Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery in Santa Monica California: A beloved local gem known for its authentic Italian sandwiches and grocery offerings.

Nestled in the heart of Santa Monica on Lincoln Boulevard, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery is a must-visit spot for food lovers craving authentic Italian flavors. Known primarily for its legendary overstuffed sandwiches, especially the iconic Godmother, this deli combines classic Italian meats, provolone cheese, and fresh produce on perfectly baked bread to create unforgettable taste experiences. Beyond sandwiches, Bay Cities also features a gourmet Italian grocery selection that includes a wide assortment of cheeses, sauces, fresh pastas, and other pantry essentials, catering to those who want to bring a taste of Italy home.

A lively atmosphere and authentic flavors

Step inside Bay Cities and you’ll find a bustling, New York-style deli vibe with a friendly, efficient staff managing a quick ticket number system to keep orders moving. While the place can get lively, the outdoor seating provides a relaxed option to savor your meal. Customers rave about the fresh, flavorful meats and the bread that truly steals the show—baked to perfection with a crisp yet tender texture.

Why locals and visitors keep coming back

Beyond the much-acclaimed Godmother sandwich, the meatball sub is another favorite, featuring house-made meatballs, rich spaghetti sauce, and parmesan cheese that perfectly complement the artisan bread. The variety of homemade sides, such as potato salads and chicken salad, make each visit an opportunity to explore new tastes. Moreover, the deli’s well-stocked grocery section invites guests to shop for premium Italian ingredients, sauces, and ready-to-go meals.

Parking and payment - There is a large free parking lot and some paid street parking options available for customers. The deli accepts debit cards but is cash-only for credit cards. Please note backpacks must be left at the front counter.
Ordering and service - Customers grab a number ticket and wait to be called for their order, which keeps the process smooth despite the busy atmosphere. Online ordering is available for fast pick-up.
Pet policy - Pets are not allowed inside except for service animals, ensuring a clean and comfortable environment for all guests.

Frequently asked questions

What are the operating hours of Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery? The deli operates from Wednesday to Sunday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Does Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery accept credit cards? No, the deli is cash-only and does not accept credit cards.
Is there parking available at Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery? Yes, there is a parking lot available for customers.
Can I order food online from Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery? Yes, the deli offers online ordering for quick pick-up, allowing customers to bypass in-store lines.
Are pets allowed at Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery? No, pets are not allowed, except for service animals.

Community sentiment

Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery enjoys an overwhelmingly positive reputation among locals and visitors alike. Patrons consistently praise the quality and freshness of the sandwiches, particularly lauding the Godmother sub for its generous portions and rich flavor combinations. The deli's expansive selection of Italian grocery items also earns kudos, making it a one-stop destination for authentic Italian food lovers. Friendly customer service, efficient ordering, and a fun, bustling atmosphere contribute to its standing as a cherished Santa Monica institution.

Established in 1925, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery has been a beloved fixture in Santa Monica for nearly a century. Nestled at 1517 Lincoln Blvd, this family-owned deli has become synonymous with authentic Italian cuisine, known particularly for its overstuffed sandwiches and gourmet grocery offerings. The deli's vibrant atmosphere and rich culinary heritage make it a must-visit for both locals and tourists.

1925: Established as a family-owned Italian deli in Santa Monica.
2000: Became renowned for its signature Godmother sandwich.
2010: Expanded offerings to include a variety of Italian grocery items.
2020: Introduced online ordering for customer convenience.

Known for its signature Godmother sandwich—a delicious combination of savory meats and fresh toppings—Bay Cities has captured the hearts of many. The deli also offers a variety of other Italian specialties, from meatball subs to freshly made pasta and sauces. The bustling atmosphere, characterized by an old-world charm, adds to the experience, making each visit feel special. The deli's commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes has solidified its reputation as one of the best spots in Los Angeles for authentic Italian food.

Over the decades, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery has maintained its strong ties to the community, becoming a gathering place for friends and family. Its dedication to customer service and high-quality food ensures it remains a local favorite. The deli's ability to adapt to modern trends, such as implementing online ordering, showcases its commitment to convenience while retaining the authenticity of its roots. Visitors can expect a delightful culinary experience that reflects the rich Italian heritage the deli proudly represents.

Discover Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery in Santa Monica California

Nestled in the heart of Santa Monica on picturesque Lincoln Boulevard, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery is a beloved local gem renowned for its authentic, overstuffed Italian sandwiches and expansive gourmet grocery selection. Whether you’re craving a classic Godmother sub or exploring their wide range of delicacies, this establishment has become a must-visit for food lovers and Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

Outstanding Italian flavors and menu variety

Bay Cities Italian Deli offers an extensive menu that covers breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, catering to diverse palates. Signature sandwiches such as the Godmother and the meatball sub are celebrated for their fresh ingredients and perfectly baked bread, earning rave reviews from visitors. Beyond sandwiches, the deli features gluten-free, halal, and kosher options to accommodate various dietary needs, along with a full range of Italian grocery items like lasagna, cheeses, sauces, and breads available for purchase.

Convenience and atmosphere

The deli’s bustling environment reflects its popularity, with a quick and efficient number ticket system ensuring smooth service during busy hours. Outdoor seating is available for those who want to enjoy California’s pleasant weather, while the interior ambiance channels a lively New York deli vibe. The location is wheelchair accessible and family-friendly, with free Wi-Fi and live music events enhancing the dining experience. Additional conveniences include parking options with a free lot and street parking, plus online ordering, takeout, and delivery services to suit busy lifestyles.

Pros: Authentic Italian sandwiches with fresh ingredients and wide grocery selection.
Pros: Convenient online ordering, takeout, delivery, and parking including a free lot.
Pros: Inclusive menu options (gluten-free, halal, kosher) and a family-friendly, lively atmosphere with live music.
Cons: The cash-only and debit-card payment policy may inconvenience customers who prefer credit cards or mobile payments.
Cons: Restrictions on backpacks and pets (other than service animals) might be inconvenient for some visitors.

Overall, Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery combines authentic Italian flavors with a vibrant local atmosphere and thoughtful amenities, making it a standout destination in Santa Monica for foodies and casual diners alike. While a few operational policies may pose minor inconveniences, the deli’s quality and charm continue to attract loyal patrons and newcomers seeking genuine Italian deli experiences.

4.4

Italian

1517 Lincoln Blvd, Santa Monica, CA 90401, USA

(310) 395-8279

Closed - Opens 9:00 AM

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

09:00–18:00

Wednesday

09:00–18:00

Thursday