hero image of Justino's Pizzeria
Justino's Pizzeria

New York, United States

Discover Justino's Pizzeria in Manhattan New York City New York 10019 USA Authentic New York style pizza and more at 879 9th Avenue with dine in takeout and delivery options open till late night a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 879 9th Avenue, Justino's Pizzeria offers a true slice of New York City's iconic pizza experience. This neighborhood gem has quickly become a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking the perfect balance of crisp crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese. Whether you're craving a quick slice after a show or a sit-down meal with friends, Justino's blends classic flavors with a welcoming atmosphere that's casual yet vibrant.

Menu highlights and dining experience

At Justino's Pizzeria, the pizza is the star of the show, featuring an extensive selection of pies from classic margherita to inventive specialty options. The crust strikes the perfect crispness that pizza lovers crave, complemented by well-seasoned toppings and fresh mozzarella. Beyond pizza, the menu includes hearty pastas and tempting desserts, catering to a variety of tastes. The staff are known for their friendly service, helping guests find just the right slice or dish to satisfy their appetite.
Dine-in, takeout, or delivery – Justino's Pizzeria makes enjoying authentic NYC pizza easy and convenient.

Community sentiment and what visitors say

Feedback from patrons reveals a community divided yet passionate. Many rave about the "top notch" quality of the pizzas and the generous portion sizes that make it a worthy stop for a meal in the city. The speedy service and variety of options delight families and pizza aficionados alike. Some guests note occasional inconsistencies in seasoning and service, but the welcoming vibe and value keep them coming back. The casual, no-frills setting ensures comfort for everyday dining or a quick bite after a night out.

Frequently asked questions about Justino's Pizzeria

  • What are the operating hours of Justino's Pizzeria? Justino's Pizzeria operates from 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM on weekdays, extending to 3:00 AM on Thursdays and Fridays, and closing at 11:00 PM on Sundays.
  • Does Justino's Pizzeria offer delivery and takeout services? Yes, Justino's Pizzeria provides both delivery and takeout services for customer convenience.
  • Is there outdoor seating available at Justino's Pizzeria? Yes, Justino's Pizzeria offers outdoor seating for patrons who prefer dining al fresco.
  • Does Justino's Pizzeria accept credit and debit cards? Yes, Justino's Pizzeria accepts various payment methods, including credit and debit cards, as well as mobile payment options like Apple Pay and Android Pay.
  • Is Justino's Pizzeria suitable for large groups? While Justino's Pizzeria offers ample seating, it may be more suitable for smaller groups due to its casual dining setup.

The story of Justino's Pizzeria

Justino's Pizzeria, established in 2000, was born from a vision to bring authentic Italian flavors to the vibrant streets of New York City. This family-owned establishment has become a beloved local favorite, known for its New York-style pizza and a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. The welcoming atmosphere invites both locals and visitors to enjoy a slice of tradition.

Milestones and growth

  • 2000: Justino's Pizzeria was established, aiming to bring authentic Italian flavors to New York City.
  • 2005: Expanded menu to include a variety of specialty pizzas and pasta dishes.
  • 2010: Introduced catering services to accommodate larger events and gatherings.
  • 2015: Renovated dining area to enhance customer experience with modern amenities.
  • 2020: Launched online ordering system for easier access to menu and services.

Cultural and local influence

Justino's Pizzeria has thrived in the heart of Manhattan, where the rich tapestry of cultures has influenced its menu and ambiance. The restaurant embraces the diverse culinary landscape of New York City, integrating local ingredients and flavors into its dishes. This commitment to community is evident in its welcoming atmosphere, where families and friends gather to share meals and create memories.

People behind the legacy

The heart and soul of Justino's Pizzeria lie in its founders, the Justino family, who have dedicated themselves to preserving the authenticity of Italian cuisine. Their passion for food and hospitality shines through in every dish, from the classic margherita pizza to the rich pasta dishes. The team, including skilled chefs and friendly staff, ensures that every guest feels like part of the family.

Evolution and modern era

Over the years, Justino's Pizzeria has adapted to the changing tastes and preferences of its patrons. The introduction of online ordering and catering services reflects its commitment to convenience and customer satisfaction. Despite these modern advancements, the restaurant remains true to its roots, continuing to serve the same beloved recipes that have delighted guests for over two decades.

Continuing the tradition

As Justino's Pizzeria looks to the future, it remains committed to its founding vision of providing authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. The legacy of the Justino family continues to thrive, ensuring that every visit is not just a meal, but a cherished experience. Join them at 879 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, for a taste of tradition and community.

Justino's Pizzeria Overview

Located at 879 9th Ave, New York, NY, Justino's Pizzeria is a vibrant eatery that captures the essence of classic New York-style pizza. Known for its generous portion sizes and authentic flavors, this pizzeria has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With late-night hours and a convenient location in Manhattan, it’s the perfect spot for a quick bite or a casual meal with friends.

Pros

  • Generous portion sizes
  • Authentic New York-style pizza
  • Late-night hours
  • Variety of menu options
  • Convenient location

Cons

  • Inconsistencies in food quality
  • Service can be slow during peak hours
  • Limited seating for large groups
  • Some patrons find the ambiance too casual

Ideal for

Justino's Pizzeria is perfect for casual dining, late-night cravings, and family outings. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice after a show or enjoying a meal with friends, this spot caters to all.

Things to know before visiting

Be prepared for potential wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends. The pizzeria offers takeout and delivery options, making it convenient for those on the go. Payment methods include credit and debit cards, and the atmosphere is casual, ideal for a relaxed dining experience.

Overall impression

Justino's Pizzeria stands out for its authentic New York-style pizza and welcoming atmosphere. While there are some inconsistencies in food quality and service during busy times, the overall experience is enjoyable. With its late-night hours and variety of menu options, it remains a go-to destination for pizza lovers in Manhattan.

Justino's pizzeria in new york city: authentic nyc pizza experience on 9th avenue

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan at 879 9th Avenue, Justino's Pizzeria offers a truly authentic New York City pizza experience that food lovers and locals rave about. Known for its perfectly crisp crusts, generous slices, and a variety of pizza options, this hidden gem is a must-visit spot for anyone craving classic NYC-style pizza with a flavorful twist.

menu highlights and unique flavors at justino's pizzeria

Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or crave adventurous toppings, Justino's extensive menu satisfies every pizza lover's craving. Guests praise the perfectly balanced flavors and the crispy yet tender crusts that define each slice. Pair your pizza with their pasta offerings or enjoy a glass of wine for a full Italian-inspired dining experience. Though the pasta marinara has received mixed reviews, the spotlight remains firmly on the pizza, which consistently earns rave remarks for taste and quality.

convenient dining options and family-friendly atmosphere

Justino's Pizzeria is ideal for families, foodies, and busy New Yorkers alike. It offers dine-in seating where you can savor fresh pizza in a relaxed setting, but also excels in providing fast and fresh delivery service straight to your door, perfect for digital nomads and on-the-go meals. Takeout options make it easy to grab a slice between errands or after a show at nearby Terminal 5. Plus, their catering service is a fantastic choice for events and gatherings, bringing the taste of authentic NYC pizza to your special occasion.

why justino's stands out in new york's pizza scene

Many visitors accidentally discover Justino's and quickly realize they've found one of the city's best kept pizza secrets. The friendly and helpful staff create a welcoming vibe, guiding even the pickiest eaters to delicious slices. While the venue doesn't offer outdoor seating or reservable tables, its efficient service and wallet-friendly pricing keep guests coming back. The pizzeria also embraces modern payment methods including contactless payments and credit or debit cards, enhancing convenience.
  • Delivery - Fast and fresh delivery service to your doorstep, ensuring hot, delicious pizza wherever you are.
  • Takeout - Convenient takeout options perfect for quick meals on the go or a casual bite after exploring the city.
  • Catering - Professional catering services that bring the flavor of authentic NYC pizza to your special events and gatherings.
If you’re craving an authentic slice of New York with a perfect balance of flavor, texture, and classic style, Justino's Pizzeria on 9th Avenue is the spot to visit. Whether you dine in, take out, or have your pizza delivered, this cozy, approachable eatery delivers consistent quality and satisfaction. It’s no wonder so many patrons declare it their favorite NYC pizza joint — and a place they’ll eagerly return to time and again.

Closed - Opens 10:00 AM

Monday

10:00–01:00

Tuesday

10:00–01:00

Wednesday

10:00–01:00

Thursday

10:00–03:00

Friday

10:00–04:00

Saturday

10:00–04:00

Sunday

10:00–23:00

Refresh your Nova Landing Page to drive a significant increase in traffic to your site.