Located at 665 W Tennyson Rd in the vibrant Harder-Tennyson neighborhood of Hayward, California, New York Pizza offers a flavorful slice of the Big Apple right in Alameda County. This cozy spot is perfect for foodies craving authentic New York-style pizzas, featuring thin yet crispy crusts and generous toppings that cater to a variety of tastes. Whether you're planning a casual dine-in night or ordering takeout for a group gathering, this pizzeria is designed to satisfy with its straightforward menu of slices, whole pies, salads, and flatbreads.
New York Pizza is known for its classic New York-style slices that strike a balance between a thin crust and crispiness, delivering that iconic pizza experience. Popular offerings like the pepperoni and green bell peppers combo are customer favorites, though some guests note that the pies here lean more toward familiar local styles like Mountain Mike's or Round Table rather than traditional New York standards. The Afghani Slice stands out as a spicy, unique twist, adding diversity to the menu that appeals to adventurous palates.
Dine-in guests can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere, though some have reported issues with kitchen odors affecting comfort. The establishment welcomes groups and families, offering a menu that includes vegetarian options and dishes suitable for children.
New York Pizza caters to diverse dining preferences with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. They operate extensive hours, typically from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, with longer hours on weekends to accommodate late-night cravings. The restaurant provides free parking both on the street and in a lot, making visits hassle-free. Payment options are flexible, accepting cashless methods such as credit, debit, and NFC payments, ensuring a convenient checkout experience.
Visitors to New York Pizza express a mix of sentiments. Many appreciate the "perfect New York style and size slices" with thin, crispy crusts and unique menu items like the spicy Afghani Slice. Affordable prices and friendly service enhance the overall experience for several customers. However, some patrons have raised concerns about inconsistent order accuracy, food quality fluctuations, and occasional strong kitchen odors impacting the dining atmosphere. Despite these critiques, the pizzeria remains a key player in Hayward's pizza scene, particularly for those seeking traditional New York flavors.
- Is New York Pizza halal? Yes, New York Pizza offers halal options, including beef pepperoni and ground beef.
- Do they accept EBT? Yes, they accept EBT for hot food purchases.
- What are the operating hours? Operating hours vary by location. For the 665 W Tennyson Rd location, they are typically open from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, with extended hours on Fridays and Saturdays.
Nestled in the vibrant city of Hayward, California, New York Pizza has been a cherished family-owned pizzeria since its founding in 2000. This beloved establishment carved out a unique niche by specializing in thin-crust New York-style pizzas, delivering an authentic slice of Italian-American culinary tradition to the local community.
Over the years, New York Pizza has expanded beyond its original pizza offerings to embrace a wider array of Italian-American favorites. By 2010, the menu had grown to include delicious calzones, hearty pasta dishes, and fresh salads, appealing to a broader range of tastes and preferences.
Embracing the digital age, the pizzeria launched online ordering and delivery services in 2015, making it easier than ever for locals and visitors to enjoy their signature pizzas and Italian dishes from the comfort of home.
Known for its welcoming, family-owned atmosphere, New York Pizza has become a staple of the Harder-Tennyson neighborhood and the greater Alameda County area. It offers a cozy dine-in experience, alongside convenient takeout and delivery options, catering to families, groups, and solo diners alike.
- Established in 2000 as a family-owned pizzeria in Hayward, CA.
- Menu expansion in 2010 to include calzones, pasta dishes, and salads.
- Introduction of online ordering and delivery in 2015 providing greater convenience for customers.
Located at 665 W Tennyson Rd in Hayward, California, New York Pizza is a small establishment known for its authentic New York-style pizzas. With a diverse menu that includes specialty pizzas, calzones, and salads, this spot caters to both dine-in and takeout customers. The restaurant has garnered attention for its fresh ingredients and friendly service, making it a popular choice among locals.
Ideal for pizza lovers seeking a casual dining experience, New York Pizza offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for families and groups.
- Authentic New York-style pizzas Diverse menu offerings Fresh ingredients Friendly and efficient service Variety of specialty pizzas and calzones
- Limited seating capacity No online reservations
New York Pizza is ideal for families, casual gatherings, and pizza enthusiasts looking for a taste of authentic New York-style pies.
Parking is available with both free street and lot options. The restaurant is family-friendly and offers a menu for children, making it a great choice for a family outing.
New York Pizza offers a solid choice for those craving authentic pizza in Hayward. While it has its drawbacks, such as limited seating and no online reservations, the quality of the food and friendly service make it worth a visit.
Nestled at 665 West Tennyson Road in the vibrant Harder-Tennyson neighborhood of Hayward, California, New York Pizza invites pizza lovers and food adventurers to enjoy authentic yet approachable New York-style pizza experience. This cozy spot offers the perfect blend of thin-crust pizzas, generous toppings, and a welcoming atmosphere that caters well to families, groups, and casual diners alike.
Whether you prefer a relaxed dine-in night or a quick takeout, New York Pizza has you covered. The restaurant offers dine-in seating ideal for family outings and friendly gatherings, with the convenience of free parking on-site. For those on the go, speedy takeout and reliable delivery services make it easy to enjoy your favorite pies anywhere.
At New York Pizza, the star of the show is the thin-crust New York-style pizza, boasting a crispy yet tender base that's perfect for folding and savoring. Choose from a variety of classic and creative toppings to customize your pie. But the offerings don't stop there — the menu also features delicious calzones stuffed with ooey-gooey cheese and your choice of fillings, satisfying pasta dishes like hearty Meat Lasagna and delicate Cheese Ravioli, fresh salads bursting with vibrant greens and toppings, and savory sandwiches such as Meatball and Italian varieties.
- Pizza - Thin-crust New York-style pizzas with various toppings starting at $12.99
- Calzones - Stuffed with cheese and your choice of fillings for $15.99
- Pasta Dishes - Including Meat Lasagna and Cheese Ravioli for $14.99
- Salads - Fresh greens with a variety of toppings at $8.99
- Sandwiches - Meatball and Italian Sandwiches priced at $9.99
- Desserts - Including classic New York Style Cheesecake for just $4.99
New York Pizza is a great spot for families and groups, offering a comfortable environment and a menu that includes options for children. The prices are friendly on the wallet, making it an accessible choice for casual dining any day of the week. Though the ambiance is simple, the focus on classic flavors and satisfying portions shines.
- Seating - Dine-in available but no outdoor seating
- Parking - Free parking lot and free street parking available
- Payment - Accepts debit, credit cards, and NFC payments, cash not accepted
- Alcohol - Does not serve beer, wine, or cocktails
