Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co Menu Overview

Nestled on Amsterdam Avenue in vibrant Manhattan, Sliced by Harlem Pizza Co offers a delightful journey through classic and innovative pizza creations alongside fresh salads, tempting starters, and satisfying desserts. This neighborhood gem combines local ingredients with bold flavors to craft an unforgettable dining experience for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike.

Starters to whet your appetite

Begin your meal with perfectly seasoned Buffalo Wings drenched in tangy buffalo sauce or savor the crispy Chicken Tenders, a classic comfort food staple. For a garlicky twist, the Garlic Knots made from fresh pizza dough, butter, and garlic offer a warm, aromatic start. If you prefer something lighter, the House Salad bursts with baby spinach, carrots, quinoa, red peppers, and scallions tossed in a ginger sesame dressing. Variations include the addition of cheese or protein toppings such as chicken, meatballs, or pepperoni, allowing you to customize your greens just the way you like.

Mains: Pizza perfection

The heart of the menu is its exceptional pizzas, crafted with a robust tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and sharp pecorino cheese, all baked on either a traditional or gluten-conscious cauliflower crust. Fans of classic flavors will appreciate the timeless Classic Cheese Pizza or venture into the Four Cheese Pizza, which adds ricotta and gorgonzola for a rich, layered cheese experience. Specialty pies like the Truffle Mushroom Pizza, topped with mixed roasted mushrooms and truffle porcini sauce, or the Buffalo Chicken Pizza featuring blue cheese and breaded chicken with a spicy hot sauce kick, showcase the kitchen's creative flair.

Meat lovers can indulge in options like the Pepperoni Pizza, Pancetta and Black Garlic, Sujuk and Beef Sausage, Meatball Pizza with smoked mozzarella, or the Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza blending smoky bacon and savory ranch dressing. Vegetarians are not left behind with the Vegetable Supreme Pizza, boasting broccoli, red peppers, olives, and mushrooms, or the Ricotta and Fresh Tomato Pizza, enhanced with fresh garlic, basil, and a drizzle of EVOO. For those who prefer a lighter crust, the cauliflower crust versions of these favorites maintain all the flavor with a health-conscious twist.

Desserts and sweet treats

Complete your meal with housemade cookies crafted for a perfect balance of sweetness and texture. Choose between the Dark Chocolate Chip Cookie with a hint of sea salt or the Oatmeal Cookie studded with fresh blueberries and crunchy pecans, both freshly baked and perfect for sharing or savoring solo.

Beverages to refresh

Soda - classic carbonated water with sweeteners to quench your thirst
Montauk Premium Iced Tea - refreshing iced tea with a touch of sweetness
Boylan - a flavorful carbonated beverage for a classic soda experience
Essential Water - pure and crisp water for hydration
Hal’s Sparkling - bubbly sparkling water to refresh your palate
Spindrift - sparkling water infused with natural fruit juice for a flavorful twist
Sparkling Ice - sweetened sparkling water with a variety of refreshing flavors