Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

London, England

Red Room

Copenhagen, Denmark

Delphine

Amsterdam, Netherlands

Chez Nina Green Brasserie

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Guide to

During Winter

Prague 

in Finland

The Northern Lights

Winter Edition

Paris

Best bars

New York Cities

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

On A Budget

5 Star Luxury Travel

You Must Visit

Eco-Friendly Hotels

Avoid Bali belly

How To:

That Are Worth The Trip

Dining Concepts

The World Is Slowing Down

Soft Travel

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Explore

Copenhagens Boutique Hotels

Discover

Tokyos best Ramen

Travel philosophy

The Rise of ‘Soft Travel’

Dublin Best Pubs

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Flagstaff

New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff, Arizona, has garnered mixed reviews from customers. While some praise the friendly staff and delicious pizza with fresh ingredients and great crust, others express disappointment over long wait times, greasy pizzas, and high prices. Despite varying opinions on speed and quality, many visitors appreciate the effort put into crafting top-quality food by taking time to prepare each meal carefully.

New Jersey Pizza Co: Flagstaff's Flavorful Slice of Home Style Pizza 

Nestled at 2224 E Cedar Ave in the heart of Flagstaff, Arizona, New Jersey Pizza Co offers a delicious journey into authentic, inventive pizza crafted with thoughtfully sourced ingredients. This cozy pizzeria has become a beloved spot for locals and travelers alike who seek a unique twist on classic pies, featuring fresh toppings and house-made dough that cater to a variety of tastes including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.

Beyond simply serving great pizza, New Jersey Pizza Co prides itself on creating an inviting atmosphere where families and groups feel at home. The staff’s warm hospitality shines, especially when managing large gatherings or busy nights, ensuring every guest’s experience feels personalized and memorable. The menu’s standout feature is its inventive combinations, like the highly recommended pepperoni with fresh jalapeños that pack a flavorful punch.

From classic cheese bread and wings to their inventive homemade pies, the menu caters to diverse palates. Notably, the "Award Winning Steamy 'V'" pizza is a vegan delight loaded with spinach, bell peppers, mushrooms, pineapple, and fresh garlic—all without cheese. Gluten-free pizza lovers can rejoice as well, with any 12-inch pizza available in a gluten-free crust made in-house from scratch using a unique flour blend.

Friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere: 

Customers consistently praise the warm hospitality and how the team handles large groups effortlessly.

Vegans and gluten-free diners can indulge confidently thanks to thoughtfully created menu items.

They accept credit, debit, and cash, making transactions smooth for every visitor.

New Jersey Pizza Co enjoys a dedicated following thanks to its standout pies and attentive team. While some visitors have noted occasional longer wait times during peak hours and a few concerns about pizza greasiness, the majority celebrate the flavorful pizzas, creative combinations, and accommodating service. Its reputation as a go-to spot in Flagstaff for families and groups remains strong, with many patrons eager to return.

What are the operating hours of New Jersey Pizza Co? 

New Jersey Pizza Co operates from Thursday to Sunday, 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM, and is closed Monday through Wednesday.

Does New Jersey Pizza Co offer vegan options? 

Yes, they provide vegan-friendly pizzas like the Award Winning Steamy 'V', which is loaded with fresh veggies and no cheese.

Is there a gluten-free pizza option available? 

Absolutely, any 12” pizza can be made gluten-free for a small extra charge with their house-made gluten-free dough.

What are the payment methods accepted at New Jersey Pizza Co? 

They accept cash, debit cards, and credit cards, making it convenient for all guests.

North America

United States

Located at 2224 E Cedar Ave #6 in Flagstaff, Arizona, New Jersey Pizza Co is a vibrant pizzeria that prides itself on using thoughtfully sourced ingredients to create inventive, homemade pies. Established in a community that values quality and flavor, this restaurant has become a local favorite for both dine-in and takeout options. The atmosphere is casual yet welcoming, making it an ideal spot for families and friends to gather over delicious pizza.

The menu at New Jersey Pizza Co features a variety of pizzas that cater to all tastes, from classic cheese to unique specialty pies. Each pizza is crafted with care, ensuring a perfect balance of flavors and textures. The restaurant also serves a selection of appetizers and sides that complement the main dishes. Here are some standout offerings to try:

The Nate: A flavorful pizza topped with pepperoni and fresh jalapeños.

Wings: Perfectly cooked and seasoned, a great pairing with any pizza.

Cheese Bread: A delightful starter that is both cheesy and satisfying.

Salads: Fresh and crisp, perfect for a lighter option.

Desserts: A sweet ending to your meal, featuring seasonal options.

New Jersey Pizza Co is situated in Flagstaff, a city known for its stunning natural beauty and vibrant cultural scene. The restaurant is conveniently located near several attractions, including the Lowell Observatory and the historic downtown area, which offers a variety of shops and galleries. Visitors can enjoy a day of exploration before settling in for a hearty meal at this beloved pizzeria.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, New Jersey Pizza Co invites you to experience their delicious offerings. With a menu that caters to all tastes and a friendly atmosphere, it's the perfect place to enjoy a meal with family and friends. Stop by today and discover why this pizzeria is a beloved part of the Flagstaff community.

Pizzeria showcasing thoughtfully sourced ingredients in its inventive, homemade pies.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNuOEpldzRBRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJd0iDBdWOLYcRmL3X4Hx6YN8/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNuOEpldzRBRRAB

No idea how this place has 4.5 stars. Got 2 pizzas and a salad. Opened up the pizza when I got home and it was just a pile of grease. One bite and tossed it.  Honestly feel like I got scammed for paying $70 for mostly grease. So incredibly pissed off. Also ordered ranch.. didn’t get any., no silverwear for the salad, and wrote no olives on the salad and guess what, we got olives . I get it’s a Saturday night but I feel personally attacked after paying as much as I did. Side note, the salad was decent but obviously not why I ordered from a pizza joint. Do not fall for the 4.5 stars on Google, this place is trash and they clearly don’t care about the customer.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQzZ0pDeEFnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJd0iDBdWOLYcRmL3X4Hx6YN8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQzZ0pDeEFnEAE

I would like to take a minute to give a shout out to this incredible pizza place and staff. We came in after a playoff game for youth football with over 40 people. Not only did they make us feel welcome but they handled our chaos and our family like their own. We order pizzas, wings, and cheese bread which all was delicious. They handled their regular busy customer base while not skipping a beat to get started for us as well. Thank you for making our special night a memorable one! We will certainly be back when we are in town again.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmM1BETFFBEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJd0iDBdWOLYcRmL3X4Hx6YN8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmM1BETFFBEAE

You will not find a better pizza in Flagstaff. Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Also, if you not had pepperoni and fresh jalapeños, you’re missing out.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQzcFlpb05BEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJd0iDBdWOLYcRmL3X4Hx6YN8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQzcFlpb05BEAE

Friendly folks for sure! Definitely artists at their craft. The pizza was DELICIOUS, but INSANELY greasy. Especially the cheese. I loved the Nate! Absolutely great flavors, unique combinations, the crust is beautifully crispy but HOLY CRAP THE GREASE. After padding it with some paper towels, it is one of the best pizzas I've had in Flagstaff

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURsa3JLVEVnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJd0iDBdWOLYcRmL3X4Hx6YN8/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURsa3JLVEVnEAE

We decided to try out a new pizza place and were shockingly disappointed. Delivery took 2 hours. Kitchens get busy, so a long wait can be excused as long as the end result is a delicious meal. This was far from it. We each tried a slice and the rest was tossed into the trash. The pizza was so greasy, that when held upright, it dripped onto the plate. Flavor-wise it was very bland and oddly tasted watered down. Maybe their other styles would have been a better choice. We also ordered wings. Thankfully, they were edible. Not great, but edible. They were very dry and tough.

Delicious Pizzas at New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff, AZ

New Jersey Pizza Co has been serving authentic New Jersey-style pizzas and Italian dishes in Flagstaff, Arizona, since 1997. Known for their commitment to quality and fresh ingredients, they have become a local favorite.

Historical Overview of New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff, Arizona.

Nestled in the heart of Flagstaff, Arizona, **New Jersey Pizza Co** has been delighting locals and visitors alike since its inception. Known for its inventive, homemade pizzas crafted from thoughtfully sourced ingredients, this pizzeria has quickly become a beloved establishment in the community. Its commitment to quality and creativity sets it apart from other dining options in the area.

Timeline of Events at New Jersey Pizza Co.

New Jersey Pizza Co opened its doors in Flagstaff, Arizona, offering a unique pizza experience with a focus on quality ingredients and innovative recipes.

From the moment you walk into New Jersey Pizza Co, you are greeted with an inviting ambiance that perfectly complements its culinary offerings. The decor is a blend of casual comfort and rustic charm, making it a great spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts. The restaurant prides itself on a menu that not only emphasizes traditional pizza but also showcases innovative recipes that cater to diverse tastes. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous flavor combinations, there's something on the menu for everyone.

Community Engagement and Customer Experience

New Jersey Pizza Co is not just about pizza; it’s about the experience. The team here is dedicated to providing top-notch service, ensuring that every visit is memorable. With a focus on community engagement, they often host events and specials that bring together the residents of Flagstaff. Customer feedback is taken seriously, with many patrons praising the restaurant for its welcoming atmosphere and willingness to accommodate large groups. This commitment to customer satisfaction has solidified its reputation as a staple in the local dining scene.

Dine In

Takeout

Delivery

Restroom

Serves Beer

Serves Wine

Serves Lunch

Serves Dinner

Good for Groups

Serves Dessert

Good for Children

Serves Vegetarian Food

In the heart of Flagstaff, Arizona, an enticing blend of flavors awaits at New Jersey Pizza Co, an eatery where culinary passion meets the vibrant spirit of the Southwest. Tucked away at 2224 East Cedar Avenue, this charming restaurant stands as a beacon for pizza enthusiasts and lovers of satisfying comfort food. The moment you step inside, the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough mingles with the rich scent of tomato sauce and melty cheese, luring you into a world where every slice tells a story. What sets this pizzeria apart is not just its delectable offerings, which boast a variety of classic and innovative toppings, but also its commitment to community. With every pie crafted from quality ingredients, visitors can take pride in supporting a local gem that thrives on the patronage of both residents and adventurous travelers. Imagine indulging in a hearty slice of New Jersey-style pizza, vibrant and crisp, while enjoying the local art adorning the walls that reflect the lively culture of Flagstaff. As you savor your meal, the location becomes a gateway to exploration. Situated near the stunning San Francisco Peaks, outdoor enthusiasts can easily plan a hike or a stroll through the charming downtown area, filled with eclectic shops and cafes. The nearby Coconino National Forest beckons with its breathtaking landscapes, offering a perfect backdrop for a day of fun and adventure. Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, the New Jersey Pizza Co is not merely a place to eat; it’s an experience steeped in flavor and community, inviting you to create memories that linger long after the last slice has been savored.

New Jersey Pizza Co

Authentic New Jersey-style pizzas and Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Meat Lovers Pizza

Vegan Supreme

Cheese Pizza

Calzone

Garlic Knots

House Salad

Tiramisu

New Jersey Pizza Co Menu

At New Jersey Pizza Co, the culinary philosophy revolves around crafting authentic New Jersey-style pizzas using thoughtfully sourced ingredients. The menu features a blend of traditional Italian flavors and innovative twists, ensuring each pie is a delightful experience. The focus is on quality, with a commitment to freshness and flavor that resonates with both locals and visitors in Flagstaff.

The menu at New Jersey Pizza Co boasts a variety of signature dishes that highlight their commitment to quality and flavor. Here are some standout options:

Meat Lovers Pizza: A hearty blend of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham, perfect for meat enthusiasts.

Vegan Supreme: Loaded with vegan cheese, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and olives, this pizza caters to plant-based diets.

Calzone: A delicious stuffed dough filled with ricotta, mozzarella, ham, mushrooms, and spinach.

To complement your meal, New Jersey Pizza Co offers a selection of beverages, including local craft beers and fine wines. The staff is knowledgeable about pairing options, ensuring your pizza experience is enhanced with the perfect drink.

New Jersey Pizza Co is committed to inclusivity, offering a variety of dietary options. Vegetarian and vegan pizzas are available, as well as gluten-free crusts to accommodate different dietary needs.

For a truly memorable experience, the chef recommends trying the Meat Lovers Pizza paired with a local craft beer. The Vegan Supreme is also a favorite among guests looking for plant-based options.

Join us at New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff for a delightful culinary experience that celebrates the art of pizza making. Whether you're dining in or taking out, we invite you to savor our delicious offerings.

Savor mouthwatering pizzas at New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff. Fresh ingredients and unique flavors await! Order now for a taste of Italy!

New Jersey Pizza Co - Delicious Pizzas in Flagstaff

Coconino County

Enjoy your favorite pizzas delivered to your doorstep.

Order ahead and pick up your meal at your convenience.

Experience our cozy atmosphere while enjoying your meal.

Dine-in

New Jersey Pizza Co Flagstaff AZ Dining Experience and Offerings Overview 

Nestled in the heart of Flagstaff at 2224 East Cedar Avenue, New Jersey Pizza Co is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers seeking a distinctive slice of the Southwest. This pizzeria is celebrated not just for its inventive, homemade pies crafted from thoughtfully sourced ingredients, but also for its inviting atmosphere that welcomes families, groups, and casual diners alike.

Whether you prefer to savor your pizza in a cozy, friendly setting or enjoy it on the go, New Jersey Pizza Co has you covered. Their dine-in service offers a comfortable space perfect for sharing a meal with friends or family. For those on the move, convenient takeout and reliable delivery options make it easy to enjoy their flavorful pies wherever you are.

Patrons rave about the combination of classic and unique toppings that make each pizza a flavorful adventure. Notably, the pepperoni with fresh jalapeños is a standout choice for those craving a spicy kick. The crust strikes a perfect balance — beautifully crispy yet light enough to let the toppings shine. Complement your meal with tantalizing sides like wings and cheese bread, which are crowd favorites for good reason.

New Jersey Pizza Co prides itself on friendly service and a welcoming vibe, ideal for casual dinners, sports teams, and families with children. They offer both free street and parking lot options, making arrival hassle-free. The establishment serves beer and wine, adding to the relaxed dining experience. While outdoor seating is not available, the inviting indoor space ensures a pleasant meal regardless of the season.

Cozy atmosphere perfect for relaxing with friends or family.

Convenient options that bring your favorite pizza right to your door or ready for pickup.

Welcoming to children and large groups, making it ideal for celebrations or casual outings.

Free street and lot parking available for a stress-free visit.

Serves both beer and wine, enhancing your dining experience.

Why Choose New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff

For those seeking a genuine pizza experience in Flagstaff, New Jersey Pizza Co stands out with its commitment to quality ingredients and bold flavors. While some patrons note that the pies can be rich and generously topped with cheese and oil, many appreciate the authentic New Jersey-style pizza vibe and the warm hospitality extended by the staff. Whether you are local or just passing through, this pizzeria offers a delicious journey into American pizza culture with a southwestern twist.

Located at 2224 E Cedar Ave #6, Flagstaff, AZ, New Jersey Pizza Co is a pizzeria that showcases thoughtfully sourced ingredients in its inventive, homemade pies. This establishment has gained attention for its authentic New Jersey-style pizza, making it a notable spot for both locals and visitors alike.

The cozy and inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect place to enjoy a meal with family or friends.

Ideal for casual dining, this restaurant serves lunch and dinner, and offers takeout and delivery options.

Higher prices compared to some competitors

Limited operating hours (Thursday to Sunday)

New Jersey Pizza Co is ideal for families looking for a casual dining experience, sports enthusiasts wanting to catch a game, and groups celebrating special occasions.

Be prepared for potential wait times during busy hours, especially on weekends. Reservations are not accepted, so arriving early is recommended. The restaurant offers both takeout and delivery, making it convenient for those on the go.

New Jersey Pizza Co offers a unique take on pizza that appeals to many. While there are some concerns regarding wait times and pricing, the quality of the ingredients and the friendly service make it a worthwhile experience. Whether you're dining in or ordering out, this pizzeria is a flavorful addition to Flagstaff's culinary scene.

Arizona

Discover New Jersey Pizza Co in Flagstaff, AZ. Authentic NJ-style pizzas, vegan & gluten-free options, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and more.

Flagstaff Pizza: Top New Jersey-Style Pizzeria Near Arizona Attractions

Enjoy fresh, high-quality ingredients at New Jersey Pizza Co. in Flagstaff. Dine-in, takeout, delivery available. Perfect for families and pizza lovers.

Flagstaff Pizza: Local Favorite for Authentic Italian Pies & Dine-In Experience

Opening hours for New Jersey Pizza Co, Flagstaff. Find opening hours for New Jersey Pizza Co, Flagstaff on 2224 E Cedar Ave, AZ - novacircle.com

Brandy's Restaurant & Bakery