Nestled on vibrant Nicollet Avenue in the Powderhorn neighborhood of Minneapolis, A Slice of New York brings the beloved flavors of authentic New York-style pizza to the Midwest. This cozy, no-nonsense pizzeria specializes in hand-tossed slices, subs, and Italian classics like calzones and stromboli, all served with a warm, local-friendly vibe.
Fans rave about the spot for its generous slice sizes, the tangy tomato sauce, and melty cheese that recalls classic NYC pizzerias. Many appreciate the friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere adorned with nostalgic New York memorabilia, creating an immersive pizza experience that feels like a quick trip to the Big Apple without leaving Minneapolis.
While some patrons suggest the crust could be a touch thinner for the perfect foldability and a more balanced flavor, this minor critique doesn’t overshadow the overall acclaim. Whether you’re craving a late-night slice or a family dinner spot that welcomes kids and groups, this pizzeria offers a satisfying taste of New York on Nicollet Avenue.
- Classic New York Style Slices: Large, foldable slices topped with tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese.
- Subs and Sandwiches: Authentic Italian-style subs filled with savory meats and cheeses.
- Calzones and Stromboli: Perfectly baked Italian pockets with a variety of fillings.
- Desserts: Sweet treats to round off your meal.
A Slice of New York welcomes dine-in guests and offers takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup options to suit busy lifestyles. The venue is family-friendly and wheelchair accessible but does not offer outdoor seating or alcoholic beverages. Payment is convenient with acceptance of credit, debit, and contactless NFC payments.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Monday to Thursday: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM; Friday and Saturday: 11:00 AM - Midnight; Sunday: Closed.
- Is there parking available? Yes, there is parking available in front of the restaurant and additional parking in the back.
- Do they offer delivery services? Yes, they offer delivery services through various platforms.
- Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible.
- Do they accept credit cards? Yes, they accept credit and debit cards.
The community around Powderhorn embraces A Slice of New York for delivering a genuine slice of NYC pizza culture. Customers consistently highlight the authentic flavors, generous portions, and the friendly team that makes every visit feel like a neighborhood gathering. Minor notes about crust thickness or service hiccups are far outweighed by the positive reviews praising the quality and atmosphere. Whether you're a local foodie, a digital nomad seeking a familiar bite, or a family looking for a kid-friendly spot, this pizzeria stands out as a beloved destination in Minneapolis for Italian comfort food.
Located at 2407 Nicollet Avenue in the Powderhorn neighborhood of Minneapolis, A Slice of New York has been serving up authentic New York-style pizza since its opening in 2010. From its inception, the restaurant set out to bring the unique flavor and style of New York pizza right to the heart of Minneapolis, quickly becoming a go-to spot for locals craving a true slice experience.
By 2015, A Slice of New York had expanded its offerings beyond classic slices to include a variety of Italian dishes such as calzones, stromboli, and even gyros, catering to a diverse palate. This expansion helped the restaurant build a loyal customer base that appreciated the cozy and casual dining environment paired with a rich menu selection.
In 2020, the eatery was widely recognized for its friendly service and inviting atmosphere, solidifying its role as a beloved local establishment. Many patrons praise its authentic New York-style pizza, highlighting the perfect balance of tomato sauce, cheese, and slice size, although some note areas for crust improvement. The combination of quality food and a welcoming vibe has made it a staple for families and groups looking for a satisfying meal in Minneapolis.
- Authentic New York-style pizza that captures the essence of the Big Apple’s iconic slice.
- Expansive menu featuring Italian classics such as calzones, stromboli, and gyros to satisfy diverse tastes.
- Cozy and inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience and builds community connection.
- Consistent commitment to quality and service that has earned loyal customers across Minneapolis.
Located in the vibrant Powderhorn neighborhood of Minneapolis, A Slice of New York is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts craving authentic New York-style fare. This cozy counter-service restaurant specializes in delivering delicious slices and pies, characterized by their perfect foldability and classic flavors. Whether you're indulging in a late-night bite or enjoying a casual lunch with friends, this eatery offers a welcoming atmosphere complemented by a menu that satisfies all taste buds. Ever since its inception, A Slice of New York has become a beloved spot where locals and visitors unite over mouthwatering pizza.
- Authentic New York-style pizza , Friendly and attentive staff , Late-night hours , Variety of menu options including calzones and desserts , Delivery and takeout services available
- Some reviews mention minor inconsistencies in crust thickness
- Limited seating capacity
- No online ordering system
A Slice of New York is perfect for anyone seeking a laid-back dining experience infused with the spirit of New York City. Families can enjoy a casual meal, friends can gather for late-night pizza runs, and pizza lovers will appreciate the authentic flavors. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner, this spot caters well to all occasions and groups, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied.
Before heading to A Slice of New York, it's worth noting that the establishment tends to get busy during peak hours, especially on weekends. While seating is limited, the atmosphere remains friendly and vibrant. The restaurant is open late, making it a great option for night owls. Additionally, they offer both delivery and takeout, ensuring that you can enjoy their pizza wherever you are. Bring cash or cards, as the restaurant accepts various payment methods, but no online ordering system is currently in place.
A Slice of New York stands out as a delightful pizza destination in Minneapolis, embodying the essence of New York-style pizza with its classic slices and engaging atmosphere. While there are minor areas for improvement, the overall experience is marked by genuine hospitality and flavorful offerings. From generous slice sizes to friendly staff, this restaurant continues to charm its patrons, making it a local favorite worth visiting. If you're in the Powderhorn area, be sure to stop by for a slice or two; they might just hit the spot!
Nestled in the vibrant Powderhorn neighborhood of Minneapolis, A Slice of New York brings authentic New York-style pizza straight to your plate. This no-nonsense spot at 2407 Nicollet Avenue captures the essence of NYC with its generously sized slices, tangy tomato sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. Whether you're craving a quick lunch or a comforting dinner, this pizzeria delivers a taste that keeps locals and visitors returning.
A Slice of New York prides itself on its simple yet flavorful menu. While their crust is a bit thicker than the traditional NYC foldable slice, the robust tomato sauce and generous cheese topping make each bite memorable. Vegetarian diners will appreciate the available meat-free options, and dessert lovers can indulge in sweet treats to round out their meal. Plus, with friendly staff creating a warm atmosphere, it’s a great spot for families and groups alike.
- Dine-in Enjoy your meal in the cozy dining area with a casual vibe, perfect for catching up with friends or family.
- Takeout Pick up your favorite slices or subs quickly and enjoy them wherever you please.
- Delivery Have piping hot New York-style pizza and subs delivered right to your doorstep, bringing the city’s flavors to your home.
Expect a genuine New York slice experience with a few Minneapolis twists. Reviewers often praise the flavorful tomato sauce and cheese blend, although some mention the crust could be thinner and more foldable. The vibe is laid-back and family-friendly, with amenities like restrooms and group seating. While they don’t serve alcohol or coffee, the focus remains on delivering authentic pizza and subs that satisfy any craving.
- Family friendly Suitable for children with a welcoming atmosphere.
- Payment options Accepts credit, debit cards, and NFC payments for ease and convenience.
Authenticity and accessibility define A Slice of New York. While some critiques note room for improvement in crust texture and topping distribution, the overall flavor profile hits the mark for New York pizza lovers in Minneapolis. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after work or ordering a full pie for a group gathering, the combination of classic taste and friendly service makes this spot a neighborhood favorite. Its central Powderhorn location adds to the charm, inviting you to stop by and savor a genuine New York slice right in the heart of Minneapolis.
