Nestled in the heart of Temple Terrace, Florida, New York New York Pizza brings a slice of the Big Apple right to your neighborhood. Famous for its crispy yet foldable crust, this pizzeria captures the true essence of authentic New York-style pizza that food enthusiasts and locals rave about. From generous toppings and rich, flavorful sauces to expertly crafted gourmet pies, every pizza is a celebration of classic flavors with a modern twist.
Whether you're grabbing a quick slice for lunch or enjoying a relaxed family dinner, New York New York Pizza offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels just like home. With dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, it caters perfectly to busy digital nomads, local families, and trend-conscious travelers craving quality pizza. The restaurant also features outdoor seating, ideal for those sunny Florida days when you want to savor your meal al fresco.
Beyond classic New York slices, the menu boasts a variety of gourmet pizzas such as the Supreme with perfectly balanced toppings, as well as strombolis and calzones. Notably, gluten-free options are available, making it a great choice for guests with dietary restrictions. Dessert lovers can indulge in sweet treats that round out the flavorful experience.
- Friendly and attentive service that makes every visit enjoyable.
- Generous toppings and bold flavors that satisfy even the most discerning pizza lovers.
- Family- and pet-friendly environment welcoming guests of all ages and their furry friends.
- What are the operating hours of New York New York Pizza? The restaurant operates from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday through Thursday, 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM Friday and Saturday, and 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Sunday.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, orders can be placed online or by phone for convenient delivery to your location.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, enjoy your meal at the outdoor seating area perfect for sunny Florida weather.
- Are there gluten-free options on the menu? Yes, they offer gluten-free pizzas to accommodate dietary needs.
- Is the restaurant pet-friendly? Yes, feel free to bring your pets along while you enjoy your meal.
The Temple Terrace community embraces New York New York Pizza for its consistent quality and authentic taste. Customers frequently highlight the "awesome" counter staff and the surprisingly great New York/New Jersey-style pizza found far from the Northeast. While most reviews celebrate the generous toppings and quick service, a few have noted concerns around order accuracy, emphasizing the restaurant's focus on improving customer service.
Overall community sentiment is positive
Whether you're a local resident or a visitor passing through Temple Terrace, this pizzeria promises a satisfying, slice-centric experience that honors tradition while welcoming all guests with open arms.
Nestled in the vibrant community of Temple Terrace, Florida, New York New York Pizza has become a cherished culinary landmark since its establishment in 2007. This family-owned restaurant quickly earned a reputation for serving authentic New York-style pizza that captures the essence of Italian-American cuisine with every slice.
In 2010, just three years after opening, New York New York Pizza expanded its offerings to include a diverse array of Italian dishes, enhancing its appeal to a broader audience seeking more than just pizza. This strategic move showcased the restaurant's commitment to delivering an authentic Italian dining experience.
The renovation of the dining area in 2015 elevated the atmosphere, creating a welcoming space that complements their flavorful menu and fosters a sense of community among diners.
Recognizing the need to meet evolving customer preferences, New York New York Pizza introduced online ordering and delivery services in 2020. This advancement allowed the restaurant to extend its reach within Temple Terrace and beyond, ensuring that fans of their classic New York-style pizza and Italian specialties could enjoy their meals with convenience and ease.
- Authenticity – Known for its true New York-style pizza, replicating traditional recipes and flavors that resonate with pizza lovers.
- Family-owned warmth – The restaurant prides itself on friendly customer service and fostering a welcoming environment for all guests.
- Community focus – It has cultivated a loyal local following through consistent quality and adapting to customer needs.
Located at 5509 E Fowler Ave, Temple Terrace, FL, New York New York Pizza offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza in a friendly atmosphere. Known for its generous toppings and gluten-free options, this establishment has become a local favorite for pizza lovers. With dine-in, takeout, and delivery services available, it caters to a variety of dining preferences.
The restaurant's inviting ambiance and friendly service make it a great spot for families and friends to gather over delicious slices. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, it has garnered positive reviews from patrons who appreciate the consistent flavor and generous portions.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Generous toppings
- Friendly service
- Gluten-free options
- Pet-friendly outdoor seating
- Occasional food quality inconsistencies
- Limited indoor seating
- No reservations accepted
Families looking for a casual dining experience, friends gathering for a game night, or anyone craving authentic pizza will find New York New York Pizza to be a perfect choice.
Parking is available with both free street and lot options. The restaurant is pet-friendly, allowing for outdoor seating with your furry friends. Be prepared for possible wait times during peak hours, as no reservations are accepted.
New York New York Pizza stands out for its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. While there are some inconsistencies in food quality and limited seating, the overall experience is enjoyable. Ideal for casual dining, it remains a beloved spot in Temple Terrace.
Nestled in the heart of Temple Terrace, Florida, New York New York Pizza serves up a slice of the Big Apple with their renowned New York and New Jersey style pizzas. This local favorite offers an inviting dine-in experience accompanied by convenient takeout and delivery options, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers, families, and groups seeking delicious comfort food in a friendly atmosphere.
New York New York Pizza offers a tempting selection of offerings that cater to both casual snackers and hearty appetites. The pizza by the slice selection lets you indulge in classics like cheese and pepperoni for just $3 a slice — perfect for a quick, flavorful bite any time of day. Their lunch specials provide incredible value at $5, ideal for a satisfying midday meal without breaking the bank. Plus, for ultimate convenience, their delivery service brings fresh, hot pizza right to your doorstep at no additional cost.
This gem in Temple Terrace truly nails the authentic NY/NJ pizza flavor profile — a fact echoed by numerous patrons who rave about the perfectly balanced toppings, generous portions, and consistent quality. The dough boasts a crisp yet chewy crust, crafted to satisfy even the most discerning pizza aficionados. Beyond pizza, they also serve strombolis, calzones, and desserts, making it a versatile spot for both lunch and dinner.
New York New York Pizza welcomes families with children, offering a kids’ menu and a comfortable dining environment. Ample free parking, including both a lot and street parking, makes it easy to visit without hassle. Payment options are flexible with NFC, credit, and debit cards accepted, ensuring a smooth transaction. While the restaurant does not serve alcohol or coffee, the focus remains firmly on delivering exceptional pizza and savory Italian-American dishes.
- Consistently authentic flavor that captures the essence of NY/NJ pizza culture.
- Affordable pricing with slices as low as $3 and great lunch deals.
- Convenient dining and delivery options to suit your schedule and preferences.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with a menu that includes options for children.
