Nestled in the vibrant community of Orlando, Florida, the New York Pizza Company brings a genuine slice of the Big Apple right to 18406 East Colonial Drive. This local favorite is a hotspot for pizza enthusiasts craving that classic New York-style pie, known for its thin, foldable crust and rich, savory toppings. Whether you're a longtime resident or a traveler passing through Orange County, this gem offers a memorable dining experience with friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere.
At New York Pizza Company, the focus is on delivering high-quality, authentic flavors that transport you straight to New York City’s bustling pizzerias. Customers rave about the generous portions of crispy, hot wings and flavorful meatball subs, perfect for game day or a casual lunch. The pizza dough strikes a balance between classic thinness and satisfying chewiness, topped with premium ingredients that keep guests coming back for more. This spot is especially popular among Wedgefield locals looking for a dependable and delicious option on the east side of Colonial Drive.
Dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup options make it easy and convenient to enjoy your favorite meal. Plus, the restaurant welcomes families with children and is wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable visit for everyone.
The New York Pizza Company enjoys a lively mix of feedback from the community. Many diners praise it as the best pizza on the east side of Colonial Drive, applauding the authentic taste and friendly staff who make every visit feel personal. However, some customers have noted occasional inconsistencies in food preparation and flavor, reminding us that every pizza joint has its highs and lows. Overall, the heartfelt passion for New York-style pizza shines through, making this an exciting spot to explore for those seeking a slice of classic flavor with a local Orlando twist.
- What are the operating hours of New York Pizza Company? Sunday: 12:00 PM–9:00 PM; Monday to Thursday: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM; Friday and Saturday: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM.
- Do they offer gluten-free options? Yes, they provide a selection of gluten-free pizzas and other menu items.
- Is there parking available at the restaurant? Yes, there is parking available for customers.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, the restaurant offers delivery; orders can be placed online or by phone.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, it is wheelchair accessible to accommodate all guests.
Nestled in the heart of Orlando, Florida, New York Pizza Company has carved out a special place for itself as a family-owned gem dedicated to serving authentic New York-style pizza. Known for its signature thin-crust slices, perfectly seasoned calzones, crispy wings, and a variety of other classic New York favorites, this establishment prides itself on bringing the true taste of New York City to the East Colonial Drive area.
Authenticity is at the core of New York Pizza Company's philosophy. With a menu that faithfully replicates the beloved flavors of New York City’s pizzerias, it offers locals and visitors alike a genuine taste experience that stands out from typical pizza spots. Whether dining in, ordering takeout, or opting for delivery, customers enjoy a slice of New York comfort wherever they are.
While New York Pizza Company is a relatively recent addition to Orlando’s vibrant food scene, it has quickly made a name for itself with a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The establishment primarily offers takeout, delivery, and catering services, making it a convenient option for families, office parties, and casual gatherings.
- 2025 milestone: Website under construction; customers are encouraged to place orders or make inquiries via the phone number 630-999-5239.
As the business continues to grow, plans for an enhanced digital presence are underway, ensuring easier access and streamlined ordering for its loyal patrons. Despite these developments, the company's focus remains on maintaining the same high standards for food quality and customer service that have earned it rave reviews from the local community.
The welcoming atmosphere at New York Pizza Company makes it a favorite spot for families and food enthusiasts looking for that iconic New York taste. Its convenient location on East Colonial Drive provides ample free parking options, including street and lot parking, enhancing accessibility for visitors. The establishment caters to diverse preferences with dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup, along with delivery services that bring the flavors straight to your door.
- Family owned and operated ensuring a personal commitment to quality and friendly service.
- Menu specialties include authentic New York-style pizza, calzones, and wings, crafted from high-quality ingredients.
- Multiple service options including dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering to fit various needs and occasions.
For those seeking a true New York pizza experience while visiting Orlando, New York Pizza Company offers a flavorful journey that combines tradition, quality, and community spirit. Its ongoing commitment to excellence makes it a beloved destination for locals and travelers alike who crave a slice of the Big Apple’s culinary charm right in Central Florida.
Located at 18406 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL, New York Pizza Company serves authentic New York-style pizza, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, this establishment has quickly become a favorite for pizza lovers in the area.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Friendly service
- Convenient takeout and delivery options
- Gluten-free options available
- Family-friendly atmosphere
- Some reviews mention issues with food quality during peak hours
- Limited seating capacity
Families looking for a casual dining experience, sports fans wanting a quick bite during games, and anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza will find New York Pizza Company to be a perfect choice.
New York Pizza Company offers both dine-in and takeout options, making it convenient for those on the go. It's advisable to check peak hours to avoid long waits, especially during weekends.
New York Pizza Company stands out for its commitment to quality and taste, delivering a slice of New York right to Orlando. With a welcoming atmosphere and a menu that caters to various dietary needs, it’s a spot worth visiting for anyone in the area.
Nestled along East Colonial Drive in vibrant Orlando, the New York Pizza Company offers an unbeatable taste of authentic New York style pizza right in the heart of Florida. This hidden gem is perfect for anyone craving a piping hot slice with that classic thin crust and fresh toppings that New Yorkers rave about. Whether you're a local resident or a traveler exploring the city, this pizza spot guarantees a memorable dining experience with a welcoming neighborhood vibe.
Whether you're in the mood to sit down and savor your meal or enjoy the convenience of dining at home, New York Pizza Company has you covered. Their dine-in space offers a cozy atmosphere where you can indulge in freshly prepared pizza, wings, and subs. Prefer to stay in? Order online or call ahead for takeout and delivery services, ensuring your meal arrives hot and fresh. Plus, with curbside pickup available, grabbing your favorite slice is quicker and safer than ever.
New York Pizza Company serves up a delicious variety of offerings beyond just pizza. Their wings are crispy and flavorful — often praised for their size and perfect seasoning. Meatball subs are a standout, combining savory meatballs with fresh bread and tasty sauces. Customers frequently comment on the "spot-on" New York style crust, despite the location being far from the Big Apple. This makes it a perfect destination for those searching for a genuine NYC pizza experience in Orlando.
- Takeout & Delivery - Convenient online ordering and phone service ensure your favorite meals are ready for pickup or delivered right to your door.
- Catering Services - Ideal for events and gatherings, their catering options bring authentic New York pizza flavors to your special occasion.
New York Pizza Company welcomes families with open arms. The restaurant is well-suited for children, making it a relaxed spot for a casual meal any day of the week. Parking is a breeze with free lot and street parking available nearby, and the establishment accepts credit cards for hassle-free payments. Restroom facilities are on site for your convenience, ensuring a comfortable dining experience.
Authenticity - Real New York style pizza that Orlando locals and visitors rave about.
Friendly Service - A welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff who treat you like family.
Value - Quality ingredients at great prices, making it a go-to for regular pizza cravings.
For anyone in Orlando seeking a slice of New York’s iconic pizza culture, the New York Pizza Company on 18406 E Colonial Dr is a must-visit. From quick lunches to family dinners and party catering, they deliver consistently delicious pies with genuine personality. Come for the pizza, stay for the friendly neighborhood atmosphere — this is the spot to satisfy your pizza cravings in Orlando's east side.
