Discover Scarr's Pizza: A New York Slice Sensation on Orchard Street

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan's vibrant Lower East Side at 35 Orchard Street, Scarr's Pizza stands out as a beloved destination for both locals and travelers craving an authentic New York slice experience. This pizzeria blends retro charm with modern culinary craftsmanship, delivering pies, slices, and subs made from high-quality, all-natural, and organic ingredients. Whether you're craving a classic thin and crispy slice or intrigued by innovative flavor combos, Scarr's offers a memorable bite in a warm, inviting atmosphere.

What Makes Scarr's Pizza a Must-Visit Spot

Scarr's Pizza is famed for its standout "Hot Boi" slice, a bold and flavorful creation featuring beef pepperoni, jalapeños, and a drizzle of hot honey that delivers a delightful spicy kick. This slice has quickly become a fan favorite and a signature offering that embodies the pizzeria's inventive spirit. Beyond this, the menu boasts both traditional and Sicilian slices, with vegan options clearly labeled, such as a Vegan Caesar Salad and vegan pizza – perfect for all dietary preferences.

Step inside to enjoy the retro-inspired decor, where a lively bar area and arcade games create a fun and welcoming vibe for groups, families, and solo diners alike. Whether you choose to dine in, take out, or have your favorite slices delivered, Scarr's commitment to quick, friendly service ensures a satisfying experience every time. Outdoor seating is available, making it a great spot to enjoy New York’s bustling street life with your furry friend, as Scarr's is dog-friendly in this area.

Community Buzz and Sentiment

The community’s sentiment toward Scarr's Pizza is overwhelmingly positive. Visitors praise the top-notch dough quality, the perfect balance of toppings, and the nostalgic ambiance that harks back to classic New York pizzerias. The fast service during peak times, coupled with the welcoming atmosphere and well-curated menu, make it a repeat favorite for many. While some note that Scarr's can get busy and seating a bit cozy, the overall experience keeps pizza lovers coming back for more.

Frequently Asked Questions about Scarr's Pizza

What are the operating hours of Scarr's Pizza? Scarr's Pizza operates from 12:00 PM to 12:00 AM on Sundays through Thursdays, and from 12:00 PM to 1:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Does Scarr's Pizza accept reservations? Yes, Scarr's Pizza accepts reservations through OpenTable.
Is there parking available near Scarr's Pizza? Street parking is available near Scarr's Pizza.
Does Scarr's Pizza offer vegan options? Yes, Scarr's Pizza offers vegan options, including a Vegan Caesar Salad and Vegan Pizza.
Is Scarr's Pizza dog-friendly? Yes, Scarr's Pizza is dog-friendly and allows dogs in their outdoor seating area.

The history of Scarr's Pizza

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan's Lower East Side, Scarr's Pizza has swiftly become a beloved staple for authentic New York-style pizza lovers since its inception. Founded in 2016 by Scarr Pimentel, this pizzeria distinguishes itself by milling its own flour fresh every day, a unique process that contributes to the exceptional texture and flavor of its crusts. The retro-inspired ambiance perfectly complements the traditional yet creative pies, drawing in a diverse crowd of locals and visitors alike.

Origins and growth

Scarr's Pizza first opened its doors at 22 Orchard Street in 2016, quickly gaining a reputation for quality slices that combined classic New York flavors with a modern twist. Scarr Pimentel’s dedication to crafting each pizza with care and authenticity helped the pizzeria stand out in a city teeming with pizza options. This commitment to quality and innovation cultivated a loyal following.

Expansion to accommodate popularity

By June 2023, the surging popularity of Scarr's Pizza prompted a relocation to a much larger space right across the street at 35 Orchard Street. This move allowed the pizzeria to better serve its growing clientele with more seating and enhanced dining comfort, all while preserving the welcoming, nostalgic vibe that regular patrons cherish. The expansion also helped solidify Scarr's presence in the competitive New York pizza scene as a must-visit destination.

Legacy and continued appeal

Today, Scarr's Pizza remains a vibrant fixture on Orchard Street, renowned for its perfectly thin, crispy crusts topped with inventive combinations, including the signature hot honey drizzle that has become a fan favorite. The retro decor invites guests to enjoy more than just a meal — it’s an experience that ties Manhattan’s rich pizza tradition to contemporary culinary trends. Whether grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a casual dine-in with friends, Scarr’s continues to capture the essence of New York’s pizza culture with every pie.

Founded by Scarr Pimentel in 2016 - Opened original location at 22 Orchard Street in Manhattan’s Lower East Side.
Relocated in 2023 - Moved to a larger venue at 35 Orchard Street to accommodate increasing popularity.

Discover Scarr's Pizza: Authentic New York Style With a Modern Twist

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 35 Orchard Street, Scarr's Pizza is a standout spot for pizza lovers craving an authentic New York slice crafted with modern, high-quality ingredients. This pizzeria features a retro-inspired decor that sets a lively and nostalgic vibe, appealing to both locals and visitors alike. Whether you're dining in their cozy space complete with arcade games or grabbing a quick takeout slice, Scarr's offers something special to the New York pizza scene.

Highlights of Scarr's Pizza

Scarr's Pizza is praised for its use of all-natural and organic ingredients which elevates the classic New York slice into a fresh and flavorful experience. The menu includes vegan and gluten-free options, making it an inclusive choice for diverse dietary preferences. Guests can enjoy their meal indoors or take advantage of the dog-friendly outdoor seating, perfect for those who want to bring their furry friends along. The venue also accepts reservations, which is a plus for groups or special occasions.

Authentic New York-style pizza made with all-natural and organic ingredients.
Retro-inspired decor that creates a unique and inviting atmosphere.
Vegan and gluten-free options cater to various dietary needs.
Dog-friendly outdoor seating allows guests to enjoy slices with their pets.
Accepts reservations easing planning for group visits.

Considerations When Visiting Scarr's Pizza

Despite its many strengths, Scarr's Pizza does have some drawbacks to keep in mind. The shop can experience long wait times during peak hours, which might test your patience if you're visiting at lunch or dinner rush. Indoor seating is somewhat limited, making it a bit crowded at times, and the prices are higher compared to other pizza joints in the area. If you're budget-conscious or prefer a quieter spot with more space, this might affect your experience.

Long wait times during peak hours can disrupt a quick meal plan.
Limited indoor seating may feel cramped during busy times.
Higher price point compared to some competitors might not suit all budgets.

In summary, Scarr's Pizza offers a delicious slice of New York with a memorable twist, ideal for those seeking quality ingredients and a lively atmosphere. While there are some challenges like wait times and seating constraints, the overall experience is rewarding for pizza enthusiasts willing to embrace a trendy spot in the bustling Lower East Side.

4.3