Nestled in the heart of Kissimmee at 3158 Bill Beck Boulevard, The New York Pizza Company offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza right in sunny Florida. Known for its perfectly balanced dough, rich tomato sauce, and generous cheese, this pizzeria is a beloved gem for locals and visitors craving genuine Italian-American flavors. Whether you're a foodie searching for the best pizza near Disney or a family looking for a welcoming spot to enjoy classic slices, this place delivers an experience worth savoring.
This pizzeria excels in offering more than just pizza. From crispy wings and hearty calzones to fresh salads and delectable desserts, the menu caters to a wide range of tastes. Diners love the "by-the-slice" option, which brings a true New York feel and convenience. The restaurant's inviting booths are perfect for relaxed meals, and the friendly service adds to the warm, neighborhood vibe.
The establishment is family-friendly and welcomes groups, making it ideal for gatherings and casual outings. While there is no outdoor seating or alcohol served, the spot offers free parking and accepts multiple payment methods including credit and debit cards as well as NFC payments, ensuring convenience for all guests.
The New York Pizza Company in Kissimmee enjoys a strong reputation among locals and tourists alike. Customers frequently praise the authenticity of the pizza — especially the cheese and pepperoni slices — calling it a true "taste of home" for those familiar with New York's renowned pizza culture. Many commend the friendly staff and the family-oriented atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for groups and children.
While most experiences are positive, some patrons note occasional inconsistencies in service or pizza preparation, such as a burnt crust on delivery orders. However, the restaurant is known for addressing feedback courteously and encouraging customers to try dining in for the best experience. Overall, affordability combined with high-quality New York-style offerings ensures its continued popularity in the Kissimmee dining scene.
- Location — 3158 Bill Beck Blvd, Kissimmee, FL 34744, USA.
- Operating Hours — Monday to Thursday: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM, Friday and Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM, Sunday: 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM.
- Services Offered — Dine-in, takeout, and delivery available with vegetarian options and a kids' menu.
- Parking and Accessibility — Free parking lot and street parking available; wheelchair accessible.
- Payment Methods — Accepts credit and debit cards, NFC payments; no cash only policy.
- What are the operating hours of The New York Pizza Company? The New York Pizza Company operates Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, The New York Pizza Company offers delivery services.
- Is there parking available at the restaurant? Yes, there is parking available at The New York Pizza Company.
- Do they accept credit cards? Yes, The New York Pizza Company accepts credit cards.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, The New York Pizza Company is wheelchair accessible.
Nestled in the heart of Kissimmee, Florida, The New York Pizza Company is a cherished family-owned gem that offers a true taste of authentic New York-style pizza and Italian cuisine. Since its inception, this vibrant restaurant has become a beloved spot for locals and tourists eager to savor New York's iconic flavors in a warm, welcoming environment.
Founded in 2018, The New York Pizza Company embarked on a delicious journey to bring the classic New York pizza experience to Florida. From the very beginning, it distinguished itself with perfectly crafted dough, balanced sauce, and generous cheese toppings that echo the Big Apple’s traditional style. This commitment to quality quickly earned the eatery a loyal following.
By 2020, the restaurant expanded its menu beyond pizza to include popular Italian-American favorites such as calzones, wings, and enticing daily specials, enhancing its appeal to a broader crowd seeking variety and bold flavors.
In tune with modern dining trends, The New York Pizza Company introduced online ordering options in 2022, streamlining pickup and delivery services for greater convenience. This innovation helped the restaurant reach more customers, making authentic New York pizza accessible at home or on the go.
The year 2024 marked a special milestone as the restaurant celebrated its 6th anniversary. This celebration was highlighted by special promotions and community events, reflecting the establishment’s deep connection to Kissimmee and its patrons. The New York Pizza Company continues to be a hub for families and groups seeking a genuine, satisfying meal with a slice of New York’s culinary spirit.
- Authentic New York style pizza crafted with care and traditional recipes.
- Expanded menu options including calzones, wings, and daily specials from 2020 onward.
- Convenient online ordering introduced in 2022 for pickup and delivery.
- A strong community presence with anniversary celebrations and local engagement.
Located at 3158 Bill Beck Blvd, Kissimmee, FL, The New York Pizza Company offers a slice of authentic New York-style pizza in a family-friendly environment. This establishment serves a variety of menu options, including calzones and wings, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers. With a welcoming atmosphere and affordable pricing, it's a great choice for both dine-in and takeout.
The New York Pizza Company has garnered positive reviews for its delicious cheese and pepperoni slices, with many patrons noting the authentic taste reminiscent of New York. However, some customers have mentioned inconsistent service and occasional issues with food quality.
Overall, The New York Pizza Company is a delightful spot for those craving a taste of New York in Kissimmee.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Variety of menu options including calzones, wings, and daily specials
- Friendly and welcoming atmosphere
- Affordable pricing
- Family-friendly environment
- Inconsistent service quality
- Some reviews mention burnt or undercooked food
- Limited online ordering availability
Families looking for a casual dining experience, pizza lovers craving authentic New York-style slices, and groups wanting a friendly atmosphere.
The restaurant offers both dine-in and takeout options. Parking is available with free street and lot parking. Be prepared for possible wait times during peak hours.
The New York Pizza Company stands out for its authentic pizza and welcoming atmosphere. While there are some inconsistencies in service and food quality, the overall experience is enjoyable, making it a worthwhile stop for pizza enthusiasts.
Located at 3158 Bill Beck Boulevard, The New York Pizza Company offers a cozy spot to enjoy classic New York pizza pies and slices that capture the true essence of the city’s famous flavors. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or a full meal, this pizzeria caters to all tastes with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes.
At the heart of their offerings is pizza by the slice, starting at just $2.50. Choose from the iconic classic cheese or create your own slice with a variety of toppings to satisfy your pizza cravings. For a hearty meal, try their calzones, filled with ham, ricotta, mozzarella, and served with marinara sauce for $9.99.
For those who love a meaty and flavorful option, the stromboli is a must-try. Packed with ham, salami, pepperoni, sausage, onions, mozzarella, and complemented by a side of marinara sauce, it’s priced at $10.99. Garlic knots, a perfect appetizer or side, come with a delicious marinara dip for $3.99, while buffalo-style chicken wings are available for $11.99 to add a little spice to your meal.
Don't miss out on the Jamaican beef patties, a flavorful pastry filled with seasoned beef for just $3.25. This diverse menu ensures that everyone from pizza aficionados to adventurous eaters finds something to enjoy.
This pizzeria is perfect for food lovers seeking an authentic New York pizza experience in Kissimmee. Whether you want to dine in at their comfortable booths or take your meal to go, The New York Pizza Company provides flexible options including delivery and takeout. They serve lunch and dinner daily and welcome families with kid-friendly menu choices.
Free parking, including a lot and street parking, makes visiting hassle-free, while multiple payment options like NFC, credit, and debit cards enhance convenience. The restaurant is noted for its friendly service and consistently delicious slices, with many patrons praising the perfect balance of dough, sauce, and cheese that brings the true New York taste to Florida.
- Good for groups: Ample seating options and menu variety make group dining easy and enjoyable.
- Kid-friendly menu: Small eaters have their own menu choices, ensuring a family-friendly visit.
- Vegetarian options: Those who prefer meat-free dishes will find satisfying vegetarian-friendly choices.
