Experience the authentic taste of New York with a local twist at Casanova Brothers Pizza, a beloved community gem in Gilbert, Arizona. Although the restaurant closed in October 2021, its legacy as a top spot for Sicilian-style pizza, calzones, garlic knots, and good old-fashioned Italian pasta remains vivid in the memories of food enthusiasts.
Established in 2008, Casanova Brothers Pizza quickly became a beloved culinary landmark nestled in the vibrant community of Gilbert, Arizona. Specializing in authentic New York-style pizza, this pizzeria delighted locals and visitors alike with its distinctive crust, fresh toppings, and a sauce that set it apart from other pizza shops. The warm, inviting atmosphere paired with photos celebrating old New York created a nostalgic dining experience that resonated with food lovers seeking genuine flavors.
Over the years, Casanova Brothers Pizza earned widespread acclaim for its quality and service. In 2016, the pizzeria was recognized by BuzzFeed as the top pizza shop in Arizona, a testament to the dedication and passion imbued by its owners and staff. Beyond the accolades, the establishment was cherished for its exceptional customer care, with many patrons praising the friendly atmosphere and thoughtful touches such as complimentary garlic knots for first-time visitors. It was more than just a restaurant — it was a community hub where friendships were forged over slices of perfectly baked pizza.
After 14 successful years of serving delectable New York-style pizza and creating memorable dining experiences, Casanova Brothers Pizza closed its doors permanently in October 2021. The closure followed the passing of co-owner Mike Casanova, whose vision and dedication were integral to the pizzeria's identity and beloved status. While the restaurant is no longer operating, its legacy endures in the hearts of those who experienced its warm hospitality and mouthwatering menu items. The story of Casanova Brothers Pizza remains a shining chapter in Gilbert’s culinary history, remembered for bringing a slice of New York to Arizona with unparalleled passion.
- 2008 - Casanova Brothers Pizza opened in Gilbert, Arizona.
- 2016 - Recognized as the top pizza shop in Arizona by BuzzFeed.
- 2021 - Permanently closed in October following the passing of co-owner Mike Casanova.
Located at 959 N Val Vista Dr, Gilbert, AZ, Casanova Brothers Pizza offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. This pizzeria is not just about the food; it’s a slice of nostalgia, decorated with photos of old New York. With a menu that includes pizzas, subs, and familiar pastas, it has become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Exceptional customer service
- Warm and welcoming atmosphere
- Variety of Italian favorites
- Generous portions
- Complimentary treats for first-time visitors
- Permanently closed
- No longer operational
Casanova Brothers Pizza is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, pizza lovers craving authentic flavors, and anyone wanting to enjoy a slice of New York in Gilbert.
Be sure to check for their current operating hours, as they may vary. Additionally, it’s advisable to arrive early during peak hours to avoid long waits.
Casanova Brothers Pizza stands out for its authentic New York-style offerings and exceptional service. Despite its closure, the memories of its warm atmosphere and delicious food linger in the hearts of many who visited.
Nestled in the heart of Val Vista Lakes, Gilbert, Casanova Brothers Pizza offers an authentic slice of New York with every pie. This cozy pizzeria is not just a typical pizza joint; it's a place where culinary tradition meets warm hospitality, creating a memorable dining experience for locals and visitors alike.
What sets Casanova Brothers Pizza apart is their dedication to authentic New York-style pizza, featuring a crispy, flavorful crust and a signature sauce that stands out from the crowd. Their pizzas are perfectly cooked with fresh toppings that never overpower but enhance every bite. Foodies rave about their creamy, cheesy calzones and the delightful garlic knots that make for the perfect starter.
Beyond pizza, the menu caters to all times of day, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a variety of options including familiar subs, hearty pastas, vegetarian dishes, and delicious desserts like their standout cannoli. Whether you're here for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, the warm and welcoming staff ensure you feel like family from the moment you walk in.
This pizzeria boasts a charming ambiance decorated with nostalgic photos of old New York, transporting guests to the streets of the Big Apple. Visitors can enjoy their meal indoors or take advantage of the inviting outdoor seating, perfect for Arizona’s sunny weather. Live music nights add a lively and spirited vibe, making it an excellent spot for food lovers and social gatherings alike.
- Dine-in and Outdoor Seating - Enjoy your pizza in a cozy indoor setting or sunny outdoor area.
- Live Music and Social Vibes - Regular live music events create a fun and energetic atmosphere.
- Family Friendly - The menu offers kid-friendly choices and the staff warmly welcomes families.
- Takeout and Delivery - Convenient options for enjoying their delicious offerings at home or on the go.
Visitors consistently praise Casanova Brothers for its authentic flavors, friendly service, and a welcoming vibe that mirrors the spirit of New York City right in Gilbert, Arizona. Whether you're craving a classic slice, a cheesy calzone, or a fresh salad, this spot delivers quality with every order, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and families alike.
Experience the bold flavors and warm hospitality of Casanova Brothers Pizza, where every meal feels like a delicious trip to New York!
