Home

Download

NO BAD **RECOMMENDATIONS**.

Stockholm, Sweden

Black Milk Gastro Bar

Gothenburg, Sweden

Brasserie Draken

Malmö, Sweden

Mutantur

The most popular restaurants in Nova Circle right now

TRENDING NOW

Kenya Safari

with Great Plains Conservation

in Maasai Mara

Guide to

Eat, Stay & Do

Rio de Janeiro

in Sweden

The Most Unique Spas

EAT & STAY

Summer in Europe

Explore curated travel guides filled with hidden gems and top recommendations to inspire your next adventure.

TRAVEL GUIDES

Discover standout moments and top picks from our vibrant community of travelers and explorers.

USER HIGHLIGHTS

Meet our most active and inspiring community members sharing unique recommendations and insights.

TOP USERS

New Launch: August 2025

Zimbabwe

Mpala Jena Private Villas

for Your Next Long Haul Flight

Beauty Hacks

Luxury Travel on a Budget

How To:

for a Stress-Free Trip

Top 10 Travel Hacks

with 30% discount

Get Lounge Access

Stay updated with the latest travel tips, trends, and exciting updates from the Nova Circle community.

NEWS

Stockholm

Dog Friendly Dining

Explore

Koh Samui

A Tropical Getaway

Best Smoothie Bowls

Travel Guide

Koh Kood

Island Escape

 Find fresh ideas and experiences to discover, from must-visit spots to unique activities.

MORE INSPIRATION

Connect with trusted partners who share our passion for unforgettable experiences and quality travel.

OUR SELECTED PARTNERS

Nova Circle is your single space for saving and sharing top recommendations around the world while getting inspired by likeminded people.

Nova Circle - No Bad Recommendations

As a valued Nova Circle member you can enjoy our exclusive partner discounts. Simply just sign in to claim the deals.

Partner Discounts

Enjoy exclusive travel partner discounts with Nova Circle.

Nova Circle Benefits - Travel Partner Discounts

Benefits

Fleming Island

Customers frequently praise the authentic New York-style pizza, friendly staff, and generous portion sizes. Some reviews mention occasional inconsistencies in food quality and service.

New York Pizza Fleming Island Experience Your Slice of Authentic New York in Florida's Clay County!

Tucked away at 1811 Golden Eagle Way #25 in the heart of Fleming Island, Florida, New York Pizza Fleming Island serves up an irresistible taste of genuine New York-style pizza that has locals and visitors raving. This vibrant spot is a haven for pizza enthusiasts looking for flavor-packed pies with a perfect crust — crunchy yet tender — and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio that truly delights. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or crave a meat lover’s dream, their generous toppings and fresh ingredients deliver on every bite.

While pizza stands as the highlight, the menu at New York Pizza Fleming Island offers an array of savory options that satisfy diverse cravings. From their famous garlic knots drizzled in garlic butter to mouth-watering buffalo fries touted as the best in town, each dish is crafted with care. The restaurant also caters to vegan diners with customizable options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious meal. And for those looking to enjoy dessert after their main course, sweet options are available to round out the experience.

This family-friendly eatery boasts a clean, modern interior with options for outdoor seating — perfect for warm Florida days. The friendly and efficient staff enhance the welcoming vibe, making it a great spot for groups and children alike. Accessibility is a priority here, with wheelchair access available. Parking is hassle-free with free lot and street parking nearby, and payment options include major credit and debit cards, catering to convenience for every visitor.

Customers often highlight the authenticity of the New York-style pizza, praising the quality ingredients and sizable portions that satisfy big appetites. Friendly staff and a comfortable atmosphere earn consistent appreciation, making this spot a beloved fixture in Fleming Island’s dining scene. While occasional inconsistencies in service or food quality surface, the overall community sentiment remains decidedly positive.

What are the operating hours of New York Pizza Fleming Island?

 The restaurant operates from 10:30 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday, 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM Friday and Saturday, and 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Sunday.

 Yes, delivery is available so you can enjoy their tasty offerings at home or on-the-go.

 Yes, guests can savor their meals in the fresh air with outdoor seating options.

 While primarily focused on traditional dishes, some menu items can be customized to suit vegan preferences.

 Yes, the establishment is equipped to accommodate wheelchair users for a comfortable dining experience.

North America

United States

Nestled in the heart of Fleming Island, New York Pizza offers a delightful escape for pizza lovers and casual diners alike. With its inviting atmosphere and a menu that echoes the vibrant streets of New York, this establishment is a must-visit. The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, enticing guests to indulge in a culinary experience that feels both familiar and exciting.

The menu at New York Pizza is a treasure trove of flavors, featuring standout dishes that are sure to please any palate. The **BBQ Chicken Pizza** is a fan favorite, boasting a perfect balance of smoky barbecue sauce, tender chicken, and a medley of fresh toppings. Each slice is a burst of flavor, with a crust that strikes the ideal balance between crispy and chewy. Another highlight is the **Garlic Knots**, which are generously drizzled with garlic butter and served warm, making them the perfect appetizer or side. Guests rave about their deliciousness, often ordering extra to take home.

Conveniently located at 1811 Golden Eagle Way, New York Pizza is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. The surrounding area is rich with attractions, including the scenic **Fleming Island Marina**, where you can enjoy a leisurely stroll or engage in water activities. For those looking to explore further, the nearby **Clay County Historical Museum** offers insights into the region's past, making it a great complement to your dining experience.

New York Pizza is renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza, featuring a perfect crust and a variety of delicious toppings.

It's a great spot for families and friends to enjoy delicious pizza in a relaxed setting, with options for takeout and delivery.

New York Pizza is open for lunch and dinner, making it a convenient choice for any meal.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, New York Pizza is the perfect destination for a satisfying meal. Come and experience the flavors of New York right here in Fleming Island. We look forward to welcoming you!

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUMzME03aTlnRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ8ccBgErF5YgRvdubSZNWkJQ/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUMzME03aTlnRRAB

Great Pizza. Super flavorful. I loved it because it wasnt super greasy!!! Would have been 5 years but they charge over 3 dollars per topping. A bit steep to sprinkle a few black olives on a pie. The buffalo fries were the best fries I have ever had.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQ5dXVqb0d3EAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ8ccBgErF5YgRvdubSZNWkJQ/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUQ5dXVqb0d3EAE

Update: got the caesar salad; t was delicious!

For my lunch of 2 slices of pizza (BBQ and chicken & ranch), 2 garlic knots, and a drink, it was just over $10. It was plenty of food for the price. The pizza was really good, my favorite being the ranch one. The garlic knots were amazing, as well as the garlic butter drizzled over them. Their drinks right now ate bottled only, but a variety to choose from including Gatorade, soda, energy drinks, tea, or water. The restaurant was clean and modern. The staff were friendly and efficient in their service.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNfN0lYcjdRRRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ8ccBgErF5YgRvdubSZNWkJQ/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNfN0lYcjdRRRAB

Great pizza!. 1st time ordering and I always get a pepperoni and an all meat for the test. The crust was amazing and the sauce was amazing and cheese was not scarce. The meats portions were great. I’ll definitely be back again. Also showed me the pizzas a plus!.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNUcDZURDh3RRAB&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ8ccBgErF5YgRvdubSZNWkJQ/reviews/ChdDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSUNUcDZURDh3RRAB

Love the Pizza!  We're New Yorkers who have NOT had good NY Pizza in Florida. Well, the search is over! New York Pizza delivered!  My husband and I are very please.  The crust was perfect! Crunchy, but not Burned.  The sauce and cheese ratio was distributed perfectly.  What a delight! I can't wait to try other items on the menu.

https://www.google.com/local/review/rap/report?postId=ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmaE9fR2ZnEAE&d=17924085&t=1

places/ChIJ8ccBgErF5YgRvdubSZNWkJQ/reviews/ChZDSUhNMG9nS0VJQ0FnSURmaE9fR2ZnEAE

Best pizza in town NOT just Fleming Island folks! We moved here in June & have eaten here 5 or 6 times. Never even slightly dissatisfied. Wings (bourbon something) are large & cooked perfect every time Soooo good!
*UPDATE*
I just picked up our order & upon paying she flipped the register screen around toward me with the TIP AMOUNT displayed. I hate that these restaurants do this now since Covid. Do not ask me to tip! A tip is just that... a TIP for great svc & quality of product. It's not entitled, it's rude AF to ask for a tip. The $10 bill in my hand went right back into my pocket.So as much as I like this pizza & wings this will be our last order. Am I wrong? Do you think it's rude to ask for a tip?

Best New York Pizza in Fleming Island, FL - Family Friendly Dining

New York Pizza Fleming Island is a family-owned pizzeria known for its authentic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes. It has been serving the Fleming Island community with a focus on quality ingredients and customer service.

The history of new york pizza fleming island: a local favorite for authentic italian cuisine in florida 

Nestled in the heart of Fleming Island, Florida, New York Pizza Fleming Island has become a beloved destination for those craving genuine New York-style pizza and classic Italian fare. This family-owned pizzeria opened its doors in 2016 with the ambitious vision of bringing a slice of New York's culinary tradition to the local community. Since then, it has steadily cultivated a reputation for quality and authentic flavors that resonate with both locals and visitors alike.

When New York Pizza Fleming Island first opened in 2016, it quickly became a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts seeking the distinctive thin crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and generous cheese layers that define authentic New York-style pizza. The pizzeria's commitment to freshness and traditional preparation methods set it apart in the Clay County dining scene. By 2018, it had earned significant recognition for its dedication to replicating the original New York pizza experience, drawing patrons from across the region.

In response to growing customer demand and to enrich its culinary offerings, New York Pizza Fleming Island expanded its menu in 2020. Alongside its signature pizzas, the restaurant began serving a variety of Italian dishes, embracing the rich heritage of Italian cuisine. This evolution has allowed it to cater to diverse tastes while maintaining the exceptional quality and flavor that customers expect. The combination of a warm, family-owned atmosphere with consistently delicious food has solidified its status as a staple for both casual lunches and family dinners.

why new york pizza fleming island stands out

 crafted with care to reflect true East Coast flavors.

 offering a versatile range of dishes beyond pizza for a fuller dining experience.

 that fosters a welcoming and friendly atmosphere for all guests.

Dine In

Takeout

Delivery

Restroom

Outdoor Seating

Good for Children

Good for Groups

In the heart of Fleming Island, a charming gem of a community in Clay County, lies a delightful haven for pizza enthusiasts – New York Pizza. This warm and inviting establishment is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary journey that transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York City with every delicious slice. The moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough mingled with rich tomato sauce and a medley of melted cheeses envelops you like a comforting embrace. Savor the vivid colors and lively chatter that add to the restaurant's vibrant atmosphere, making it the ideal spot for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends. Each pizza is crafted with care, boasting an array of toppings that caters to all palates – from traditional pepperoni to inventive veggie combinations that will delight even the most discerning tastes. Beyond the stellar pizza, the menu offers an irresistible selection of subs and salads, perfect for a quick bite or a leisurely meal. Just a short drive from the scenic banks of the St. Johns River, New York Pizza stands as a cozy pitstop for travelers seeking adventure or locals craving comfort food. The surrounding area invites exploration, with parks and waterways perfect for outdoor activities, ensuring your culinary escapade can be complemented with nature's beauty. Whether you’re here for the food, the fun, or both, a visit to New York Pizza on Golden Eagle Way promises unforgettable flavors and a sense of community that will linger long after your last bite.

New York Pizza Fleming Island

In the heart of Fleming Island, New York Pizza is a delightful haven for pizza enthusiasts, offering a culinary journey with every delicious slice. The warm atmosphere and array of toppings cater to all palates, making it the ideal spot for family dinners or casual nights out. Beyond pizza, the menu includes subs and salads, perfect for a quick bite or leisurely meal.

Authentic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients.

Cheese Pizza Slice

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Garlic Knots

Buffalo Chicken Wings

Caprese Salad

New York Pizza Fleming Island Menu

New York Pizza Fleming Island Menu Overview - Authentic Italian Feasts in Florida's Heartland

Step into New York Pizza Fleming Island for a true taste of authentic New York-style pizza and Italian dishes crafted with the freshest ingredients. Nestled in the welcoming community of Fleming Island, Florida, this gem offers a menu designed to delight lovers of classic flavors and vibrant culinary traditions.

Begin your meal with inviting appetizers that set the stage for the flavors to come. The Garlic Knots are a crowd favorite, featuring perfectly baked pizza dough infused with rich garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese — a warm, savory treat that complements any dish.

Garlic Knots made with pizza dough, garlic, butter, and parmesan cheese.

Antipasti Salad combining mixed greens, salami, ham, mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato, cucumber, red onion, olives, and vinaigrette dressing.

Delight in classic New York-style pizza slices prepared with a perfect balance of crust, sauce, and cheese that keeps locals coming back. The Cheese Pizza Slice offers a timeless combination of rich tomato sauce and melted cheese on a crisp pizza dough base, while the Pepperoni Pizza elevates this with generous slices of savory pepperoni atop the cheese.

For a heartier Italian indulgence, the Calzone is a must-try. This folded pizza dough creation is stuffed with creamy ricotta and mozzarella cheeses, complemented by layers of ham, salami, and a savory tomato sauce that melds into every bite.

Cheese Pizza Slice with cheese, tomato sauce, and pizza dough.

Pepperoni Pizza topped with pepperoni, cheese, tomato sauce, and pizza dough.

Calzone with pizza dough, ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese, ham, salami, and tomato sauce.

Complete your dining experience with scrumptious desserts and a selection of bottled drinks — including sodas, energy drinks, and refreshing iced tea — that perfectly complement the bold and fresh flavors of your meal.

Among the standout items, the Buffalo Fries have earned rave reviews for their bold flavor and crispy texture, making them a must-try side. Friendly service and a modern, clean atmosphere enhance the experience, making New York Pizza Fleming Island a top choice for families, groups, and anyone craving authentic, flavorful pizza in Clay County.

Savor authentic flavors at New York Pizza in Fleming Island. Indulge in delicious pizza, fresh ingredients, and a cozy atmosphere. Order now!

New York Pizza in Fleming Island - Tasty & Cozy Dining

Clay County

Enjoy your favorite pizzas delivered to your doorstep.

Order ahead and pick up your meal at your convenience.

New York Pizza Fleming Island: Authentic Flavors in a Friendly Setting 

Nestled at 1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island, New York Pizza Fleming Island brings the iconic taste of New York-style pizza right to the heart of Florida. This inviting spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike who crave 

 without the heavy greasiness that often drowns out quality toppings. Whether you’re a Fleming Island native, a foodie on the hunt for the best pies, or a digital nomad needing a reliable and tasty meal, this pizzeria delivers a satisfying experience.

Delicious menu highlights and specialties

From classic pepperoni and all-meat pies to innovative options like BBQ chicken and chicken & ranch pizzas, every slice is crafted with care. The crust maintains the perfect balance—crispy yet never burnt—with a rich sauce and ample cheese. Don’t miss the garlic knots, generously drizzled with garlic butter, praised as "amazing" by regulars.

 have also earned rave reviews, regarded as some of the best fries around. For lighter fare, the Caesar salad is a delicious choice that complements the hearty pizzas perfectly. The menu also includes desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth after a savory meal.

Convenient dining options and family-friendly atmosphere

New York Pizza Fleming Island offers a variety of ways to enjoy its menu. Whether you prefer a relaxed dine-in experience with 

, the convenience of takeout, or the comfort of having your meal delivered, they’ve got you covered. This flexibility makes it ideal for family dinners, casual meetups, or a quick lunch break.

 - Enjoy your favorite pizzas and Italian dishes delivered straight to your doorstep.

 - Order ahead and pick up your meal when it’s most convenient for you.

 - Dine comfortably in a fresh air environment perfect for groups and families.

Why locals and visitors love New York Pizza Fleming Island

With a welcoming, clean, and modern setting, the restaurant is praised for friendly and efficient service. Customers appreciate the generous portions of meats and toppings, and the balanced flavors of crust, sauce, and cheese that create a truly satisfying slice. Plus, it’s a great spot for families, offering a kids’ menu and a casual atmosphere where everyone can feel at home.

 and easy access make visits hassle-free, while multiple payment options add convenience to every transaction. Whether you’re craving a quick slice or planning a group meal, New York Pizza Fleming Island lives up to its name with authentic New York-style pizza that Florida locals rave about.

Florida

Indulge in delicious, authentic New York-style pizza at New York Pizza Fleming Island. Enjoy family-friendly dining and outdoor seating. Order now!

Savor Authentic NY Pizza in Fleming Island, FL

Explore exciting dining itineraries around Fleming Island, including must-try dishes at New York Pizza. Satisfy your pizza cravings today!

Delicious Itineraries for New York Pizza Fleming Island

Discover the story of New York Pizza Fleming Island, known for its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. Join our pizza-loving community!

Best New York Pizza in Fleming Island, FL - Family Friendly Dining

Dining & Culinary Delights.

Location & Nearby Attractions.

FAQs.

Visit Us Today!