Nestled in the heart of Petaluma, Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is a beloved local landmark that has been serving up authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas since 1979. Located at 41 Petaluma Boulevard North, this charming eatery combines a warm historic atmosphere with mouthwatering cuisine, making it a favorite spot for families, foodies, and anyone craving a hearty slice of pizza.
Stepping into Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant feels like a trip back in time. The restaurant’s classic brick walls, elegant chandeliers, and intriguing hallways evoke a rich history—rumored to have once been a brothel—adding a unique character to your dining experience. This setting beautifully complements the warm and comforting vibe that has made it a neighborhood favorite for decades.
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is renowned for its signature deep-dish pizzas made with quality, fresh ingredients. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni and sausage or prefer a variety of toppings like mushrooms and veggies, their pizzas are generously prepared and satisfy even the heartiest appetites. Many locals and visitors alike consider it the best deep-dish pizza spot in Sonoma County.
Besides the pizza, the menu features delicious garlic bread, fresh salads like Caesar, and a selection of desserts to round out your meal. The restaurant serves lunch, brunch, and dinner, ensuring there’s always a perfect time to indulge in their famous pies.
Guests often praise the friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to create a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a casual meal, their service makes every visit memorable.
- Is Old Chicago Pizza pet-friendly? Yes, this pet-friendly restaurant welcomes your furry friends so the whole family can enjoy a meal.
- What are the operating hours? The downtown location is open Thursday through Monday from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM and closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. The delivery and takeout location operates daily from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM.
- Do they offer gluten-free options? Yes, gluten-free thin crust pizzas are available for those with dietary preferences.
- Is parking available? Yes, there is convenient free parking nearby including street and lot options.
- Do they accept reservations? Yes, reservations are accepted for groups of seven or more.
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is not just about food; it’s about creating lasting memories. Patrons fondly recall family traditions, special celebrations, and friendly encounters with staff that make every visit feel like coming home. The iconic deep-dish pizzas, paired with the historic ambiance and excellent service, create a dining experience that stands out in the Sonoma County culinary scene.
Nestled in the heart of downtown Petaluma at 41 Petaluma Boulevard North, Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is a beloved culinary treasure with a rich history dating back to 1978. Housed within the Historic Lanmart Building, this iconic pizzeria has been delighting locals and visitors alike for over four decades with its authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas.
Since its establishment in 1978, Old Chicago Pizza has maintained a steadfast commitment to replicating the classic deep-dish experience that Chicago is famous for. The restaurant’s menu proudly features thick, buttery crusts layered generously with rich tomato sauce, high-quality cheeses, and savory toppings, crafting a pie that is truly to die for. Fans rave about their deep-dish pepperoni and sausage pizzas, which have become synonymous with the restaurant’s identity and charm.
Stepping inside Old Chicago Pizza is like stepping back in time. The restaurant boasts stunning red brick walls, classic chandeliers, and intriguing hallways that whisper stories of the past. Locals share intriguing tidbits, including rumors that the Historic Lanmart Building once housed a brothel, adding an alluring mystique to the dining experience. This unique ambiance, combined with attentive staff and a welcoming vibe, makes it a perfect spot for celebrations, family gatherings, or casual meals.
After more than 40 years as a cornerstone of Petaluma’s food scene, Old Chicago Pizza expanded its services in 2018 by reintroducing delivery options, bringing their famous deep-dish pies right to customers’ doors. This move enhanced accessibility while preserving the restaurant’s high standards of quality and comfort.
Consistency in style, comfort, and food has kept visitors coming back since 1979. Many patrons cherish the memories created here with family and friends, cementing it as a community staple.
- Authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas made with quality ingredients and generous portions.
- Historic setting in the Lanmart Building offering a unique ambiance rich with local character and stories.
- Friendly and attentive staff dedicated to creating an exceptional dining experience.
- Expanded delivery service since 2018 making it easier than ever to enjoy their famous pies from home.
- Authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas
- Historic and charming setting
- Friendly and attentive staff
- Variety of crust options including gluten-free
- Accommodates both dine-in and takeout orders
- Limited operating hours (closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays)
- Parking can be challenging in the area
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is perfect for families, pizza lovers, and anyone looking to enjoy a hearty meal in a charming setting. It's also a great choice for casual gatherings and celebrations.
Reservations are recommended, especially during weekends. The restaurant is family-friendly and offers a menu for children. Be aware of the limited parking options nearby.
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant stands out as a beloved establishment in Petaluma, offering a delightful experience with its deep-dish pizzas and warm ambiance. With a rich history since 1979, it continues to be a favorite for locals and visitors alike.
Nestled in the heart of downtown Petaluma at 41 Petaluma Boulevard North, Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is a beloved culinary landmark known for its authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas. This iconic eatery invites locals and visitors alike to experience a slice of Chicago tradition, expertly crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and served in a warm, historic setting dating back to the late 1970s.
Old Chicago Pizza is renowned for its signature deep dish pizza, a hearty, buttery crust layered with generous toppings and rich tomato sauce that has earned rave reviews from locals who call it the best pizza in Sonoma County. Beyond the classic deep-dish, the menu features a variety of pizzas including crispy thin crust, gluten-free thin crust, and indulgent double crust pies, ensuring there’s a perfect option for every palate.
- Deep Dish Pizza: Traditional Chicago-style deep-dish pizza with a variety of toppings priced at $16.85.
- Thin Crust Pizza: Crispy thin crust pizza with multiple topping choices for $14.20.
- Gluten-Free Thin Crust Pizza: A gluten-free alternative with a selection of toppings, priced at $17.70.
- Double Crust Pizza: A double-layered crust pizza topped with two toppings for $19.50.
Complement your meal with flavorful sides like garlic bread or the pesto garlic bread, freshly baked to warm your appetite. For those seeking a lighter option, the chicken dinner salad is topped with grilled chicken breast, delivering a fresh balance of flavors. Save room for dessert with decadent choices such as an individual cheesecake or the gluten-free flourless chocolate tort that perfectly finishes your dining experience.
- Garlic Bread: Freshly baked bread with garlic butter, $3.50.
- Pesto Garlic Bread: Garlic bread infused with pesto flavor, $3.75.
- Individual Cheesecake: Rich and creamy individual servings, $5.50.
- Flourless Chocolate Tort: Gluten-free chocolate dessert, $5.50.
Old Chicago Pizza not only delivers mouthwatering food but also an inviting dining experience. The historic building’s charming red brick walls and cozy ambiance evoke nostalgia, making every visit memorable. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, guests enjoy friendly service from attentive staff. The restaurant welcomes families, groups, and pizza lovers with amenities including free parking, acceptance of credit and debit cards, and options for beer and wine to complement your meal.
