Best Sandwich Shop in Phoenix: J P Mc Gurkee's Delights
Nestled in the heart of Phoenix's Margarita Place neighborhood, J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop offers a nostalgic dive into classic American deli culture. This beloved local eatery has been a staple for community college students and longtime residents alike, known for its hearty sandwiches crafted with care and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like stepping back into a simpler time. The shop’s toasted breads are often praised as "the absolute bomb," providing the perfect crisp foundation for generous, lean meats that satisfy every craving.
Dining and culinary delights
J P Mc Gurkee's menu is a celebration of classic sandwiches, with the Super Sicilian sub standing out as a crowd favorite. This sandwich features a perfectly toasted sesame seed bun that strikes a balance between crunch and softness, layered with a well-portioned selection of lean meats that deliver a satisfying flavor without overwhelming the palate. Accompanying your sandwich, the creamy and tangy potato salad offers a delightful contrast, while crisp pickle spears add a refreshing bite.
The shop serves lunch and dinner, with options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, making it a convenient choice for busy locals and visitors. While the establishment does not offer vegetarian or cocktail options, it does serve beer and wine, enhancing the casual dining experience. Outdoor seating is available for those who prefer to enjoy their meal under the Arizona sun.
Location and nearby attractions
Located at 2822 North 15th Avenue in Phoenix, Arizona, J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop sits within the vibrant Margarita Place neighborhood. The area offers a blend of local culture and easy access to Maricopa County's attractions. While parking can be a bit tricky due to the segmented lots, free parking options are available both on the street and in nearby lots, making it accessible for visitors.
Signature highlights
- Super Sicilian sub – A generously portioned sandwich with perfectly toasted sesame seed bread and lean meats that balance flavor and texture.
- Potato salad side – Creamy and tangy, this side perfectly complements the hearty sandwiches.
Behind the scenes
J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop carries a rich sense of nostalgia, reflected in its wood-laden interior and 80’s rock tunes playing softly in the background. A black-and-white tintype photo of the founder hangs proudly above the counter, reminding visitors of the shop’s enduring legacy. The friendly staff are known for their attentive service, often engaging warmly with customers and updating them on their orders, especially during busy times when locals pick up large catering orders.
FAQs
- What is J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop known for? It’s famous for its nostalgic atmosphere and the Super Sicilian sub, featuring perfectly toasted bread and lean, generous meats.
- Why should I visit J P Mc Gurkee's? To experience a slice of authentic Phoenix deli culture with friendly service, hearty sandwiches, and a cozy, nostalgic setting.
- Is parking available? Yes, there is free parking available both on the street and in nearby lots, although the segmented parking areas require some navigation.
Experience J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop today
Whether you're a local craving a comforting sandwich or a traveler seeking an authentic taste of Phoenix, J P Mc Gurkee's Sandwich Shop invites you to indulge in its time-honored flavors and warm hospitality. Share your experience, recommend your favorite sandwich, and savor the unique charm that keeps customers coming back for decades.
