Overview of the menu
Big Gay Ice Cream, located in the vibrant Tribeca neighborhood of New York, offers a whimsical take on classic ice cream treats. The philosophy here revolves around celebrating diversity and joy through unique flavor combinations and playful presentations. Inspired by a mix of traditional and modern influences, the menu features soft serve creations that blend familiar ingredients with unexpected twists, appealing to both the nostalgic and adventurous palate.
Signature dishes
- Salty Pimp: Vanilla soft serve drizzled with dulce de leche, topped with sea salt and a chocolate dip.
- American Globs: A delightful mix of vanilla soft serve, pretzel pieces, and a rich chocolate dip.
- Rocky Roadhouse: A decadent chocolate soft serve topped with marshmallows, almonds, and chocolate bits.
- Dorothy: Vanilla soft serve layered with dulce de leche and Nilla wafers for a creamy texture.
- Mermaid Sundae: A refreshing blend of vanilla soft serve, key lime curd, whipped cream, and graham cracker crust.
- Strawberry Shortcake: Vanilla soft serve topped with luscious strawberry sauce and crunchy shortbread cookies.
Beverages and pairings
At Big Gay Ice Cream, the beverage menu complements the indulgent ice cream offerings perfectly. Offering a selection of freshly brewed coffee, guests can enjoy a smooth cup alongside their favorite soft serve. For a unique twist, try pairing the Salty Pimp with a rich espresso for a delightful contrast of flavors.
Dietary options
Big Gay Ice Cream is committed to inclusivity, offering a variety of dietary options. The menu features vegan soft serve, gluten-free cones, and allergen-friendly ingredients, ensuring that everyone can indulge in their sweet creations.
Chef recommendations
Seasonal highlights at Big Gay Ice Cream include the Mermaid Sundae, which perfectly captures the essence of summer with its zesty key lime curd. Regulars also rave about the Rocky Roadhouse as an all-time favorite, making it a must-try for chocolate lovers.
Experience the menu
Step into Big Gay Ice Cream and experience the fun and creativity of their ice cream menu. Whether you’re indulging in a classic like the Salty Pimp or exploring seasonal delights, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Visit Big Gay Ice Cream in New York and treat yourself to a scoop of happiness!






