
New York Pizzeria
New Berlin, United States
New York Pizzeria Menu Overview
Discover the authentic flavors of New York right in the heart of New Berlin at New York Pizzeria. This family-owned gem offers a delicious variety of Italian dishes crafted with care and quality ingredients, perfect for food lovers seeking genuine New York-style pizza and classic Italian mains.
starters
Begin your meal with irresistible appetizers that set the tone for a memorable dining experience. The Garlic Bread with Cheese combines crunchy bread with a savory garlic and melted cheese topping. For those craving a bit of spice, the Boneless Buffalo Wings are coated in a tangy buffalo sauce, delivering a perfect kick. Classic Mozzarella Sticks, breaded and fried to golden perfection, come with a rich marinara sauce that makes every bite delightful.
mains
The star of the menu is undoubtedly the iconic New York-Style Pizza, featuring a hand-tossed dough base, rich tomato sauce, and generous layers of mozzarella cheese baked to perfection with a crisp crust that echoes the classic flavors of NYC. Beyond pizza, the mains offer a range of hearty Italian favorites.
- Chicken Saltimbocca – tender chicken breast wrapped with prosciutto and sage, simmered in a delicate white wine sauce.
- Chicken Florentine – juicy chicken breast sautéed with garlic and fresh spinach in a creamy sauce, offering rich and comforting flavors.
- Eggplant Parmesan – slices of breaded eggplant layered with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese baked until bubbly and golden.
- Chicken Marsala – a flavorful dish with chicken breast cooked in savory Marsala wine and mushrooms, a true Italian classic.
- Chicken Riggies – a spicy delight featuring chicken breast with rigatoni pasta, hot peppers, and creamy sauce for those who love a little heat.
- Shrimp Alfredo – succulent shrimp served over fettuccine pasta slathered in a rich and creamy Alfredo sauce, a seafood lover's dream.
desserts and drinks
While the menu is centered around savory Italian cuisine, New York Pizzeria also offers a selection of desserts and beverages to complement your meal. Enjoy a freshly brewed coffee or choose from a variety of sodas and wines to accompany your dining experience. Please note, hot drinks such as hot chocolate are not available, but the friendly service and warm atmosphere more than make up for it.
special features
This pizzeria is known for its family-operated charm and exceptional customer care, ensuring every visitor feels like part of the family. The generous portions, authentic recipes, and quality ingredients combine to create a truly memorable dining experience. Whether you are stopping by for a quick slice of pizza or settling in for a full Italian feast, New York Pizzeria delivers genuine taste and warm hospitality.
Open Now - Closing 9:00 PM
Monday
10:30–21:00
Tuesday
10:30–21:00
Wednesday
10:30–21:00
Thursday
10:30–21:00
Friday
10:30–21:00
Saturday
10:30–21:00
Sunday
10:30–21:00
Aggregated Ratings 4.6
Loading map...