Nestled in the heart of Fountain Hills, That Guy's Pizza offers a delightful escape to New York City's famed pizzerias through its cozy, brick-walled interior adorned with authentic NYC-themed decor. Known for its generous slices and an inviting ambiance, this local gem serves up Italian staples including crispy calzones, fresh salads, and of course, mouthwatering pizzas with perfectly stringy, high-quality cheese and just the right crust texture.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a casual dinner, That Guy's Pizza impresses with its quality and value. One highlight among visitors is the "2 slices and a drink for $7" deal, featuring large slices loaded with toppings and a drink that perfectly complements the meal. The crust strikes a beautiful balance — neither too thick nor too thin — delivering an authentic New York-style bite. Plus, the kid-friendly menu ensures even the little ones leave happy.
That Guy’s Pizza inspires a mix of feelings among the Fountain Hills community. Many patrons appreciate the cozy, small-space vibe and friendly staff who often remember regulars, creating a welcoming environment. Sports fans enjoy multiple TVs tuned to different games, enhancing the casual dining experience. However, some visitors have noted occasional concerns with cleanliness and maintenance, reminding prospective customers to weigh these factors alongside the delicious food offerings.
- Authentic NYC-themed decor that transports you to the Big Apple.
- Large, affordable pizza slices and combo deals perfect for quick meals or casual gatherings.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with a kids’ menu and space welcoming children.
- Takeout and delivery options including no-contact delivery for convenience and safety.
- What are the operating hours of That Guy's Pizza? The restaurant operates from 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM on Sundays, Mondays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays; 11:30 AM to 9:30 PM on Fridays and Saturdays; and is closed on Tuesdays.
- Does That Guy's Pizza offer delivery services? Yes, they offer delivery, including no-contact delivery options.
- Is there a kids' menu available? Yes, the restaurant provides a kids' menu.
- Are reservations accepted at That Guy's Pizza? The restaurant does not accept reservations.
- Is That Guy's Pizza wheelchair accessible? Yes, the establishment is wheelchair accessible.
That Guy's Pizza has been a beloved local eatery in the heart of Fountain Hills, Arizona, since its inception in 2010. Nestled at 16948 East Shea Boulevard, this pizzeria quickly carved out a niche with a welcoming, cozy atmosphere that celebrates New York City's iconic pizza culture through brick-walled decor and authentic Italian menu offerings. Over the years, it has become a go-to spot for families, foodies, and casual diners seeking delicious pizza, calzones, and other Italian staples.
From its opening in 2010, That Guy's Pizza steadily attracted a loyal clientele. By 2015, it gained significant popularity for its specialty pizzas and calzones, praised for quality crusts, stringy cheese, and generous toppings that stand out from typical chain pizzerias. This period marked a high point as locals embraced the restaurant as a neighborhood staple.
- 2010 Opening - That Guy's Pizza opens in Fountain Hills, introducing its NYC-themed pizzeria concept.
- 2015 Popularity Surge - The eatery becomes known for its standout specialty pizzas and calzones, drawing a bigger following.
- 2020 Operational Challenges - The restaurant experiences mixed reviews and hurdles in service quality and cleanliness, impacting its reputation.
- 2023 Continuing Legacy - Despite challenges, That Guy's Pizza remains a fixture of the Fountain Hills dining scene with a diverse menu and warm ambiance.
What sets That Guy's Pizza apart is its authentic New York City vibe infused into the Arizona desert setting. The brick walls and sports TVs create a casual and familiar atmosphere where customers often feel like part of a close-knit community. The menu caters to families and children with generous portions, offering both dine-in and takeout options, including delivery. Despite some critiques over recent years regarding maintenance and service, loyal patrons continue to appreciate the flavorful pies, hearty calzones, and overall value.
Whether you're a Fountain Hills resident or a visitor exploring Arizona, That Guy's Pizza offers an inviting spot to indulge in classic Italian comfort food with a twist of NYC spirit. Its journey from a rising local gem to a community mainstay reflects the passion and challenges that come with running a neighborhood pizzeria dedicated to quality and connection.
Located at 16948 E Shea Blvd, Fountain Hills, AZ, That Guy's Pizza offers a cozy dining experience with a unique NYC-themed decor. Known for its delicious pizza and calzones, this establishment serves a variety of Italian staples in a relaxed setting. With a focus on affordability and quality, it has become a local favorite for both dine-in and takeout.
- Delicious pizza with generous toppings
- Cozy, NYC-themed atmosphere
- Affordable pricing with special deals
- Friendly and welcoming staff
- Inconsistent service quality
- Cleanliness issues reported by some patrons
- Limited seating space
- Operational challenges such as broken AC
That Guy's Pizza is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, friends gathering for a game night, or anyone craving a quick and delicious meal.
- Check for special deals on pizza slices and drinks.
- Be prepared for limited seating, especially during peak hours.
- Cash and debit cards are accepted; cash-only payments are not an option.
That Guy's Pizza stands out for its delicious offerings and friendly atmosphere, making it a worthwhile stop for pizza lovers. While there are some cleanliness and service inconsistencies, the overall experience is enjoyable, especially for those seeking a casual meal without breaking the bank.
Nestled at 16948 East Shea Boulevard, That Guy's Pizza is a beloved local spot where pizza enthusiasts and families alike find a flavorful escape. This gem features a cozy dine-in experience set against rustic brick walls decked with distinctive New York City-themed decor, giving you a taste of the Big Apple right in Fountain Hills. Whether you're craving a hearty calzone or a perfectly topped pizza, the menu celebrates classic Italian staples crafted with care and quality ingredients.
That Guy's Pizza shines with its versatile offerings that cater to all dining preferences. Enjoy your meal on-site in the inviting atmosphere, or take advantage of convenient takeout and delivery services, including no-contact delivery for safe and easy access to your favorite dishes. This commitment to flexibility ensures whether you're dining solo, with friends, or family, a delicious meal is always within reach.
The pizza here is renowned for its perfect crust thickness and high-quality, stringy cheese that truly elevates every bite. Fans rave about the generous toppings and the flavorful calzones, making it clear that That Guy's Pizza offers not just great taste but excellent value as well. Popular deals, such as two large slices with a drink for under eight dollars, make it a go-to spot for a quick, satisfying meal without breaking the bank.
Beyond the delicious food, That Guy's Pizza's warm and familiar vibe resonates with visitors. Staff are known to remember returning guests, creating a friendly atmosphere that invites you to relax and enjoy your meal. While the space is compact, every inch is thoughtfully utilized, featuring multiple TVs with sports channels to keep the energy lively during your visit.
- Family-friendly environment: Great spot for kids with a dedicated children's menu.
- Payment options: Accepts debit cards and cash, making transactions easy.
- Restroom availability: Facilities on-site for customer convenience.
