huntsville, AL, Terry's Pizza has been a staple in the community since 1959. Known for its variety of signature pizzas and traditional Italian dishes, it offers both dine-in and take-out options. However, recent changes have limited its buffet offerings, which were once a highlight for many patrons. Despite mixed reviews, the restaurant continues to attract locals and visitors alike.
• Established in 1959, offering a long-standing tradition of quality pizza.
• Offers a variety of signature pizzas and traditional Italian dishes.
• Provides both dine-in and take-out options.
• Available at multiple Star Market locations for convenience.
• Original location closed in 2024, limiting dine-in options.
• Mixed reviews regarding service and food quality.
• No longer offers buffet options.
• Limited seating at Star Market locations.
Families looking for a casual dining experience.
Groups wanting to enjoy a variety of pizzas.
Casual gatherings with friends.
Reservations are recommended during peak hours.
Parking is available on-site.
Check for daily specials to maximize your dining experience.
Terry's Pizza offers a nostalgic dining experience with its long-standing tradition of quality pizza. While recent changes have impacted its buffet offerings and service quality, it remains a popular choice for families and groups seeking a casual meal. With a variety of pizzas to choose from, it continues to be a noteworthy spot in Huntsville.
Located at 7900 Bailey Cove Rd SE UNIT A in Huntsville, Alabama, Terry's Pizza is a neighborhood staple that brings a variety of pizza experiences to the table. Whether you're craving a relaxed dine-in meal or need a quick, convenient option, Terry's offers a range of ways to enjoy their classic pies and more.
Terry's Pizza caters to a variety of preferences with flexible service options. You can enjoy your meal in a cozy dining area designed for comfort and a relaxed atmosphere. For those on the go, their carry-out service allows you to order your favorites to enjoy wherever you please. Plus, a drive-thru offers a speedy pick-up for busy days. For home chefs, Terry's unique take-and-bake option lets you bring home uncooked pizzas to bake fresh in your own oven—perfect for a fun culinary experience.
Beyond pizza, Terry's Pizza offers a variety of options that appeal to all ages and tastes. The restaurant is known for serving vegetarian dishes alongside their beloved classics, making it a welcoming spot for diverse dietary preferences. Families appreciate the child-friendly menu and the welcoming atmosphere, ensuring that kids are comfortably catered to. With lunch and dinner service available, you can count on Terry's to satisfy your cravings throughout the day.
- Dine-In - Enjoy your meal in our cozy dining area.
- Carry-Out - Order your favorite dishes to-go.
- Drive-Thru - Convenient drive-thru service for quick pick-up.
- Take-and-Bake - Purchase uncooked pizzas to bake at home.
Terry's Pizza not only delights taste buds but also offers practical amenities to enhance your visit. It features free parking, making arrival and departure hassle-free. The restaurant accepts debit cards and contactless payments for modern convenience. Additionally, Terry's is family-friendly with suitable options for children and accessible restroom facilities. For those who enjoy a drink with their meal, the establishment serves both beer and wine, rounding out a complete dining experience.
While Terry's Pizza is cherished by some locals for its nostalgic vibe and hearty calzones, it has also received mixed reviews regarding its buffet and food quality. Some guests mention delays during peak times and inconsistencies in preparation, particularly with takeout items. Despite these critiques, many continue to visit for the classic pizza flavors and convenient service options. If you're exploring Huntsville's pizza scene, Terry's offers a charming spot to try classic pies with a hometown feel.
