Nestled in Tampa's vibrant Ybor City Historic District, New York New York Pizza serves up generous slices of true New York-style pizza that have quickly become a local favorite. Known for its easygoing atmosphere and tantalizing menu that goes beyond pizza to include hearty sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and calzones, this spot is a must-visit for foodies craving authentic flavors and satisfying portions.
What keeps locals and visitors coming back? It’s the perfect blend of generous, flavorful slices and attentive service. The crust is thin and perfectly baked, with just the right balance of crispiness and chew. Specialty pies like Florentine and meat lovers delight every palate, while vegetarian options ensure everyone finds a slice they love. The staff’s warmth and attentiveness add to the welcoming vibe, making every visit memorable.
Pro tip: Try multiple slices to savor the variety — many guests rave about the gourmet pizza options and the flavorful sauces that make each bite unforgettable.
- Dine-in with an inviting ambience that’s more relaxed than the bustling strip — perfect for groups and families.
- Outdoor seating available for those who enjoy dining al fresco in Tampa’s warm climate.
- Convenient takeout and delivery services, including DoorDash, for pizza on the go or late-night cravings.
- Gluten-free crust options to accommodate various dietary needs without compromising flavor.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? New York New York Pizza operates from 10:00 AM to 12:00 AM on Sundays through Wednesdays, and extends to 3:00 AM on Thursdays through Saturdays.
- Do they offer gluten-free options? Yes, the restaurant provides gluten-free pizza crusts for those with dietary restrictions.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, the restaurant offers outdoor seating for patrons who prefer dining al fresco.
- Do they accept reservations? Yes, reservations are accepted, especially during peak hours and weekends.
- Is delivery available? Yes, delivery services are available through various platforms, including DoorDash.
The community embraces New York New York Pizza as a staple in Tampa’s dining scene, praising its authentic taste, hearty portions, and friendly service. While a few patrons have shared critiques about occasional inconsistencies like doughiness or dryness, the overwhelmingly positive reviews highlight its status as a dependable spot for satisfying pizza lovers. Whether you're grabbing a late-night slice, enjoying a meal with family, or ordering delivery, this pizzeria delivers an unmistakable New York charm right in the heart of Ybor City.
Located at 1512 East 7th Avenue in the vibrant Ybor City Historic District of Tampa, Florida, New York New York Pizza has firmly established itself as a beloved local eatery since its inception in 2015. This pizzeria is renowned for delivering an authentic New York-style pizza experience right in the heart of Tampa, delighting pizza enthusiasts with generous portions and flavorful crusts that evoke the classic tastes of the Big Apple.
The restaurant's journey began in 2015, quickly becoming a staple for locals and visitors craving genuine New York pizza flavors. Recognizing the diverse needs of its clientele, New York New York Pizza expanded its offerings in 2017 to include gluten-free options, reflecting a commitment to inclusivity and dietary preferences. Continuing its evolution, in 2019, the pizzeria introduced convenient late-night delivery services, catering to night owls and those seeking a slice at any hour.
Beyond pizza, New York New York Pizza offers an easygoing atmosphere with a menu that has grown to include plentiful sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and calzones, perfect for families and groups. The addition of an outdoor seating area in 2021 enhanced the dining experience by providing a relaxed setting to enjoy meals in the fresh air. The restaurant serves beer and wine, complementing its hearty Italian-inspired dishes, and welcomes children with a dedicated kids menu.
New York New York Pizza ensures a seamless visit with multiple payment options including NFC, debit, and credit cards, alongside cash acceptance. Parking is readily accessible with free street parking as well as paid options nearby, making it easy for guests to stop by. Amenities such as restrooms and accommodations for groups add to the convenience, while the welcoming staff enhances the overall friendly vibe.
The pizzeria enjoys a loyal following, praised for its enormous, delicious slices and attentive service. Guests often highlight the perfectly baked crust and gourmet pizza options. While the majority of reviews are glowing, some patrons have expressed disappointment over topping quantity and pricing, reflecting the subjective nature of taste and expectations. Nevertheless, New York New York Pizza remains a staple in Tampa's culinary scene, celebrated for its authentic approach and dynamic menu.
- 2015 : Restaurant established in Tampa, Florida.
- 2017 : Expanded menu to include gluten-free options.
- 2019 : Introduced late-night delivery services.
- 2021 : Opened outdoor seating area to accommodate more guests.
Located in the vibrant Ybor City Historic District of Tampa, New York New York Pizza offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza. Known for its enormous slices and friendly service, this pizzeria is a staple for both locals and visitors. With a menu that includes a variety of gourmet pizzas, sandwiches, and more, it caters to diverse tastes. The restaurant's casual atmosphere makes it an inviting spot for families and groups alike.
- Authentic New York-style pizza with large slices.
- Friendly and attentive staff.
- Variety of menu options including gluten-free pizza.
- Good for groups and families.
- Inconsistent quality reported by some customers.
- Some complaints about soggy crusts.
- Limited indoor seating can lead to wait times.
- Some diners have noted excessive grease.
New York New York Pizza is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, friends gathering for game nights, or anyone craving a hearty slice of pizza. It’s also a great spot for those exploring the historic Ybor City area.
- Parking is available on the street and in nearby lots.
- Takeout and delivery options are available.
- Reservations are not accepted.
New York New York Pizza stands out for its authentic flavors and generous portions. While there are occasional inconsistencies, the overall experience is enjoyable, thanks to the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this pizzeria is worth a stop for a satisfying meal.
Nestled in the heart of Tampa's vibrant Ybor City Historic District, New York New York Pizza at 1512 East 7th Avenue serves up an authentic slice of Italian comfort with a modern twist. This local favorite is a must-visit for anyone craving classic, hearty pizza and flavorful Italian dishes in a lively yet welcoming atmosphere.
Known for its generous slices with perfectly baked crusts, New York New York Pizza offers a variety of gourmet pies that satisfy every taste bud. From classic meat lovers to the lush Florentine, each pizza is baked just right, boasting a delicious blend of sauces and toppings that reflect true Italian roots. Beyond pizza, the menu features plentiful sandwiches, wraps, savory burgers, and calzones — making it a versatile spot for lunch or dinner.
The ambiance strikes a perfect balance, more subdued than the noisier spots on the strip, ideal for groups, families, and casual dates alike. Outdoor seating is available for those who enjoy dining under the Florida sun or stars. Attentive staff ensure your drinks are constantly refilled and your dining experience is top-notch.
Whether you’re looking to dine in, pick up a quick meal, or enjoy your favorite Italian comfort food delivered right to your doorstep, New York New York Pizza has you covered. They offer convenient takeout and delivery services, making it easy to enjoy their signature dishes wherever you are. Planning a party or corporate event? Their catering service features a variety of menu items perfect for any gathering.
- Dine-in with a cozy and inviting atmosphere, including outdoor seating options.
- Takeout service for guests on the go.
- Delivery bringing their delicious pizzas and Italian favorites straight to your door.
- Catering services ideal for events and celebrations of all sizes.
Conveniently located at 1512 East 7th Avenue in Tampa's iconic Ybor City Historic District, this pizzeria is easy to find and offers ample parking options, including free street parking and paid lots nearby. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, stopping by New York New York Pizza is a delicious way to experience Tampa’s culinary scene.
This easygoing pizzeria stands out by delivering generous portions of expertly crafted pizzas and Italian favorites at a great value. Their menu suits vegetarians and families, with kid-friendly selections and accommodating staff. The combination of flavor, variety, and welcoming service makes it a cornerstone of Tampa’s dining landscape.
- Generous and delicious pizza slices that satisfy diverse tastes.
- Varied menu options including sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and calzones.
- Family and kid-friendly environment with menu items for children and attentive service.
- Multiple service options including dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering.
