Carnegie Pizza menu overview New York Times Square authentic style cooking food dining experience selection ingredients specialties place quality taste crust cheese sauce chicken pepperoni basil onions cilantro garlic knots starters mains desserts drinks specials atmosphere seating service location city state country United States 200 West 41st Street Manhattan New York NY 10036 10036 US address street number route sublocality level 1 sublocality political county administrative area level 2 political administrative area level 1 political political establishment point of interest restaurant food pizza cuisine finger food variety meats vegetables vegetarian options kids friendly family dining quick serve reheat delicious original classic signature crowd pleasing seating limited dine in outdoor curbside pickup delivery takeout reservable payment options nfc debit credit cards cash only no nodiscount live music no good for watching sports no parking paid parking lot beer served wine not available lunch dinner dessert available great reviews highly rated recommended chef special house favorite culinary experience hidden gem lines wait time fast service quality consistency texture thickness chew flavor satisfaction loyal clientele tourist local fast casual casual dining experience authentic New York style pizza slice slice lovers crowd pleaser fast bite quick lunch dinner choices fun foodies nomads travelers visitors locals hidden gem excellent quality value prices fair reasonable affordable tasty pizza lovers family friends groups couple solo dining party casual hangout bright cozy inviting vibe ambience friendly staff quick turnaround limited seating standing counters small tables back area atmosphere lively comfortable efficient customer focused food quality outstanding distinctive unique popular place hidden spot best pizza Midtown Manhattan Times Square area appetizing flavorful mouth watering fresh ingredients creative topping combos exceptional quality crust thin crispy fresh cheesy flavorful margherita buffalo chicken bbq chicken spicy pepperoni variety topping options mozzarella cheese blue cheese dressing red onions garlic butter parsley herbs freshly prepared pizza dough pizza dough preparation method traditional style wood fire oven classic recipes modern taste preferences something for everyone eat in take out quick casual dining experience must try must visit recommended place slice experience visit New York City culinary delights pizza market culinary scene food culture street food favorite spot meat toppings vegetable toppings finger foods kids menu vegetarian friendly suitable families dining options drinks beer served no wine menu overview detailed comprehensive appetizing inviting selection meal options full course dining casual snack food lovers pizza enthusiasts busy time day lunch dinner snack quick meal spot burger sandwich alternative pizza places quality food service speed convenience best choice near Times Square tourist attraction nearby venues comfortable seating options outdoor seating curbside pickup delivery available payment methods nfc debit credit cards no cash only friendly professional efficient staff clean hygiene standards fast turnaround delightful visit recommended eatery pizza joint must visit spot foodie guide top picks local favorite food blog reviews customer testimonials positive feedback culinary excellence commitment fresh quality ingredients presentation consistent taste safe hygienic environment overall wonderful dining experience

Located in the heart of Manhattan at 200 West 41st Street, Carnegie Pizza delivers a truly authentic New York-style pizza experience that satisfies both locals and visitors alike. This humble yet vibrant pizzeria is renowned for its perfectly crispy and fresh crust, thin yet substantial enough to support a rich layering of high-quality mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and fragrant basil. The menu showcases a delightful variety of toppings, from classic Margherita to bold Buffalo Chicken and smoky BBQ Chicken, each slice promising a flavorful journey with every bite.

Starters and mains at carnegie pizza new york times square location fresh ingredients quality service fast casual dining friendly atmosphere family friendly vegetarian options kids menu finger foods garlic knots classic appetizer signature sides perfect complement pizza crust fresh herbs butter garlic parsley delicious crispy golden bites quick start meal choice casual dining experience

Begin your meal with their irresistible Garlic Knots, made from freshly prepared pizza dough baked to golden perfection, then tossed in a luscious blend of garlic, butter, and parsley. These finger-friendly starters are a perfect prelude to the main event and highlight the kitchen’s dedication to fresh, flavorful ingredients.

Main pizzas a variety of toppings from classic to bold combinations margherita buffalo chicken bbq chicken spicy pepperoni mozzarella cheese tomato sauce blue cheese dressing red onions cilantro authentic new york style signature slices crowd favorites casual dining quick serve reheat fresh crispy crust consistent quality taste

Carnegie Pizza’s mains are the stars of the show, boasting an array of expertly crafted pies that cater to a wide range of palates. The Margherita Pizza stands out with its delicate balance of tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil, delivering a timeless flavor beloved by pizza purists. For those craving a little kick, the Spicy Pepperoni Pizza features spicy pepperoni layered over mozzarella and rich tomato sauce, creating a harmonious blend of heat and savoriness.

The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a crowd-pleaser, generously topped with tender buffalo chicken, creamy mozzarella, and drizzled with blue cheese dressing for a bold and satisfying taste. Meanwhile, the BBQ Chicken Pizza offers a smoky, tangy twist with BBQ chicken, mozzarella, red onions, and fresh cilantro, delivering complex layers of flavor that surprise and delight. Each pizza is quickly reheated to ensure freshness and served with a crust that achieves the perfect texture—crispy on the outside, chewy inside, making every bite unforgettable.

Desserts drinks and specials comfortable seating dine in outdoor curbside pickup delivery quick service payment options nfc debit credit cards family friendly good for children no live music atmosphere casual inviting great location times square midtown manhattan

Although Carnegie Pizza’s menu focuses primarily on their signature pizza offerings and savory starters, they also provide dessert options and refreshing drinks to complete your dining experience. The venue offers comfortable seating with limited indoor tables alongside outdoor seating, perfect for savoring your meal in the bustling atmosphere of Midtown Manhattan. For convenience, patrons can choose from dine-in, curbside pickup, delivery, or takeout services. The restaurant accepts various payment methods, including NFC, debit, and credit cards, making your visit hassle-free.

Why choose Carnegie Pizza - Authentic New York-style pizza with a crispy, fresh crust and flavorful toppings made from high-quality ingredients.
Menu variety - From classic Margherita to bold Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken pizzas, plus delicious starters like Garlic Knots.
Convenient dining options - Dine in with limited seating, outdoor seating available, curbside pickup, delivery, and quick takeout.
Family friendly - Suitable for children with a dedicated kids menu and welcoming atmosphere.