Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu Overview

Step into the heart of Idaho Falls and experience the authentic taste of New York-style pizza at Lucy's New York Style Pizza. Known for their thin-crust perfection and vibrant atmosphere, Lucy's offers a deliciously diverse menu crafted with fresh, hand-tossed dough and premium ingredients. Whether you’re craving classic flavors or bold combinations, this local favorite has something to satisfy every pizza lover.

Starters

Begin your meal with a tempting array of starters that set the tone for a memorable dining experience. Indulge in the crispy Breadsticks, brushed with garlic butter and served alongside marinara. For cheese enthusiasts, the Cheesesticks deliver mozzarella-rich goodness, while Firesticks bring a spicy kick with buffalo sauce, jalapenos, and melted cheese atop crunchy breadsticks. The Fried Mutz offers breaded whole milk cheese paired with tangy marinara, and the hearty Meatball, a 10oz zesty masterpiece, is perfect for sharing. Don't miss the Wings, tossed in buffalo, sweet chili, or BBQ sauces, served with dressing for dipping.

Mains

The star of the menu is the wide selection of authentic New York-style pizzas, each boasting a hand-tossed thin crust and vibrant toppings. Meat lovers will relish the Meaty Pizza, loaded with pepperoni, ham, fresh pulled sausage, bacon, and zesty meatballs. Vegetarians can enjoy the Veggie Pizza, featuring mushrooms, onions, artichokes, peppers, and black olives. The Margherita Pizza offers a classic blend of olive oil and garlic sauce, fresh basil, and tomatoes for a fresh, simple bite.

For those craving a tropical twist, the Pacific Pizza pairs pineapple with ham, while the Supreme Pizza combines pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives for a balanced medley. The Zim Pizza is a bold choice with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes. Adventurous eaters will love the Zestpian Pizza, layered with ranch and BBQ sauces, pepperoni, ham, chicken, pineapple, bacon, and jalapenos. The CCB Pizza offers creamy ranch sauce with sliced chicken breast and bacon, and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza features savory chicken with signature buffalo sauce. The BBQ Chicken Pizza delights with seasoned chicken and smokey BBQ sauce, and the BLT Pizza is a feast of creamy ranch, bacon, fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and balsamic glaze. Don't forget the Red Sauce & Cheese Pizza for a straightforward favorite, or the Bronx Bomber Pizza with its indulgent double crust. Calzones are also available, with a classic cheese option for a satisfying main.

Desserts

End your meal on a sweet note with Lucy’s indulgent desserts. The Dessert Calzone is a decadent treat filled with Snickers, Milky Way, Reese's, 3 Musketeers, Twix, Oreo, Nutella, and cheesecake—a true chocolate lover’s dream. The Cannoli offers a crisp fried pastry shell with a sweet creamy filling, while the New York Cheesecake impresses with layers of cheesecake, fruit, dark chocolate, and caramel. For gluten-conscious dessert seekers, the Gluten-Free Brownie combines rich dark chocolate with luscious caramel sauce.

Drinks and Specials

Complement your meal with a selection of beer and wine thoughtfully curated to pair perfectly with Lucy’s rich flavors. Although cocktails are not on the menu, the beverage options are designed to enhance your dining experience. Keep an eye out for seasonal specials and pizza creations that showcase unique blends of sauces and toppings, making each visit a chance to discover something new.

Why choose Lucy's for your next meal

Authentic New York-style pizza crafted with fresh, hand-tossed dough and premium ingredients.
Wide variety of pizzas ranging from meat-packed to vegetarian and creative specialty pies.
Tantalizing starters and desserts to complement every craving and sweet tooth.
Casual, welcoming atmosphere ideal for groups, families, and solo diners alike.