Nestled on Broadway in the vibrant Upper West Side of New York City, Sal and Carmine Pizza serves up a mouthwatering slice of authentic New York-style pizza that captures the heart of locals and visitors alike. This family-run pizzeria, with roots dating back to 1959, offers a nostalgic atmosphere where the charm of old-school New York meets the bustling energy of Manhattan.
Sal and Carmine Pizza is a true gem for pizza lovers craving the perfect New York slice. Their pies boast a generous layer of rich, flavorful sauce paired with fresh mozzarella and expertly balanced toppings like pepperoni and sausage. The crust is a standout feature — offering a delightful combination of light, airy texture with a satisfying crunch that pizza aficionados seek.
Whether you prefer it straight from the oven or heated a bit longer for extra crunch, Sal and Carmine’s consistently delivers. Plus, the fair pricing makes it a fantastic spot for grabbing a generous slice or a whole pie without breaking the bank.
The pizzeria's interior features exposed brick walls and a cozy, narrow space with a handful of tables, inviting guests to enjoy their meals in a laid-back, friendly environment. With ample seating available, it’s a great spot to relax and share a slice with friends or family. The staff is known for their warmth and approachability, often engaging with customers and creating that neighborhood feel so cherished in New York’s dining scene.
Though it’s primarily a pizzeria, Sal and Carmine also accommodate takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy their classic slices wherever you are in the city. The venue is family-friendly and wheelchair accessible, ensuring that all guests can savor their authentic New York pizza experience.
- What are the operating hours of Sal and Carmine Pizza? Sal and Carmine Pizza operates from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Sundays and Mondays, and from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM on Tuesdays through Saturdays.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, Sal and Carmine Pizza offers delivery services through their website and various delivery platforms.
- Is there seating available for dining in? Yes, the pizzeria has a small seating area available for dine-in customers.
- Do they accept credit cards? Yes, Sal and Carmine Pizza accepts major credit and debit cards, as well as mobile payment options.
- Is the pizzeria wheelchair accessible? Yes, the establishment is wheelchair accessible, ensuring comfort for all patrons.
Overall, the community sentiment surrounding Sal and Carmine Pizza is overwhelmingly positive. Devoted patrons praise the pizzeria for its delicious, authentic slices, friendly service, and the cozy, nostalgic vibe that transports diners back to classic New York pizza parlors. Although a few have noted occasional inconsistencies, the majority embrace it as a cherished neighborhood staple on the Upper West Side.
If you’re exploring New York City and looking for an authentic pizza experience that combines quality, tradition, and a welcoming atmosphere, Sal and Carmine Pizza is a must-visit destination.
Nestled in the bustling Upper West Side of New York City, Sal and Carmine Pizza is a cherished institution that has served its community for over six decades. Established in 1959 by Sal Malanga, an Italian immigrant, this pizzeria has become synonymous with authentic New York-style pizza, characterized by crispy crusts, rich sauces, and generous toppings. As you step inside, the exposed brick walls and cozy seating create a welcoming atmosphere that invites both locals and tourists to enjoy a slice of history.
- 1959: Sal and Carmine Pizza was founded by Sal Malanga on the Upper West Side of New York City.
- 1987: The pizzeria relocated to its current address at 2671 Broadway.
- 2015: Sal and Carmine Pizza was inducted into the Pizza Hall of Fame.
- 2022: The pizzeria was featured in a list of the 18 best pizza slices in New York City by Eater NY critic Robert Sietsema.
The legacy of Sal and Carmine Pizza reflects not only the passion for crafting delicious pizza but also the warm community spirit of the Upper West Side. Each visit offers a chance to enjoy traditional recipes passed down through generations, all set against the backdrop of New York's vibrant culture. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, indulging in a slice at Sal and Carmine’s is more than just a meal; it’s an experience steeped in history.
Located at 2671 Broadway, New York, NY, Sal and Carmine Pizza has been serving authentic New York-style pizza for over 60 years. This establishment is a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, known for its generous toppings and casual atmosphere. The rich, flavorful sauce and perfectly crispy crust make it a must-try for pizza lovers.
- Authentic New York-style pizza
- Generous toppings
- Casual atmosphere
- Efficient service
- Cash-only payment policy
- Limited seating area
- No restroom facilities
Sal and Carmine Pizza is perfect for casual dining, family outings, or a quick bite after exploring the Upper West Side. Its relaxed vibe makes it a great spot for pizza enthusiasts of all ages.
- Bring cash, as they do not accept cards.
- Expect a wait during peak hours.
- Limited seating means you may need to wait for a table.
Sal and Carmine Pizza stands out as a quintessential New York pizza spot, offering a delightful experience for both locals and tourists. While it has its drawbacks, such as the cash-only policy and limited seating, the quality of the pizza and the friendly service make it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or dining in, this establishment is sure to satisfy your pizza cravings.
Nestled at 2671 Broadway in vibrant Manhattan, Sal and Carmine Pizza invites food lovers to indulge in an unforgettable New York-style pizza experience. This local gem serves up slices that perfectly balance tradition with a welcoming neighborhood vibe.
Sal and Carmine’s pizza is a celebration of classic flavors — think a rich, flavorful tomato sauce topped generously on a crust that strikes the perfect balance between light, airy, and satisfyingly crispy. Made with fresh mozzarella and lovingly prepared toppings like pepperoni and sausage, each slice brings the essence of New York’s iconic pizza culture to your table.
Fair prices and generous slice sizes make it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike who want big flavor without breaking the bank.
Whether you're looking to soak in the cozy, spacious interior or prefer to enjoy your meal on the go, Sal and Carmine Pizza has you covered. Their offerings include:
- Delivery – Enjoy our pizzas delivered fresh right to your doorstep.
- Takeout – Order ahead and pick up your meal at your convenience.
- Dine-in – Experience the cozy atmosphere and friendly service while enjoying your pizza fresh from the oven.
Sal and Carmine Pizza welcomes families with children, providing a warm and inviting space that’s perfect for casual lunches and dinners. Despite the absence of a specialized kids’ menu, the classic pizza selections and affordable pricing make it a great spot for all ages.
Note: This establishment does not serve alcohol or coffee, and there are no on-site restrooms or valet parking available, making it a straightforward, no-frills pizzeria focused on great pizza and friendly vibes.
Regular patrons rave about the perfectly balanced sauce that harmonizes sweetness and savory notes, the fresh mozzarella’s creamy texture, and the crust that hits just the right thickness — not too thin, not too thick. If you crave an extra crunch, just ask for your slice to be heated a little longer. Friendly staff interactions and a spacious interior add to the charm, making Sal and Carmine a beloved spot for locals craving authentic New York pizza on the Upper West Side.
- What makes the pizza special – Flavorful sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a delightfully crispy crust.
- Location perks – Convenient Upper West Side setting with ample seating.
- Value for money – Generous slice sizes at wallet-friendly prices.
