Overview of the Menu
At New York Plate, the culinary philosophy revolves around a fusion of Mediterranean and American flavors, offering a diverse menu that caters to various tastes. The establishment emphasizes hearty portions and bold flavors, making it a popular choice among locals in Gary, Indiana. With an inviting atmosphere, it aims to provide a satisfying dining experience, whether you're enjoying a casual meal or a takeout feast.
Signature Dishes
- New York Plate: A hearty combination of gyro meat, chicken, rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $17.99. Manhattan Plate: Featuring steak, chicken, gyro meat, rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $19.99. Long Island: Fried shrimp served with rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $17.99. Coney Island: Fried catfish with rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $17.99.
- Gyro Platter: A classic dish featuring gyro meat, rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $14.99. Grilled Shrimp Plate: Grilled shrimp served with rice, grilled onions, green peppers, salad, pita bread, and New York sauce for $18.99.
Beverages and Pairings
While New York Plate does not serve alcoholic beverages, guests can enjoy a selection of refreshing soft drinks and iced teas. The sweet tea has received mixed reviews, but the other beverages complement the hearty dishes well.
Dietary Options
New York Plate offers limited dietary options, primarily focusing on hearty meat dishes. Currently, there are no specific vegetarian or vegan options available, and gluten-free choices are also minimal.
Chef Recommendations
The chef highly recommends the Manhattan Plate for its rich combination of flavors and generous portions. The Grilled Shrimp Plate is also a standout, offering a delightful seafood option that pairs well with the fresh salad.
Experience the Menu
Join us at New York Plate in Gary, Indiana, for a memorable meal that combines the best of Mediterranean and American cuisine. Whether you're dining in or taking out, the flavors await you.



