Nestled in the heart of Menifee, California, New York's Upper Crust Pizza was a beloved spot for authentic New York-style pizza and classic Italian favorites. Famous for its hand-made, brick-oven pizzas, this eatery offered a cozy atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating, making it perfect for families and casual diners alike. Visitors raved about the fresh ingredients and bold flavors that brought a slice of NYC to Riverside County.
The pizzeria stood out for its commitment to quality and the authentic New York pizza experience. Unlike typical quick-serve pizza joints, this place focused on hand-rolled dough, fresh sauce, and generous cheese. Beyond pizza, their sandwiches and garlic knots attracted foodies looking for hearty, comforting Italian-American meals. The friendly staff and laid-back vibe made every visit memorable.
Customers often praised the pizzeria for its authentic taste and quality ingredients. Many enjoyed the warm atmosphere and outdoor seating options, perfect for sunny Menifee days. The staff's friendly and attentive service further enhanced the dining experience. However, some visitors noted occasional inconsistencies during busy periods, reminding patrons that even great places have room for improvement.
- Authentic New York-style pizza made fresh in a brick oven.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with seating options inside and outside.
- Friendly and attentive staff who make every visit enjoyable.
- Is New York's Upper Crust Pizza still open As of May 17, 2025, New York's Upper Crust Pizza in Menifee, CA, is permanently closed.
- What were the operating hours When it was operational, the restaurant's hours were Monday to Friday: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm; Saturday: 11:00 am - 10:00 pm; Sunday: 11:00 am - 9:00 pm.
- Did the restaurant offer delivery Yes, the restaurant offered delivery services to customers.
- Was outdoor seating available Yes, the restaurant provided outdoor seating for customers.
- What payment methods were accepted The restaurant accepted credit card payments, including Visa and MasterCard.
New York's Upper Crust Pizza was a beloved family-owned pizzeria renowned for bringing the authentic taste of New York-style pizza and classic Italian dishes to California. Established initially in Laguna Niguel in 1991, this establishment captured the hearts and appetites of pizza enthusiasts with its handmade, fresh, and hot pizzas cooked in a traditional brick oven. Over the decades, it expanded its reach to multiple locations across California, including a notable presence in Menifee, Irvine, and Laguna Niguel.
Starting in Laguna Niguel, New York's Upper Crust Pizza quickly established itself as a go-to destination for lovers of authentic pizza by the slice and other Italian favorites. The pizzeria’s commitment to traditional recipes and quality ingredients distinguished it from the fast-food pizza chains prevalent in the area. This dedication earned it a loyal customer base, who appreciated its cozy atmosphere and friendly service.
In 2016, New York's Upper Crust Pizza celebrated its 25th anniversary, marking a quarter-century of delivering traditional New York-style pizza to Californian communities. This milestone highlighted the pizzeria's lasting appeal and its ability to sustain quality and customer satisfaction over the years. The anniversary was a testament to the family's dedication to maintaining the timeless flavors and welcoming ambiance that defined the chain.
The Menifee branch, located at 30076 Haun Road, Suite 220, became a local favorite for its genuine New York pizza experience. The establishment offered both dine-in and takeout options, featuring classic Italian dishes, vegetarian choices, and a vibrant yet relaxed atmosphere suitable for families and casual diners alike. Despite its popularity, the Menifee location was reported as permanently closed in 2023, marking the end of an era for fans of authentic New York-style pizza in that area.
New York's Upper Crust Pizza left a lasting impression on the California pizza scene by offering a slice of New York's culinary tradition. Its emphasis on quality, authenticity, and family-friendly service continues to inspire pizza lovers seeking genuine Italian-American flavors. Though the Menifee location has closed, the story of this cherished pizzeria remains a flavorful chapter in the local dining history.
- 1991: Established in Laguna Niguel, CA.
- 2016: Celebrated 25th anniversary of serving authentic New York-style pizza.
- 2023: Menifee location reported as permanently closed.
Located at 30076 Haun Rd STE 220, Menifee, CA 92584, New York's Upper Crust Pizza is a pizzeria that serves authentic NYC-style Italian favorites. Known for its pizza by the slice, this establishment offers a basic yet inviting setting for diners. With a focus on quality ingredients and a friendly atmosphere, it has garnered attention from locals and visitors alike.
The restaurant is particularly noted for its handmade, fresh pizzas baked in a brick oven, providing a delightful experience for pizza lovers. The casual ambiance makes it a great spot for families and friends looking to enjoy a meal together.
• Authentic New York-style pizza
• Friendly staff
• Quality ingredients
• Variety of menu options
• Service speed during peak times
• Limited seating capacity
Families, casual dining, pizza lovers, and those seeking a quick bite.
The restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Outdoor seating is available, making it a great choice for pleasant weather. It's advisable to visit during off-peak hours for quicker service.
New York's Upper Crust Pizza stands out for its commitment to authentic flavors and quality ingredients. While there are some service speed issues during busy times, the overall experience is enjoyable, making it a worthwhile stop for pizza enthusiasts in Menifee.
Located at 30076 Haun Rd STE 220 in Menifee, California, this lively pizzeria brings the essence of NYC Italian favorites straight to Riverside County. Whether you're a foodie craving an authentic slice or a family looking for a welcoming spot, this restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating options. The brick oven pizzas here are hand crafted and baked fresh, promising a genuine taste experience that stands out from quick, mass-produced pies.
At New York's Upper Crust Pizza, the focus is on quality and flavor. Patrons enjoy a variety of pizza slices with rich marinara sauce, gooey cheese, and fresh toppings. The menu also includes tasty sandwiches and signature garlic knots, perfect as sides or snacks. Vegetarian options ensure there's something delicious for everyone.
- Dine-in experience: Enjoy your freshly baked pizza in a relaxed setting with friendly staff and options for outdoor seating.
- Takeout convenience: Grab your favorite slices and sandwiches to go, perfect for quick meals or casual gatherings.
- Delivery service: Get piping hot pizza delivered right to your doorstep at no extra cost, with fast and reliable service.
- Family friendly: Welcoming environment suitable for children to enjoy classic Italian pizza favorites.
This spot is ideal for pizza lovers searching for an authentic New York-style Italian experience outside the Big Apple. Reviewers praise the fresh, hand-made pizzas with excellent marinara sauce and the inviting atmosphere. The combination of dine-in, takeout, and delivery options offer flexibility for busy lifestyles. Plus, the availability of beer and wine complements your meal perfectly.
