For All Things Good Bed-Stuy: A cozy mexican gem in brooklyn's heart.

Nestled in the vibrant Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn, For All Things Good Bed-Stuy is a snug Mexican restaurant that captivates locals and visitors with its authentic Oaxacan-inspired cuisine. Known for its expertly crafted tacos, quesadillas, and antojitos, this eatery boasts a menu that highlights fresh masa and tortillas made daily, delivering a genuine taste of Mexico in the heart of New York City.

Delightful dining experience and distinctive flavors

This quaint corner spot is beloved for its fresh tortillas and flavorful dishes like the tlayuda topped with a perfectly runny egg, spicy yet balanced chilaquiles, and the rich, thick tortilla soup bursting with blue corn tortilla pieces. The horchata coffee is a must-try, offering a heavy but delightful complement to the meal. The menu caters to all-day cravings, serving breakfast, lunch, brunch, dinner, and tempting desserts alongside a large wine and mezcal list.

Dine-in comfort is cozy, especially ideal for small parties of two, with outdoor seating available that welcomes dogs, perfect for enjoying Brooklyn’s lively streetscape.

Why locals and food lovers keep coming back

Patrons consistently praise the freshness and quality of the ingredients, with standout mentions of their tacos — touted as some of the best in New York — and the overall friendly service that makes every visit welcoming. While some dishes can be mild or a bit dry occasionally, the flavorful menu and vibrant atmosphere make it a beloved spot for authentic Mexican cuisine in Brooklyn.

Authentic Oaxacan-inspired menu with fresh masa and tortillas made daily.
Cozy indoor seating and charming dog-friendly outdoor patio.
Extensive wine and mezcal list perfect for pairing with bold Mexican flavors.
Family-friendly atmosphere with options for children, though no special kids' menu.
Convenient payment options including NFC, credit and debit cards, and delivery/takeout available.

Frequently asked questions

Do they accept walk-ins for brunch? Yes, walk-ins are accepted for brunch. However, it can get busier on weekends, so arriving early is recommended.
Is outdoor seating available? Yes, outdoor seating is available and is dog-friendly.
Are reservations required? Reservations are not required but are recommended, especially during peak hours.

Community vibe and sentiment

The community sentiment surrounding For All Things Good Bed-Stuy is highly positive, with many praising its dedication to authentic flavors and fresh ingredients. The cozy atmosphere, combined with attentive service, creates a welcoming space that feels like a neighborhood treasure. This beloved spot has become a go-to destination for those craving genuine Mexican fare in Brooklyn, offering a slice of Oaxacan tradition with every bite.

For All Things Good Bed-Stuy: A Brooklyn Gem of Mexican Culinary Tradition in Focus.

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant at 343 Franklin Avenue, For All Things Good Bed-Stuy stands as a beacon of authentic Mexican cuisine and culture in Brooklyn. Since its inception in 2020, this intimate café and boutique molino has captivated food lovers with its dedication to traditional Oaxacan flavors and handcrafted culinary techniques. Its specialty lies in the art of making fresh masa and tortillas, crafted from heirloom corn sourced directly from Mexican villages. This meticulous process involves nixtamalization and grinding with water on-site, producing some of the most celebrated tortillas in the borough.

Establishment and evolution

For All Things Good Bed-Stuy opened its doors in 2020, immediately distinguishing itself by delivering Oaxacan-inspired dishes with a focus on fresh, house-made tortillas. This fresh approach to masa and tortilla preparation, rare in New York dining, quickly drew attention from locals and food connoisseurs alike. The café's menu highlights include mushroom tlayuditas, hibiscus and chipotle salsa tetelas, and squash blossom quesadillas — dishes that showcase the vibrant, authentic flavors of Mexico using fresh, artisanal ingredients.

Recognition and growth

In 2021, barely a year after its launch, the café earned recognition from the MICHELIN Guide, cementing its reputation for culinary excellence within New York City. This prestigious acknowledgment celebrates the establishment's commitment to quality and authenticity, marking it as a must-visit destination for those seeking genuine Mexican flavors and expertly crafted dishes.

Boutique molino and fresh masa experience

By 2024, For All Things Good Bed-Stuy expanded beyond its café roots by adding a boutique molino to its offerings. This unique addition invites customers to take home the cornerstone of Mexican cooking — fresh masa. The molino enables patrons to purchase freshly nixtamalized and ground masa, ensuring their homemade tortillas and dishes capture the same vibrant flavors and textures that have made the café famous. This initiative deepens the connection between the Brooklyn community and authentic Mexican culinary traditions.

Why visit For All Things Good Bed-Stuy

Authentic Mexican cuisine featuring traditional Oaxacan dishes made with fresh, in-house masa and tortillas.
Boutique molino offering freshly ground masa for home cooking enthusiasts seeking authentic flavor.
Recognition by the MICHELIN Guide as a top culinary destination in Brooklyn.
A cozy, authentic atmosphere where guests can enjoy Mexican specialties including mushroom tlayuditas and squash blossom quesadillas.

Discovering For All Things Good Bed-Stuy: A cozy Mexican gem in Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood.

Nestled at 343 Franklin Ave in Brooklyn, For All Things Good Bed-Stuy offers a vibrant Mexican dining experience with a strong emphasis on authentic Oaxacan-inspired dishes. This snug eatery is celebrated for its fresh masa and tortillas made in-house, providing a distinctive taste that draws food lovers and locals alike. The atmosphere is cozy and casual, making it a welcoming spot for both casual lunches and relaxed dinners.

Menu highlights and drink offerings

The menu at For All Things Good features classics such as tacos, quesadillas, and antojitos that showcase traditional flavors with a modern twist. Guests often praise the perfectly runny egg atop the tlayuda and the flavorful tortilla soup enriched with blue corn tortillas. Vegetarians and vegans will find thoughtful options here, ensuring an inclusive dining experience. Complementing the food is an extensive wine and mezcal list, with mezcal frozen cocktails standing out as a delightful treat.

Ambiance and amenities

The restaurant's inviting vibe is enhanced by dog-friendly outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying Brooklyn's lively neighborhood atmosphere. Despite being a small space with limited indoor seating, it is well-suited for intimate gatherings, especially for parties of two. The venue serves all meals including breakfast, lunch, brunch, and dinner, catering to a variety of dining preferences. Payment options are modern and convenient, accepting credit, debit, and NFC payments.

Considerations before visiting

Visitors should be aware that For All Things Good can get quite busy during peak hours, especially on weekends, so planning ahead or arriving early may enhance your experience. Some guests have noted that certain dishes come with milder flavors and can be a bit dry, which might not suit those seeking bolder seasoning. Additionally, the limited indoor seating might feel cramped during busy times, making outdoor seating a preferred option when weather permits.

Pros Authentic Oaxacan-inspired dishes with fresh, house-made masa and tortillas; vegetarian and vegan-friendly options; cozy, casual atmosphere; dog-friendly outdoor seating; extensive mezcal and wine selection; positive food and service reviews.
Cons Can get busy during peak hours; limited indoor seating; some dishes have mild flavors and occasional dryness noted by diners.

Mexican

343 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

(646) 238-2068

Open Now - Closing 10:00 PM

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

08:00–15:00, 18:00–22:00

Wednesday

08:00–15:00, 18:00–22:00

Thursday

08:00–15:00, 18:00–22:00