Old Fashion Pizzeria
New York, United States
Old fashion pizzeria menu overview
Located in the heart of Manhattan, Old Fashion Pizzeria invites you to experience a classic New York neighborhood vibe paired with a diverse menu that celebrates traditional Italian-American comfort food. Whether you're craving a crispy thin crust or a thick Sicilian slice, this spot offers an array of flavorful pies crafted with passion and quality ingredients.
starters and appetizers
Kick off your meal with Old Fashion’s tempting starters that blend traditional flavors with hearty portions. From the garlicky allure of Garlic Knots and Garlic Bread, with options enhanced by melted cheese, to the flaky and savory Beef Patty – there's something for every palate. Fans of classic Italian fare will appreciate the variety of calzones stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, spinach, pepperoni, ham, or chicken, as well as the crispy Sausage and Pepper rolls and flavorful Pinwheels featuring pepperoni or spinach.
- Garlic Knots sprinkled with olive oil and herb seasoning, with or without cheese.
- Beef Patty flaky pastry filled with seasoned beef, available with cheese.
- Calzones and Rolls including Cheese, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach calzones and Chicken or Buffalo Chicken rolls with hot sauce and blue cheese.
main dishes and signature pizzas
The star feature at Old Fashion Pizzeria is its impressive selection of pizzas, ranging from timeless classics to inventive pies. Build your own cheese pizza or choose from specialty options like the Margherita Pie with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomatoes, or the indulgent Four Cheese Pie boasting a blend of fresh mozzarella, gorgonzola, fontina, and parmesan. For meat lovers, the Meat Lovers Pie and Supreme Pie deliver a satisfying mix of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and peppers.
- Grandma Pie thin crust topped with mozzarella, garlic, parmesan, and tomatoes for a crisp, flavorful bite.
- Penne Alla Vodka Pie a unique pizza featuring penne pasta tossed in rich vodka sauce.
- Buffalo Chicken Pie topped with spicy buffalo chicken and creamy mozzarella cheese.
Vegetarian options are thoughtfully prepared too, such as the Primavera Pie loaded with mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, onions, and peppers, and the White Pie with a blend of ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses. For those desiring a gluten-free crust, a Gluten Free Cheese Pizza is available, allowing everyone to enjoy the classic cheese experience.
desserts and beverages
While the menu emphasizes hearty Italian classics, quench your thirst with a selection of refreshing beverages including soda, Poland Spring water, and Snapple. These perfectly complement your meal, whether dining in or enjoying takeout.
specials and deli heroes
For a satisfying handheld meal, Old Fashion Pizzeria offers a variety of parmigiana heroes, such as the Chicken Cutlet, Meatball, and Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana Heroes, each layered with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese. These sandwiches capture the essence of Italian-American deli culture and make for a perfect lunch or dinner on the go.
Open Now - Closing 2:00 AM
Monday
12:00–23:30
Tuesday
12:00–23:30
Wednesday
12:00–23:30
Thursday
12:00–02:00
Friday
12:00–03:00
Saturday
12:00–03:00
Sunday
12:00–23:30
Aggregated Ratings 4.2
Loading map...
