Blame Butter Menu Overview
Blame Butter is a unique pie pop-up located in Chicago, IL, that redefines dessert with its artistic approach to pie-making. The culinary philosophy here revolves around creativity and quality, with a focus on using high-quality ingredients to craft visually stunning and delicious pies. The proprietor, Asa, infuses her passion for baking into each slice, making the experience not just about dessert but also about artistry. The shop operates from a small counter within a poke restaurant, creating a distinctive atmosphere that blends savory and sweet.
Signature Dishes
- Affair of the Heart: A delightful blend of blueberry compote, vanilla, and crème moulee, topped with fresh blackberries and elderflowers.
- The Gateway: A refreshing slice featuring apricots and raspberries with a crunchy Demerara topping.
- Creamy Cinnamon Pie: A rich pie with a brûléed top, served with a drizzle of rice and cinnamon crème fraîche.
- Fig Pie: A more traditional offering that showcases the classic flavors of fig in a creamy filling.
Beverages and Pairings
Blame Butter does not have a dedicated beverage menu, but the rich flavors of the pies pair well with coffee or tea. For a more indulgent experience, consider pairing a slice with a dessert wine or a light sparkling wine to enhance the sweetness of the pies.
Dietary Options
Blame Butter offers some options for dietary preferences, but it is primarily focused on traditional pie recipes. While there may be vegetarian options, specific vegan or gluten-free pies are not explicitly mentioned. Customers with allergies should inquire directly for ingredient details to ensure safe choices.
Chef Recommendations
Asa recommends trying the Affair of the Heart for its unique flavor combination and aesthetic appeal. Seasonal highlights may include special flavors that rotate based on ingredient availability, so it's worth checking back frequently. The staff is known for their passion and can provide insights into the best choices based on current offerings.
Experience the Menu at Blame Butter
Visiting Blame Butter is not just about enjoying a slice of pie; it’s an experience that combines art and flavor. With a limited selection that often sells out quickly, it's advisable to arrive early to secure your favorite slice. The unique presentation and the care taken in each order make it a must-visit for dessert lovers in Chicago. Don't miss out on this artistic pie adventure!






