Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan's East Village, Emmy Squared Pizza offers a distinctive take on pizza that goes beyond the traditional slice. Famous for its Detroit-style square pizzas, the spot has quickly become a go-to destination for food lovers seeking bold, flavorful combinations in a cozy, brick-clad setting.
Emmy Squared stands out with its signature Colony Pizza, a mouthwatering square pie loaded with pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and a drizzle of honey that creates a perfect balance of spice and sweetness. Beyond pizza, the menu shines with the award-winning Le Big Matt burger, packed with flavor and a satisfying kick, as well as Italian sandwiches, crispy Zia fries, and cheesy garlic sticks that delight every palate.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options are thoughtfully included, making it a welcoming spot for diverse dietary needs. The vegan build-your-own pizza allows tailoring to personal tastes, although some diners have noted that the vegan cheese texture can be improved to match the classic gooeyness.
With its inviting brick décor and lively vibe, Emmy Squared is perfect for groups and casual outings alike. Patrons can enjoy outdoor seating in good weather, adding to the relaxed yet energetic ambiance. While the food consistently earns high marks for flavor, some visitors have experienced slower service during peak hours and occasional feelings of being rushed. Nonetheless, friendliness shines through, especially from the bartenders crafting excellent cocktails such as the popular Last Word.
Emmy Squared offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, making it easy to enjoy its signature dishes wherever you please. Reservations are available via OpenTable, and the restaurant accepts all major credit cards, including AMEX and Visa. For families, the spot is child-friendly, though it does not have a dedicated kids' menu. Parking is limited with no valet service, but the central location makes it accessible by public transit.
- What are the restaurant's operating hours? Emmy Squared Pizza operates Monday to Friday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Saturday from 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
- Does the restaurant offer gluten-free options? Yes, Emmy Squared Pizza offers gluten-free options, including a gluten-free pizza crust.
- Is there outdoor seating available? Yes, the restaurant provides outdoor seating for guests.
- Can I make a reservation? Yes, reservations can be made through OpenTable.
- Does the restaurant accept credit cards? Yes, Emmy Squared Pizza accepts major credit cards, including AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Emmy Squared Pizza, a beloved establishment known for its distinct Detroit-style square pizzas with delectably crispy and cheesy edges, has made a notable mark on New York City's vibrant dining scene. Co-founded by Emily Hyland and executive chef Matthew Hyland, this pizzeria has become synonymous with inventive flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere that appeals to food enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
The journey of Emmy Squared began in 2016 with the opening of its first location in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. This initial foray introduced New Yorkers to their signature square pizzas inspired by Detroit's classic style, characterized by a fluffy yet crisp crust that boasts a caramelized cheese edge unique to this pizza variety. The Williamsburg location quickly gained popularity for its innovative approach to pizza, coupled with a menu that also included Italian sandwiches, an acclaimed signature burger named Le Big Matt, and a variety of fresh salads and indulgent desserts.
Building on the success of its Brooklyn origin, Emmy Squared expanded to Manhattan's East Village, setting up shop at 83 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10003. This location continues to celebrate the essence of Detroit-style pizza while enhancing the experience with its cozy brick-clad interior that perfectly complements the hearty, cheesy offerings. The East Village spot has become a go-to destination for locals and visitors craving a unique twist on classic pizza, alongside other menu highlights such as the Le Big Matt burger, an award-winning favorite among patrons.
Emmy Squared's commitment to culinary creativity is evident in its diverse menu, which extends beyond pizza to include Italian sandwiches and fresh salads, catering to a variety of tastes including vegetarian options. Their signature dish, the Le Big Matt burger, is a standout item praised for its bold flavors and satisfying portions. The East Village location also offers a full-service bar with a selection of craft beers and cocktails, enhancing the overall dining experience in a setting that blends comfort with urban chic.
- 2016 opening in Williamsburg Brooklyn - Emmy Squared Pizza launched its first location, introducing authentic Detroit-style square pizzas to the Williamsburg community.
- Expansion to East Village New York - The second location opened at 83 1st Ave., offering a welcoming brick-clad ambiance and the same beloved Detroit-style pizza along with other menu favorites.
Located at 83 1st Ave., New York, NY, Emmy Squared serves up Detroit-style square pizzas, Italian sandwiches, and a signature burger in a cozy, brick-clad setting. This unique eatery has garnered attention for its creative toppings and family-friendly atmosphere, making it a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
- Unique Detroit-style pizzas with crispy edges and creative toppings.
- Award-winning burgers like Le Big Matt.
- Gluten-free options available.
- Family-friendly environment.
- Outdoor seating available.
- Inconsistent service reported in some locations.
- Occasional delays in food and drink orders.
- Some locations may experience understaffing during peak hours.
Emmy Squared is perfect for families looking for a casual dining experience, friends gathering for a fun night out, or anyone craving unique pizza options. It's also a great spot for lunch breaks or casual dinners.
- Reservations are recommended during peak hours.
- Takeout and delivery options are available.
- Outdoor seating is available for a pleasant dining experience.
Emmy Squared offers a delightful dining experience with its unique take on Detroit-style pizza and a welcoming atmosphere. While there may be occasional service inconsistencies, the creative menu and family-friendly vibe make it a worthwhile visit. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just looking for a fun meal, Emmy Squared is a solid choice in New York City.
Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 83 1st Avenue, Emmy Squared is a vibrant spot that redefines pizza with its signature Detroit-style square pies. This culinary gem invites food lovers and trend-conscious travelers to indulge in fluffy deep-dish pizzas that boast irresistibly crispy, cheesy edges—delivering a mouthwatering experience far beyond your usual slice.
Emmy Squared takes pride in delivering a dynamic menu that satisfies diverse cravings. Beyond their iconic Detroit-style pizzas priced around $26.50, guests rave about the award-winning Le Big Matt burger. This standout features a juicy 1/2 lb double-stack of grass-fed beef crowned with American cheese, a zesty Sammy sauce, fresh greens, and pickles—all tucked inside a perfectly toasted pretzel bun for just $30.50.
If you're in the mood for sharable appetizers, the hand-breaded mozzarella sticks offer a crispy, cheesy delight paired with a signature red sauce, priced at $17.50. For a savory crunch, the seasoned waffle fries ($8.50) and cheesy garlic sticks served with spicy tomato sauce ($15.50) round out the menu with bold, satisfying flavors.
Set against a stylish brick-clad interior, Emmy Squared creates a welcoming atmosphere perfect for brunch, lunch, dinner, or a casual night out. The spot is well-equipped with outdoor seating options, kid-friendly amenities, and accommodates groups, making it ideal for social gatherings or family meals.
Beyond dine-in, the restaurant offers convenient takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup options. Guests can enjoy a curated selection of beers, wines, and handcrafted cocktails, perfectly complementing the robust flavors on the menu. Payment is hassle-free with credit, debit, and contactless NFC methods accepted.
Emmy Squared isn’t your traditional New York pizza joint. Known for its innovative spin on Detroit-style pies and a menu that balances hearty, indulgent options with thoughtfully crafted drinks, it has become a hotspot for foodies and locals seeking something fresh and exciting in the city’s dining scene.
- Signature Detroit-Style Square Pizzas – Fluffy, deep-dish crust with crispy, cheesy edges that deliver a unique texture and flavor combination.
- Award-Winning Le Big Matt Burger – A hearty double-stacked grass-fed beef burger with a zesty sauce and perfectly toasted pretzel bun.
- Diverse Menu Options – From cheesy garlic sticks to seasoned waffle fries, there’s something for every palate.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, Emmy Squared offers a memorable dining experience that combines inventive takes on classic favorites with a lively, approachable vibe. Perfect for brunch with friends, a casual dinner, or a hearty lunch, this spot should be on every pizza lover's New York checklist.
