Village Square Pizza Menu Overview

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Manhattan at 147 Avenue A, Village Square Pizza invites pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike to indulge in a distinct New York-style pizzeria experience. Known for its snug neighborhood counter-serve vibe, this spot excels in serving both square and round pizza slices or whole pies that perfectly balance crispiness with chewy, flavorful crusts.

Starters

Begin your meal with perfectly baked Garlic Knots infused with fragrant garlic and olive oil, or upgrade to Cheesy Garlic Knots for an extra layer of melty delight. For something heartier, the Calzone offers a delightful dough pocket packed with ricotta, mozzarella, and egg, while the Pepperoni Calzone adds a savory twist with spicy pepperoni. Complement your starters with signature dipping sauces like the creamy Ranch Dressing, the zesty Vodka Sauce made with tomatoes and cream, or the sweet-spicy Hot Honey Cup.

Mains - Signature Pizzas

Village Square Pizza offers an impressive selection of gourmet New York-style pizzas, crafted with fresh ingredients and their cherished family recipe tomato sauce. The Classic Pizza boasts whole milk mozzarella and grated parmesan, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil for a timeless taste.

For lovers of fresh, vibrant flavors, the Margherita Pizza combines fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil, while the Grandma Pizza adds a homemade pesto twist alongside parmesan cheese. The White Square Pizza indulges with whipped ricotta and a touch of premium honey, delivering a luscious balance of creamy and sweet.

Explore bold flavor profiles with the Vodka Square Pizza, featuring a rich vodka sauce blended with fresh mozzarella and parmesan, or the Marinara Square Pizza that highlights marinara sauce with cheese and olive oil. The Classic Sicilian Pizza offers thick crust satisfaction loaded with mozzarella and their signature tomato sauce.

Vegetarian and vegan diners will appreciate the Bruschetta Pizza with fresh tomatoes, red onions, and basil on a golden garlic crust, as well as the Vegan Square Pizza topped with roasted mushrooms, peppers, and onions. The Eggplant Square Pizza combines fried eggplant, hand-crushed tomatoes, and fresh basil for a hearty plant-based option.

Meat lovers are in for a treat with the Pepperoni Square Pizza, loaded with spicy pepperoni and fra diavolo sauce, or the Buffalo Chicken Pizza featuring premium chicken and Frank’s hot sauce. The Sausage and Peppers Pizza pairs sweet sausage with roasted peppers and onions, while the True Meat Lovers Pizza tantalizes with mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, and crispy bacon.

For those who love variety, the Half & Half Pepperoni Pizza combines spicy pepperoni with your choice of classic or innovative options, and the Half & Half Pizza offers a custom blend of favorites like white, vodka, or vegan toppings. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza rounds out the menu with a creamy ranch dressing layered over mozzarella, premium chicken, and crispy bacon.

Drinks

Complement your pizza with a range of non-alcoholic beverages, including classic sodas like Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, and Fanta Orange, alongside refreshing options such as ginger ale, seltzer water, Powerade, and still water. These drinks perfectly balance the bold flavors of the menu.

Experience Highlights

Authentic New York-style pizza: Both thick and thin crust options with crispy yet chewy textures and rich flavor profiles.
Diverse vegan and vegetarian options: Including vegan squares and bruschetta pizza, catering to plant-based palates with fresh, wholesome ingredients.
Convenient takeout and dine-in: Ideal for grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a casual sit-down meal with outdoor seating available.
Family-friendly environment: Welcoming atmosphere suitable for all ages, perfect for casual group dining or solo pizza indulgence.