New York Pizza & Pasta Menu Overview

Discover the authentic flavors of New York-style pizza and classic Italian-American dishes at New York Pizza & Pasta, located in Indian Trail, North Carolina. This cozy eatery offers a vibrant menu featuring an array of carefully crafted pizzas, hearty starters, and satisfying salads, perfect for food lovers seeking a true taste of Italian comfort food.

Starters

Kick off your meal with a delicious selection of starters designed to excite your palate. From the soft, garlicky Garlic Knots to the crispy Mozzarella Sticks and golden Fried Mushrooms, each appetizer is a perfect introduction to the meal ahead. The Combination Platter offers a generous mix including Chicken Tenders, Stuffed Jalapenos, Onion Rings, and Marinara Sauce — great for sharing with friends or family.

Garlic Bread with Cheese: Garlic bread topped with melted mozzarella for a cheesy twist.
Garlic Knots: Soft, garlicky bread knots that are irresistibly delightful.
Mozzarella Sticks: Crunchy battered mozzarella sticks, perfect for cheese lovers.
Combination Platter: A shareable delight with chicken tenders, stuffed jalapenos, mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, and onion rings served with marinara.

Mains

The heart of the menu lies in its sumptuous pizzas, baked to perfection with fresh ingredients and rich flavors. Whether you crave the iconic Pepperoni Pizza with mozzarella, burrata cheese, basil, and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey, or the creamy Vodka Fresh Mozzarella Pizza topped with basil and Parmigiano-Reggiano, there’s a slice to satisfy every craving. For a white pizza lover, the NYPP White Pizza blends mozzarella, ricotta, provolone, and parmesan without sauce, highlighting the cheese's richness.

Explore specialty choices like Tony's Pizza featuring grilled chicken and bacon on an Alfredo sauce base, or the zesty Chicken Buffalo and Chicken BBQ Pizzas with your choice of grilled or fried chicken. Seafood enthusiasts will appreciate the Seafood Pizza loaded with clams, calamari, shrimp, and a choice of red or white wine sauce, or the spicy Seafood Fra Diavolo with a fiery marinara sauce.

Pepperoni Pizza: Classic pepperoni with rich mozzarella and burrata cheeses, fresh basil, and a hint of Mike’s Hot Honey.
Vodka Fresh Mozzarella Pizza: Creamy vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella and aromatic basil.
NYPP White Pizza: A rich combination of mozzarella, ricotta, provolone, and parmesan cheeses without sauce.
Tony's Pizza: Grilled chicken and bacon served over a creamy Alfredo sauce.

Other favorites include the classic Margherita Pizza, the hearty Meat Lover’s and Deluxe Pizzas loaded with a variety of meats and vegetables, and the popular Grandma's 16-inch thin square pizza with garlic and basil. For those who prefer no sauce, the New York Cheesesteak or Chicken Cheesesteak Pizzas offer a savory combination of American and mozzarella cheeses with sautéed onions, peppers, and mushrooms.

Salads

Complement your main course with fresh salads that bring garden-fresh vegetables and vibrant flavors to the table. Choose from the crisp Garden Salad, the savory Greek Salad with feta cheese, or the protein-packed Grilled Chicken Salad featuring marinated chicken and cheese. The Chef's Salad combines ham, turkey, provolone cheese, and hard-boiled eggs for a hearty option.

Desserts and Drinks

While the menu highlights savory Italian-American classics, the restaurant also offers desserts and a selection of drinks including beer, wine, and coffee to round out your dining experience. These options provide the perfect finish or refreshment to accompany your meal.

Specialties and Signature Flavors

New York Pizza & Pasta is renowned for its dedication to classic New York flavors infused with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Dishes like the Chicken Parmesan, praised for its crispy, juicy texture and perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio, and the Stromboli packed with fresh fillings baked to perfection, showcase the kitchen's mastery of Italian-American cuisine. The garlic knots, soft and garlicky, are an addictive starter beloved by regulars.

Chicken Parmesan: Crispy and juicy with a perfect balance of sauce and melted cheese.
Stromboli: A baked delight packed with fresh ingredients that capture traditional Italian flavors.
Garlic Knots: Soft, garlicky, and impossible to stop eating — a beloved classic starter.

4.0

624 Indian Trail Road South, Indian Trail, NC 28079, USA

(704) 821-6000

Closed - Opens 11:00 AM

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

11:00–14:00

Wednesday

11:00–20:30

Thursday

11:00–20:30