Nestled on the bustling Saint George Street in St. Augustine, Florida, Pizza Time stands as a beloved no-frills pizzeria serving up authentic New York-style pizza by the slice. This cozy spot is a must-visit for food enthusiasts craving flavorful pies with a crisp crust and generous toppings, all crafted with a dedication to classic pizza-making traditions. Whether you're a local or a traveler exploring the historic district, Pizza Time offers an inviting atmosphere that balances quick service with quality food.
Pizza Time is renowned for its quick-moving lines despite busy times, a testament to the efficient and friendly staff who keep guests satisfied even during peak hours. The pizzeria's menu features favorites like the Grandma and Mediterranean slices, paired wonderfully with their affordable wine and sangria specials. The dining area, though limited, offers a charming space to enjoy your meal once you’ve ordered. Attention to detail like reheating slices to hot, crispy perfection ensures every bite delights the palate.
While Pizza Time excels in delivering tasty slices with a nostalgic New York flair, some visitors have noted a few quirks. The establishment operates on a cash-only basis, which can be inconvenient for those who prefer card payments, but an ATM is conveniently available on site. Pricing is not always visible upfront, and slices are priced around $10 each, which some guests find steep. The restaurant enforces some house rules like allowing seated guests only after ordering and limiting refills to one per person. Despite these, the overall dining experience remains positive for many.
- Does Pizza Time accept credit cards? No, Pizza Time operates on a cash-only basis. An ATM is available on-site for customer convenience.
- What are the operating hours of Pizza Time? Pizza Time is open Monday through Thursday from 10:30 AM to 10:30 PM, and Friday through Sunday from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM.
- Is there seating available at Pizza Time? Yes, there is limited indoor seating available, but the establishment is primarily designed for takeout.
- Are there gluten-free options at Pizza Time? While Pizza Time offers a variety of pizzas, it's advisable to inquire directly about gluten-free options, as availability may vary.
- Is Pizza Time wheelchair accessible? Yes, the establishment is wheelchair accessible.
Pizza Time garners a mixed yet vibrant community response. Patrons consistently laud the pizzeria for its authentic New York-style slices, friendly staff, and efficient service that keeps the long lines moving. However, some express reservations about the price point, cash-only policy, and lack of visible pricing, which can impact the overall experience. Despite these, the establishment remains a popular destination for both locals and visitors seeking a satisfying slice in the heart of St. Augustine's historic district.
For those eager to explore classic New York pizza flavors amid the charm of Florida's oldest city, Pizza Time offers a taste that’s worth discovering.
Established in 2005, Pizza Time of St. Augustine has become a beloved destination for pizza lovers. With a vision to bring authentic Brooklyn-style pizza to Florida, the founders aimed to create a casual dining experience where quality and flavor reign supreme. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh ingredients and traditional techniques has earned it a reputation as one of the top pizzerias in the United States.
- 2005: Pizza Time of St. Augustine was established.
- 2015: Ranked as the second-highest rated pizzeria in the United States.
Pizza Time has become a staple in the Historic District of St. Augustine, attracting both locals and tourists alike. The restaurant's vibrant atmosphere reflects the community's rich history and culture, making it a perfect spot for families and friends to gather. Its commitment to quality and service has fostered a loyal customer base, contributing to the local economy and enhancing the culinary landscape of the area.
The founders of Pizza Time have dedicated their lives to perfecting the art of pizza making. Their passion for authentic New York-style pizza is evident in every slice served. The skilled chefs and staff contribute their expertise and warmth, ensuring that each customer feels welcomed. This team effort has solidified Pizza Time's reputation as a beloved dining destination.
Over the years, Pizza Time has adapted to changing tastes and dining trends while maintaining its core values. The menu has expanded to include a variety of toppings and specialty pizzas, catering to diverse palates. The restaurant has embraced technology, offering online ordering and social media engagement to connect with its customers. This evolution has allowed Pizza Time to remain relevant and continue thriving in a competitive market.
As Pizza Time looks to the future, it remains committed to its founding principles of quality, community, and tradition. The restaurant continues to be a gathering place for friends and families, celebrating life's moments over delicious pizza. With a legacy built on passion and dedication, Pizza Time is poised to remain a cherished part of St. Augustine's culinary scene for years to come.
Located at 124 St George St in the Historic District of St. Augustine, Pizza Time is a no-frills pizzeria known for its wide selection of New York-style pies served by the slice. With a reputation for fresh and flavorful Brooklyn-style pizza, it has become a popular stop for locals and tourists alike. The restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, making it a convenient choice for pizza lovers.
- Fresh and flavorful Brooklyn-style pizza Variety of pizza options and sides Family-friendly atmosphere Free parking available at the Spanish Street entrance Takeout, delivery, and catering services offered
- Cash-only payment policy No displayed prices leading to unexpected costs Limited seating with potential long wait times Service perceived as rushed during peak hours No credit or debit card acceptance
Pizza Time is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, friends gathering for a quick bite, or anyone craving a delicious slice of pizza in a lively atmosphere.
- Be prepared for a cash-only payment policy. Expect potential wait times during peak hours. Order promptly upon entering as there is no menu displayed. Limited seating means you may need to share tables.
Pizza Time offers a delightful pizza experience with its fresh ingredients and a variety of options. While the cash-only policy and potential wait times may deter some, the quality of the pizza and the family-friendly atmosphere make it worth a visit. Whether you're a local or just passing through St. Augustine, this pizzeria is a satisfying stop for pizza lovers.
Nestled in the heart of the Historic District, Pizza Time at 124 St George St offers an authentic New York-style pizza experience that tantalizes the taste buds of foodies and local diners alike. Known for its no-nonsense approach, this cozy pizzeria specializes in delicious pies served by the slice, perfect for those craving a quick and satisfying meal in vibrant St Augustine, FL.
Pizza Time serves up classic New York-style pizza characterized by a perfectly crisp crust and a harmonious blend of flavorful sauce and cheese. Whether you opt for the popular Grandma slice or the Mediterranean pie, each slice is crafted to deliver a memorable flavor experience. Complement your pizza with their tasty garlic knots and a refreshing glass of sangria or wine, available daily with attractive deals.
Note : Seating is limited indoors and available only to customers who have placed their order, ensuring you will have a spot once your meal is ready. The pizzeria is wheelchair accessible, making it convenient for all visitors.
- Takeout - Enjoy delicious pizzas and savory sides to go, perfect for a quick and tasty meal on the move.
- Serves Alcohol - A selection of alcoholic beverages including wine and sangria to pair perfectly with your pizza.
- Highchairs Available - Families with young children will appreciate the availability of highchairs, making dining out hassle free.
- Wheelchair Accessible - The pizzeria is designed to be accessible to guests with mobility needs, welcoming everyone to enjoy their slice.
Pizza Time tends to attract a steady crowd, especially during peak hours and weekends. Arriving early can help you beat the line and secure seating more easily. Remember that while the spot is clean and well-organized, payment options include debit cards and cash, so be prepared accordingly. The restaurant does not offer outdoor seating or delivery, but the fast-moving queue ensures minimal wait times.
Parking advice : Paid parking lots and street parking are available nearby, providing convenient options for visitors traveling by car in the Historic District.
Whether you're a local or a traveler exploring St. Augustine, Pizza Time is a top choice for those seeking authentic New York-style pizza by the slice with a casual, welcoming vibe. Its balance of great flavors, family-friendly amenities, and efficient service make it a memorable stop for lunch or dinner in the historic city.
