Nestled in the heart of Boerum Hill, Brooklyn, Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market has been a cherished local gem since 1996. This family-owned seafood haven offers an impressive selection of ultra-fresh, sustainably sourced fish and shellfish that keeps aficionados coming back for over a decade. From line-caught striped bass and flounder from Long Island to succulent langoustines, tuna steaks, cockles, and soft shell crabs, every catch promises exceptional quality and flavor. The dedicated, knowledgeable team led by Nick, Chris, and Jose ensures each visit is a delightful experience, whether you're shopping for premium fish or indulging in their expertly prepared seafood dishes and soups.
If you crave the freshest seafood in Brooklyn, Fish Tales is the place to be. Customers rave about their tender crab legs and sashimi-grade fish, highlighting the market as an essential stop for seafood lovers. Beyond the superior product, the market's staff goes the extra mile, offering services like shrimp cleaning to make your cooking experience effortless. It's a perfect spot for busy locals who appreciate premium quality without compromise.
Fish Tales enjoys a glowing reputation among Brooklynites. Most visitors commend the friendly and knowledgeable team who consistently deliver high-quality seafood and personalized service. The market's warm atmosphere and local charm make it a beloved institution. While the majority praise the welcoming vibe, a handful of customers mention that the store has a close-knit group of regulars which can sometimes make newcomers feel less at ease. However, the quality and freshness of the seafood keep customers coming back time and again.
- What are the operating hours of Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market? Monday to Friday: 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM; Saturday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM; Sunday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM.
- Does Fish Tales offer delivery services? Yes, Fish Tales provides delivery services Monday to Friday from 2:00 PM to 4:30 PM, and Saturday from 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM. Last delivery orders are accepted 30 minutes before closing time.
- Is Fish Tales a family-owned business? Yes, Fish Tales has been a family-owned business since its inception in 1996, offering high-quality seafood and exceptional customer service.
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn's Boerum Hill neighborhood, Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market has been a beacon for fresh, high-quality seafood since its founding in 1996. This family-owned establishment was created by Larry Tramontano with a clear vision: to serve the local community with the freshest catches and impeccable customer service. Over the years, this market has become synonymous with seaside freshness right in New York City.
Just two years after its launch, in 1998, Fish Tales welcomed Larry's cousin, John Addis, as a partner. This family expansion strengthened the business's foundation and set the stage for continued success. When Larry retired in 2001, John took the helm and steered the market toward new opportunities, ensuring the legacy remained vibrant and customer-focused.
Fish Tales' dedication to quality and freshness earned it a spotlight on the Food Network's popular show 'Throwdown with Bobby Flay' in 2009, introducing their exceptional offerings to a wider audience. This exposure showcased their commitment to gourmet seafood and elevated their profile within the culinary community.
Celebrating 25 years in 2021, Fish Tales remains a cherished local gem in Brooklyn. The market is beloved for its diverse selection of fresh seafood, from line-caught striped bass and flounder to langoustines and sashimi-grade fish. The team behind the scenes is praised for their knowledgeable and friendly service, catering to both everyday seafood lovers and culinary professionals alike.
- 1996 Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market was founded by Larry Tramontano.
- 1998 Larry's cousin, John Addis, joined as a partner, reinforcing the family roots.
- 2001 John Addis took over the business after Larry's retirement, leading new growth.
- 2009 The market was featured on Food Network's 'Throwdown with Bobby Flay,' highlighting its gourmet seafood.
- 2021 Fish Tales celebrated its 25th anniversary, marking a quarter-century of excellence.
- High-quality, fresh seafood
- Exceptional customer service
- Diverse menu offerings
- Family-owned business
- Established reputation since 1996
- Prices may be higher than average
- Limited seating for dine-in
- No online ordering for prepared foods
Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market is perfect for seafood lovers, families looking for fresh ingredients, and home cooks wanting to prepare high-quality meals.
Be prepared for potentially higher prices and limited seating. It's advisable to visit during off-peak hours for a more relaxed shopping experience.
Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market stands out for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Despite some drawbacks, it remains a beloved destination for fresh seafood in Brooklyn.
Nestled in the heart of vibrant Boerum Hill, Brooklyn, Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market at 191A Court Street is a beloved destination for seafood aficionados craving the freshest ocean treasures. This lively market has been a cornerstone of the community for over a decade, renowned for its impressive variety of premium fish, shellfish, and specialty seafood that's sourced with care and expertise. Whether you're a local or a visiting foodie, Fish Tales offers a distinct blend of quality, convenience, and culinary inspiration that keeps customers coming back.
Fish Tales is your go-to spot for ultra-fresh, line-caught fish and succulent shellfish that wow even the most discerning palates. From Long Island striped bass and flounder to langoustines, tuna steaks, cockles, and soft shell crabs, every item is meticulously selected to guarantee peak freshness and flavor. Seafood lovers will appreciate the market's dedication to quality, with daily deliveries ensuring an ever-changing lineup of ocean delights perfect for home cooking or special recipes.
When you’re craving fantastic seafood but short on time, Fish Tales has you covered with an enticing range of prepared foods. Their menu features freshly made sandwiches, hearty soups, crisp salads, and daily specials crafted to satisfy any appetite. These ready-to-eat options are perfect for grabbing a quick lunch or bringing gourmet convenience to your dinner table.
Planning a special event or gathering? Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market offers professional catering services featuring their freshest seafood and prepared dishes. Whether it's an intimate dinner party or a larger celebration, their expertly crafted menus bring the best of the sea to your occasion, impressing guests with extraordinary flavors and impeccable quality.
- Ultra fresh seafood selection – Consistently praised for high-quality fish and shellfish that are delivered fresh daily.
- Convenient prepared foods – Ready-to-eat sandwiches, soups, and salads offer quick gourmet options for busy days.
- Catering expertise – Ideal for events, delivering fresh seafood dishes that elevate any occasion.
- Local favorite – A trusted neighborhood gem with many loyal customers returning for years.
