
SELECTED RESTAURANT
New York, United States
Penny Menu Overview
Nestled in the heart of New York City, Penny offers a refined seafood dining experience that tantalizes the taste buds with fresh, expertly curated dishes. This exquisite menu is a celebration of oceanic flavors, paired with carefully crafted desserts and an impressive wine selection, making it a perfect destination for seafood aficionados and discerning diners alike.
Starters
Begin your culinary journey with Penny’s vibrant starters, where delicate seafood meets bold seasoning and creative preparation.
- Sesame Brioche with Butter and Anchovies – Melt-in-your-mouth sesame brioche paired with creamy butter and rich anchovies for a briny, buttery start.
- Oyster Confit – Plump oysters slow-cooked in chicken fat, enriched with crème fraîche and accompanied by spiced crackers that add texture and warmth.
- Tuna Carpaccio – Thinly sliced tuna dressed with olive oil, onion, and olives to awaken your palate with fresh, Mediterranean-inspired notes.
- Octopus Potato Salad – Tender octopus combined with potatoes and vinaigrette brings a refreshing yet hearty start to your meal.
Mains
Penny’s mains showcase an exquisite range of seafood specialties, each dish highlighting fresh ingredients and sophisticated flavor pairings.
- Ice Box – A chilled bounty featuring oysters, clams, shrimp, mussels, and crab salad, perfect for seafood lovers seeking variety and freshness.
- Ice Box Plus – An indulgent expansion of the Ice Box with seasonal crudo, periwinkles, vichyssoise, and a touch of caviar for elevated taste.
- Stuffed Squid – Squid filled with swiss chard and tuna, enhanced by a spicy harissa kick, crafting a balanced blend of flavors and textures.
- Oyster Pan Roast – Oysters baked with vegetables and broth, enveloped in flaky puff pastry, offering a comforting yet elegant dish.
- Dover Sole with Bone Marrow – Delicate Dover sole paired with rich bone marrow, bordelaise sauce and shimeji mushrooms for a sophisticated delight.
- Cod with Clams – Fresh cod complemented by clams and braised scallions in a rich broth, perfect for those craving a hearty seafood entree.
Desserts
Complement your meal with Penny’s thoughtfully crafted desserts that provide a sweet finish without overpowering your palate.
- Chocolate Mousse – Decadent chocolate mousse with creamy texture and crunchy hazelnut pieces for a rich, satisfying treat.
- Ice Cream Sandwich – A luscious vanilla ice cream sandwiched between buttery brioche and strawberry jam, combining creamy and fruity flavors.
Drinks and Specials
Penny pairs its fresh seafood with a curated wine list featuring standout selections like white wines from Portugal, alongside expertly mixed cocktails that enhance the dining experience. Seasonal specials highlight the freshest catches and creative preparations, with some dishes intentionally limited each evening to ensure premium quality and exclusivity.
Note that many dishes sell out quickly, so reservations and early dining times are recommended to enjoy the full array of offerings.
Closed - Opens 5:00 PM
Monday
17:00–22:30
Tuesday
17:00–22:30
Wednesday
17:00–22:30
Thursday
17:00–22:30
Friday
17:00–22:30
Saturday
17:00–22:30
Sunday
17:00–22:30
Aggregated Ratings 4.6
Loading map...
Gallery



See all images