Nestled in the heart of San Pedro, Bonello's New York Pizza stands out as a cherished local gem that brings the authentic flavors of classic New York-style pizza to the Los Angeles community. This cozy spot is famous for its thin yet crispy slices that deliver the perfect chew and that unmistakable NY taste that pizza lovers crave. Whether you're a visitor or a local, the inviting red-sauce ambiance and friendly staff make every visit a warm and memorable experience.
Bonello's is renowned for its mouthwatering New York- and Sicilian-style pizzas, with favorites like the Pepperoni Happy Roll and the classic New York Style Cheese Pizza winning hearts and taste buds alike. The menu also features hearty subs and spaghetti dishes, perfect for those craving a full Italian-American comfort meal. Expect generous portions, great prices, and a simple, no-frills environment that puts the spotlight squarely on the food.
Dine-in guests enjoy a clean and cozy space with about five tables, while those on the go can take advantage of delivery and takeout options, including convenient curbside pickup. Though the establishment is cash-only, many patrons find the exceptional quality and friendly service well worth the extra effort.
The community sentiment around Bonello's New York Pizza is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the spot for maintaining an authentic New York pizza experience so far from the Big Apple. Happy rolls, loaded with cheese and savory fillings, are a standout, though some diners prefer sticking to the classic slices for the best flavor balance. The staff's warm service and the restaurant's inviting vibe make it a beloved stop for family meals, casual dates, and friendly hangouts alike.
Free street parking and a small parking lot right in front make visiting hassle-free, while the absence of public restrooms and the cash-only policy are important to keep in mind before heading over. Vegetarian visitors will also find satisfying options like salads and cheese pizza, ensuring everyone can enjoy a great meal.
- What are the operating hours of Bonello's New York Pizza? Bonello's New York Pizza operates from Monday to Saturday, 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and is closed on Sundays.
- Is Bonello's New York Pizza a cash-only establishment? Yes, Bonello's New York Pizza operates on a cash-only basis.
- Does Bonello's New York Pizza offer delivery services? Yes, Bonello's New York Pizza offers delivery, takeout, and dine-in options.
- Is there parking available at Bonello's New York Pizza? Yes, there is parking available in front of the building, with curbside pickup options.
- Does Bonello's New York Pizza have vegetarian options? Yes, Bonello's New York Pizza offers vegetarian options, including salads and cheese pizza.
Nestled in the heart of San Pedro, California, Bonello's New York Pizza stands as a beloved family-owned landmark, serving authentic New York-style pizza and traditional Italian dishes. Since its founding in 1984 by Charlie Bonello, this pizzeria has been a cornerstone in the community, delivering a consistent, quality dining experience that has become synonymous with its name.
Charlie Bonello’s vision materialized in 1984 when he opened the doors of Bonello's New York Pizza, bringing a slice of authentic New York flavor to San Pedro. Over the decades, the restaurant has maintained its commitment to the classic thin, yet crispy, pizza crust—capturing the iconic New York taste that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
More than 30 years later, Bonello's continues to thrive, preserving the family’s legacy and dedication to quality ingredients and authentic recipes. Its menu features not only mouthwatering New York-style pizzas but also classic Italian staples like subs and spaghetti, appealing to a broad range of tastes.
- 1984: Bonello's New York Pizza was established by Charlie Bonello.
- 2025: Bonello's New York Pizza continues to serve the San Pedro community with a strong reputation for quality and consistency.
Located at 806 S Gaffey St #3613 in San Pedro, California, Bonello's New York Pizza is a cozy eatery that specializes in authentic New York-style pizza. This tiny red-sauce outlet has garnered a loyal following for its delicious offerings, including subs and spaghetti. With a focus on quality and a welcoming atmosphere, it's a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the Los Angeles area.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Friendly and attentive staff
- Cozy and clean atmosphere
- Offers delivery, takeout, and dine-in options
- Cash-only policy ensures quick transactions
- Cash-only policy may be inconvenient for some customers
- Limited seating with only about five tables available
- No online ordering system available
Bonello's New York Pizza is perfect for casual dining, family outings, or a quick bite after a long day. Its friendly atmosphere makes it a great choice for pizza lovers of all ages.
- Bring cash, as this is a cash-only establishment
- Parking is available on the street and in a free lot
- The restaurant is small, so expect limited seating
Bonello's New York Pizza stands out for its authentic flavors and friendly service. While the cash-only policy and limited seating may pose challenges, the quality of the pizza and the inviting atmosphere make it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or dining in with family, Bonello's delivers a taste of New York right in San Pedro.
Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of San Pedro, Los Angeles, Bonello's New York Pizza serves up an irresistible slice of authentic New York-style pizza. This cozy red-sauce joint offers a slice of nostalgia for pizza lovers craving the thin, crispy crusts and classic flavors that define NYC pizza culture. Whether you're a local foodie, a digital nomad seeking a quick yet satisfying meal, or a trend-conscious traveler exploring Los Angeles's culinary scene, Bonello's promises a genuine taste experience that captures the essence of New York.
Bonello's is known for its classic New York and Sicilian-style pizzas made with a thin crust that strikes the perfect balance between crispiness and chewiness. Each slice delivers that iconic combination of tangy tomato sauce, rich cheese, and a satisfying crust that pizza aficionados rave about. Beyond pizza, the menu features subs and spaghetti that complement the authentic Italian-American vibe. Reviewers repeatedly praise the cheese slice as a "must-try" for capturing that cherished NYC pizza taste. While some specialty items like the "happy roll" may not suit all palates, the pizza consistently earns accolades for flavor and portion size.
Bonello's caters to a variety of dining preferences with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, making it easy to enjoy their classic pies wherever you are. The eatery features a clean, welcoming environment suitable for groups and families, complete with seating arrangements that foster a relaxed dining experience. Although there is no outdoor seating or alcohol service, patrons appreciate the friendly staff and efficient service, including order pickup brought directly to your car if you prefer to dine elsewhere. Parking is a breeze with free street and lot options, a rarity in busy Los Angeles neighborhoods.
- Cash Only - Be prepared to pay with cash as Bonello's does not accept cards.
- Parking - Free parking available on the street and in nearby lots, a big plus in San Pedro.
- Order Variety - Try the classic cheese slice to experience the well-loved New York flavor.
