Nestled in the heart of Farmhouse Meadows on South Gilbert Road, Nicantoni's Pizza has been a beloved neighborhood gem in Gilbert, Arizona for over three decades. Known for its sizzling New York-style pizzas and calzones, this vibrant eatery boasts graffiti-spattered walls that set a funky, welcoming ambiance perfect for foodies and families alike.
Nicantoni's shines with its authentic approach to classic Italian-American favorites. From perfectly baked pizzas with thin crusts to hearty calzones bursting with quality ingredients, the menu caters to a variety of palates. Notably, they offered gluten-free crusts to accommodate dietary needs, ensuring everyone could savor a slice of this cherished spot. Beyond pizza, patrons rave about standout dishes such as the crispy Fish n' Chips and irresistible calamari wrapped in jalapeño and bacon—a true testament to Nicantoni's creative culinary spirit.
Inside Nicantoni's, you'll find a cozy, homey atmosphere with a few well-appointed tables that foster a sense of community. Outdoor seating options add a relaxed, quiet charm to the dining experience. Adding to the ambiance, live music on Fridays transforms the space into a lively local hotspot. Families felt right at home here, thanks to a child-friendly menu and welcoming staff that made every visit memorable. The restaurant embraced modern conveniences with NFC payment options and accepted all major credit cards, making it easy to enjoy your meal without hassle.
Nicantoni's Pizza left a lasting impression on Gilbert's dining scene. Revered for its authentic flavors and inviting atmosphere, the eatery earned praise for great service and quality food. While some patrons found certain pizzas less flavorful or crusts a bit dry, the overall consensus celebrates it as a hidden gem with hearty portions and excellent prices. Its closure in May 2021 marked the end of a cherished era, leaving fond memories and a void in the local culinary community.
- Is Nicantoni's Pizza still open? As of May 16, 2025, Nicantoni's Pizza is permanently closed. The restaurant ceased operations on May 30, 2021, after 33 years of serving the Gilbert community.
- What were the operating hours of Nicantoni's Pizza? Before closing, it was open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and closed on Sundays.
- Did Nicantoni's Pizza offer gluten-free options? Yes, gluten-free crusts were available, catering to guests with gluten sensitivities.
- Was Nicantoni's Pizza a family-friendly restaurant? Absolutely, it was known for its welcoming environment and menu options suitable for children.
- Did Nicantoni's Pizza offer live music? Yes, live music was a key part of the dining experience, especially on Friday nights.
Nicantoni's Pizza holds a cherished place in the culinary landscape of Gilbert, Arizona, celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizzas and classic Italian dishes. The story begins in 1988 when Vic Buono founded Buono's Pizza in nearby Mesa, Arizona, marking the start of a local pizza legacy that would span over three decades.
In 2003, after selling Buono's Pizza, Vic Buono took an exciting new step by acquiring Islands Pizza located in Gilbert. He transformed this neighborhood spot into Nicantoni's, infusing it with his passion for New York-style pizza-making and Italian culinary traditions. This transition marked the birth of Nicantoni's as a beloved local eatery, renowned for its genuine flavors and welcoming atmosphere.
Nicantoni's steadily grew in popularity, becoming a cherished spot for locals and visitors alike. In 2016, the restaurant relocated to JD’s Homestead center on Gilbert Road, nestled between Elliot and Warner, a move that allowed it to better serve the vibrant Farmhouse Meadows neighborhood and the broader Gilbert community. Its funky decor with graffiti-splattered walls and lively Friday night live music made it not just a place to eat, but a hub of social and cultural gatherings.
After 33 years of dedicated service to the Gilbert community, Nicantoni's closed its doors on May 30, 2021, following Vic Buono’s retirement. The closing marked the end of an era for a restaurant that was known not only for its delicious pizzas and Italian fare but also as a neighborhood cornerstone where families and friends gathered. Its reputation for quality food, friendly service, and a welcoming vibe continues to resonate with those who experienced its unique charm.
- Founded by Vic Buono in 1988 - Began as Buono's Pizza in Mesa, Arizona.
- Transformation in 2003 - Acquired Islands Pizza and renamed it Nicantoni's in Gilbert.
- Relocation in 2016 - Moved to JD’s Homestead center on Gilbert Road between Elliot and Warner.
- Closing in 2021 - Closed after 33 years as founder Vic Buono retired.
Located at 323 S Gilbert Rd UNIT 111 in Gilbert, Arizona, Nicantoni's is a vibrant eatery known for its authentic New York-style pizzas and calzones. This funky restaurant, adorned with graffiti-spattered walls, offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for casual dining. With a diverse menu and a welcoming vibe, it has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Friendly and attentive service
- Cozy and welcoming atmosphere
- Generous portion sizes
- Reasonable prices
- Happy hour specials
- Outdoor seating available
- Pet-friendly environment
- Wheelchair accessible
- Accepts various payment methods
- Limited indoor seating
- Occasional wait times during peak hours
- No reservations accepted
- Limited parking space
Nicantoni's is perfect for casual family dinners, quick lunches, and gatherings with friends. Its relaxed atmosphere makes it a great spot for unwinding after a long day or enjoying a weekend meal.
Be prepared for limited indoor seating, especially during peak hours. It's advisable to arrive early to avoid long wait times. Parking can be challenging, so consider carpooling or using rideshare services.
Nicantoni's stands out for its authentic flavors and friendly service. While there are some drawbacks, such as limited seating and parking, the overall experience is enjoyable. If you're in Gilbert, this eatery is worth a visit for its delicious pizza and inviting atmosphere.
Nestled in the charming Farmhouse Meadows neighborhood of Gilbert, Nicantoni's is a vibrant local gem that brings the authentic taste of New York-style pizza right to Arizona. This funky eatery is instantly recognizable by its graffiti-spattered walls, creating a lively and artistic atmosphere that complements its casual, welcoming vibe. Whether you're craving a classic slice or something more adventurous, Nicantoni's delivers a flavorful experience that caters to food lovers and families alike.
At Nicantoni's, the menu showcases traditional New York-style pizzas and calzones crafted with care, featuring a delicious variety of toppings and vegetarian options. Beyond pizza, you’ll find standout dishes like perfectly cooked cod fish and chips, crispy fries, and indulgent appetizers such as calamari and jalapeño wrapped in bacon — a true crowd-pleaser. The generous portions and reasonable prices make it a favorite spot for casual lunches, dinners, or relaxed weekend gatherings.
This neighborhood establishment shines with its inviting, homey atmosphere and friendly service. Guests appreciate the option for outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying Gilbert’s pleasant weather in a calm setting. Live music on Fridays adds a fun vibe, making every visit feel like a special occasion. Families are welcomed warmly with a menu suitable for children, ensuring everyone can find something delicious to enjoy.
- Full-service dining with a casual, friendly atmosphere.
- Takeout and delivery available for ultimate convenience.
- Reservations accepted to guarantee your table.
- Wheelchair accessible, ensuring comfort for all guests.
- Serves a variety of alcoholic beverages including beer, wine, and cocktails.
- Complimentary Wi-Fi and television for entertainment and connectivity.
Whether you're a local or just passing through Gilbert, Nicantoni's offers a memorable dining experience with a unique blend of New York-style flavors and southwestern charm. Perfect for families, foodies, or anyone seeking a relaxed yet lively spot to enjoy great food and drinks, this eatery is a must-visit. Don't forget to check out their live music nights and come hungry for delicious pizza, calzones, and more.
