Nestled in the heart of Milton, Florida, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen offers more than just pizza — it delivers a delightful blast from the past with its vibrant 1950s retro decor and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families, foodies, and nostalgic souls alike. This beloved local spot at 5227 Willing Street is renowned for its specialty pizzas, homemade fudge, and unique beverages including Florida fruit wines, beer, and classic cocktails, making it a must-visit destination for a memorable dining experience.
At Boomerang Pizza Kitchen, every pizza is crafted with attention to detail, featuring a variety of specialty toppings including the fan-favorite buffalo chicken and build-your-own options loaded with pepperoni, meatballs, ricotta, and a surprising hot honey drizzle on a garlic butter crust. The restaurant accommodates diverse dietary needs with gluten-free crust options, ensuring everyone can enjoy their cheesy, flavorful creations. Complement your meal with appetizers like mac and cheese or indulge in their famous homemade fudge and sweet treats.
Perfect for families and groups, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen is designed with a playful and welcoming vibe. The nostalgic 50s theme is complemented by a kids’ play area and a curated gift shop featuring vintage toys, candies, and local products, making it a fun stop for visitors of all ages. Friendly staff enhance your experience, helping celebrate special moments like birthdays, and the spacious interior allows for relaxing dine-in service, alongside convenient takeout and delivery options.
Positive community sentiment highlights the charm of Boomerang Pizza Kitchen as a local favorite. Guests praise the friendly staff, the authentic retro ambiance, and the delicious specialty pizzas that keep them coming back. While some have experienced minor service delays or order mix-ups, the overall experience is warm and enjoyable, especially for families looking for a fun and tasty night out in Santa Rosa County.
- What are the operating hours of Boomerang Pizza Kitchen? The restaurant operates Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. It is closed on Mondays.
- Do they offer gluten-free options? Yes, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen provides gluten-free crust options for their pizzas.
- Is there a gift shop at the restaurant? Yes, the restaurant features a gift shop offering a variety of retro items, including vintage toys, candies, and local products.
- Do they serve alcohol? Yes, they serve a selection of Florida fruit wines, beer, and cocktails.
- Is the restaurant family-friendly? Absolutely, the restaurant is family-friendly, featuring a kids' play area and a nostalgic atmosphere that appeals to all ages.
Nestled in the heart of Milton, Florida, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen began its mouthwatering journey in 2015 as a family-owned pizzeria that quickly captivated locals and visitors alike with its authentic New York-style pizzas. The establishment embraces a distinctive retro 50s vibe, creating a nostalgic ambiance that perfectly complements the delicious food experience. Owner and pizza maestro trained by the renowned 11-time world pizza champion Tony Gemignani, brings expert craftsmanship to every pie, making it a must-visit destination for pizza lovers.
Since its grand opening in 2015, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen has made impactful strides that enhanced its charm and offerings:
- 2015 - Opened as a family-owned pizzeria in Milton, FL, instantly becoming a neighborhood favorite for authentic New York-style pizza.
- 2015 - Added a delightful gift shop area, showcasing retro collectibles alongside their signature homemade fudge that quickly became a local treat.
- 2015 - Expanded beverage options by introducing a curated selection of Florida fruit wines, enhancing the unique dining experience and celebrating local flavors.
Boomerang Pizza Kitchen combines traditional pizza-making with quality ingredients such as Grande cheese and a homemade sauce, delivering specialty pizzas that tantalize taste buds. Beyond pizza, guests can indulge in rich homemade fudge and sip on locally inspired fruit wines, making it a distinctive spot in Milton’s dining landscape. The retro 50s decor not only provides a cool, vibrant backdrop but also invites guests to step back in time, making every visit both a culinary and cultural experience.
Located at 5227 Willing St, Milton, FL, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen offers a nostalgic dining experience with its authentic New York-style pizza. The restaurant combines a retro 50s and 60s ambiance with a menu featuring homemade fudge and unique Florida fruit wines. Ideal for families and pizza lovers alike, this establishment is known for its friendly service and high-quality ingredients.
With dine-in, takeout, and delivery options available, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen caters to various dining preferences, making it a convenient choice for locals and visitors.
The restaurant's unique decor, featuring vintage board games and nostalgic items, adds to the charm, creating a welcoming environment for all ages.
Overall, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen is a delightful spot for anyone craving delicious pizza in a fun, retro setting.
Pros
• Authentic New York-style pizza
• Nostalgic 50s and 60s ambiance
• Friendly and attentive staff
• Homemade fudge and desserts
• Unique Florida fruit wines
• Gluten-free options available
Cons
• Limited operating hours
• No delivery service
• No online menu available
• No reservations accepted
Ideal for
• Family dinners
• Casual gatherings with friends
• Celebrating special occasions
Things to know before visiting
• Parking is available on-site and on the street.
• The restaurant is family-friendly and offers a children's menu.
Overall impression
Boomerang Pizza Kitchen offers a unique blend of nostalgic vibes and quality food, making it a worthwhile stop in Milton. While there are some operational limitations, the warm atmosphere and delicious pizza make it a place worth visiting.
Nestled in the heart of Milton, Florida, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen delivers a distinctive dining experience that blends a quaint, metro vibe with a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families, foodies, and local explorers alike. Located at 5227 Willing Street, this charming spot invites guests to enjoy freshly crafted pizzas alongside unique local offerings that celebrate the flavors of the Sunshine State.
Boomerang Pizza Kitchen stands out with its hand-tossed pizzas, featuring creative toppings such as buffalo chicken, pepperoni, meatballs, ricotta, and a tantalizing hot honey drizzle on a garlic butter crust. This spot caters to all tastes, including vegetarian options, ensuring everyone finds a favorite. Families praise the attentive service and relaxed, inviting décor that makes celebrations, like birthday dinners, extra special. Whether dining in or ordering takeout or delivery, guests appreciate the efficient, friendly experience and the spacious, old-school atmosphere that’s larger than it appears from outside.
Beyond pizza, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen delights guests with sweet treats and beverages that showcase local flavor. Indulge in homemade fudge available in several delicious varieties including chocolate peanut butter, dark chocolate caramel sea salt, cookies and cream, and mint chocolate swirl — each a rich, decadent choice priced affordably. For those seeking a unique sip, the menu features Florida Fruit Wines crafted exclusively from native fruits like blueberry, mango, pineapple, and orange, offering fresh and fruity notes for an unforgettable tasting experience.
- Dine-in and takeout options make it easy to enjoy your meal your way.
- Family-friendly environment with a children's menu ensures dining fun for all ages.
- Accepts credit, debit, and NFC payments for smooth, modern transactions.
- Free parking available both on the street and in a lot nearby.
- Serves beer and wine to complement your meal.
Whether you're a local craving a fresh, flavorful pizza or a visitor exploring Milton's culinary gems, Boomerang Pizza Kitchen offers a memorable taste of community spirit, quality food, and warm hospitality.
